Comments on: So You Think You Can Dance – Should Pania Have Been Eliminated?

By: katef

katef — Wed, 11 Mar 2009 11:36:07 +0000

Penny drives me bonkers… something about her really annoys me.. though I don’t mind her when she is dancing. Was a bit surprised that they picked Pania over Lamb… not sure that was the right decision.

By: Reality Raver

Reality Raver — Mon, 09 Mar 2009 11:34:12 +0000

Notmensa – Agree re: Penny I don’t know why the judges keep on giving her the love. I will be interesting to see what happens to her once it is a voting free for all in the top 10. Methinks she will be gone.
Charlie is very popular and appears to be very nice. Reminds me a bit of Jack. Will we have a similar winner this year? I hope not.
The pole dancer moves were interesting. If you live in Sydney I think their is a pole dancing school in Stanmore. Personally I think I would fall and hit my head.

By: Reality Raver

Reality Raver — Mon, 09 Mar 2009 11:23:13 +0000

Agree when I saw the bottom three couples I thought easy Lamb and Damien. But was shocked about Pania. They did not really give a reason, apart from Lamb showing versatility even if she was ordinary. Whoops I forgot to mention the prize of the winner dancing on the US SYTYCD show. What an opportunity.

By: notmensa

notmensa — Mon, 09 Mar 2009 11:22:29 +0000

The judges did say that they were disappointed with the DFYL solos that didn’t show anything new. Guess it would’ve been hypocritical for them to get rid of Pania & Ben who had taken that on board. (Not that it’s stopped them before.) And dammit, until Dubbo stops voting en masse for Charlie we’ll keep seeing Hot Mess Penny (HMP?).

On the upside, the delightful Amy is now paired with the understated Ben.

I didn’t watch Macy, I was trying to see the pole dancers who were dudded out of a feature show. How do they do that?!

By: Anonymous

Anonymous — Mon, 09 Mar 2009 11:12:37 +0000

Eh, I reckon Talia and Loredo have way more charisma/talent than Amy and Ben. How well they are received depends on what choreography they receive. Now that the two routines each thing happens next week, it will be even more absurd if Talia and Loredo don’t get Contemporary/Lyrical.

Am I alone in not liking Amy that much? Not impressed with her solo tonight. She’s like cookie-cutter Contemporary to me. She gets compared to Kate a lot, but I think Kate was more fabulous – a true chameleon for all styles.

I’m pissed off that Pania was eliminated. Totally bogus. She was sacrificed so the judges could give their precious favourite dancer a stronger partner. Totally lame.