for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Masterchef Australia – There Are Eight Deadly Sins If You Add In Channel Ten’s Editing

Again the Masterchef Australia editing was the equivalent of a deflated souffle with the producer’s not showing the judging of Adam’s invention test dish. This follows on from the fact that regular commenter Little Petal on the Spoiler thread, had said the preview for tonight’s episode showed Claire had won tonight’s mystery box. Considering there had been that clanger in the Thursday night’s episode, I would have thought someone might have double checked the preview ads….

Tonight was the mystery box to win, as it meant they bypassed the invention test, and therefore only have to dodge Wednesday night’s bullet and then they are into the final week of the competition. Unless of course Claire manages to win the Celebrity Chef challenge on Tuesday night then she will have the final immunity pin, which can only be used in this week’s elimination.

It was a big prize for 30 minutes of cooking.

The mystery box had pandan leaf, prawns, banana, chilli, basil and pancetta.

Jimmy said he wanted to show the judges that he could cook something different, but he couldn’t with his croquembouche with basil sauce, stuck together with honey. I am still not sure whether it was meant to be a appetiser or dessert. Callum’s prawn dish with the soup was too salty showing once again that if it is not a dessert he is a out of his depth.

Courtney and Claire were judged to be the top two dishes, with both doing a variation of prawns. Claire who is peaking at the right time dished showed slightly more sophistication, technique and flavour than Courtney’s.

In the invention test each contestant had to select one of the seven deadly sins and incorporate that theme into their dish.

This challenge was very similar to one they had on Top Chef Los Angles where the seven deadly sins had to be incorporated into the dishes of a seven course meal. Personally I don’t have problem of ripping off the Top Chef challenges, but I do wish someone would do an Australian version of this show.

Claire had the power to select who got to pick their sin first. She picked Courtney first, who chose envy but really had nothing in mind and wandered around the pantry for 15 minutes.

She picked Jonathan second last, which he took as a sign that Claire saw him as a threat, and she did not want him to be there for the final week, not that she just did not like him.

Jimmy was picked last and was left with sloth, and to be honest I don’t know why he didn’t just replate his croquembouche from the mystery box. Seriously it is a travesty that he is still there and not Marion.

Callum picked gluttony and made a chocolate dessert, which the judges really loved, however it depresses me that he has made it this far without making many first rate savoury dishes.

Aaron did a world first and merged Italian and Mexican cuisines to make mole ravioli, Matt Preston said it fulfilled the theme of pride due to him having the arrogance to think he could pull it off, however he did not mention flavour. He did mention the ravioli was undercooked.  I did laugh when Aaron was explaining his dish to George Calombaris when he was cooking it. George looked horrified and said “Aahh good luck” and scampered away.

Courtney’s sweet and sour trout salad, and lemon and lime cheesecake was thought to not show enough technique. However Alvin’s take on greed looked delicious with a bowl of caramelised pork belly served with rice, and Gary Mehigan was in raptures.

Jonathan’s dessert of meringue, strawberry sorbet and white chocolate mousse had not set so was a disaster, and he did not get time to plate it and left the paper still wrapped around it. It was meant to represent lust, and the closest it got was representing the end product of this sin.

Gary Mehigan thought the presentation is a disaster, but thought the flavours were stunning.  Whilst  Matt Preston gave him a dressing down saying “This is not the first time you have failed to deliver, do it once is an aberration, but to do it twice we start to question your ability to organise yourself in the kitchen.”

WTF? What does he say to Jimmy, Aaron, and Callum who have stuffed up four, five and six times? Or are people judged at different standards?

And of course we did not get to see Adam’s “Angry Chicken” which was meant to show wrath.

Jimmy  way of representing sloth was making curry croquettes, but he burnt the curry sauce, he then turned them into Australian/Indian rissoles. The dish was an embarrassment as was the judges trying to do some sort of pantomime by bringing out a sofa and pretending to be slothful. I thought George Calombaris was being kind when he said ”Regardless of theme the food has got to have some heart and soul” .

It was no surprise that Jimmy was in the bottom three, nor really was it surprising Jonathan was there as well. But Courtney appeared to be there because she showed lack of technique. I thought they were meant to be judging on flavour.

Hopefully Jimmy will go tomorrow night, if Jonathan goes this will mean another of the better cooks will be out of the competition.

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • email
  • MySpace

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

Related Posts

58 comments

1 Wurstsemmel { 07.12.10 at 12:05 am }

I thought Johnathan’s dish wasa standout representation of the aftermath of the deadly sin Lust. Looked just like a bad skin outbreak in the STD version of a medical book

2 Cravatwatch { 07.12.10 at 12:14 am }

There’s no way Jimmy can continue tomorrow. His technique is all over the place, his one-note gimmick is wearing thin and, most importantly of all, he just doesn’t make good tv.

3 Fides { 07.12.10 at 12:16 am }

I was an angry bird not to get to see the tasting of Adam’s “angry bird”. Perhaps that was the point… Seriously though, it’s just insulting to viewers – this year’s Sunday night episodes have been the worst. It’s all about the story … too much on Jimmy’s croquembouche , George having a lie down and judges spoonfeeding Callum that who cares that one week before the finals, they still can’t show everyone’s dishes at tasting?! I’ll cross my fingers it will be sorted by next week, but I won’t get my hopes up.

And you could pick the bottom three, or at least two of the bottom three, within about five minutes of the challenge beginning. Jono can lose it with his disorganisation sometimes (actually, that’s twice in two weeks) but he needn’t worry despite what Matt said – has Matt forgotten that Julie served raw ling to Matt Moran, and did not even plate up all the components of her dishes in the Donna Hay challenge in the final week last year?

4 AnonyMousse { 07.12.10 at 12:27 am }

Most of the sins would seem to be hard to actually translate to food without relying on cliches (ie chilli/red for wrath). Alvin’s dish seemed to show greed more through the size of the bowls than in their actual content, for example. I’d of been stuck in the pantry for 15 minutes if I had a sin like envy as well, unless maybe I cooked something green.

5 Reality Raver { 07.12.10 at 12:31 am }

Wurstsemmel – Laughed my head off at your comment.

Cravatwatch – it is gone from comedic to tragic the Jimmy situation, has he cooked anything good since his returned. He needs to vote himself off now, otherwise noone is going to buy his curry sauces.

Fides – I had forgotten the raw ling incident.

Anonymouse – the irony was she was the first one to pick, personally I would have gone for gluttony.

6 AnonyMousse { 07.12.10 at 12:40 am }

Yes, poor Jimmy – his reputation would have been better off if he’d not come back. I sat there when he was explaining why he was making his dish, thinking ‘making a dish they’ve done on Masterchef doesn’t show you can do different things, it just shows you’re derivitive’. I definitely had more respect for his cooking abilities before he came back – I actually felt embarassed by proxy for him for the dishes he made tonight.

Now that I think back on it Callum’s idea (that you’d eat it all but regret it) was the one that rung most true to the 7 sins idea.

7 Wurstsemmel { 07.12.10 at 12:44 am }

Shame Claire didn’t participate, lust sounds like it might be right up her street. Kate, queen of the microwave, could have run up a good sloth effort. Matt should have taste tested greed.

What tonight makes crystal clear is that one trick ponies such as Callum and Jimmy should have been gone and stayed home long ago

8 hine { 07.12.10 at 12:47 am }

Sloth seems to suit Jimmy. After all he was driven whilst the others walked in the army challenge and always cooks curries, quite lazy indeed. Shame Aaron isn’t in the bottom 3 and hope Jimmy goes.
With the puddle pie Jon is surely goiing to be this years winner?

9 CG { 07.12.10 at 12:57 am }

Anonymouse, agree Jimmy is just embarassing and cannibalising his post-MC brand. He has got to go, for his own sake as well as ours.

“Envy” could have been easy: green and sour – a nice lime cheesecake would have done the trick? or how about a margarita based dessert?

Don’t know why Courtney got so caught up in the “story” she had to tell to justify her dish: judges didn’t seem to care – cook what you know you can cook and retrofit the story I reckon. Aaron is expert at this.

Alvin’s schtick is starting to get on my nerves. I think he is being coached to put cutesy “my mum used to cook..”, “my auntie used to cook..” and/or childhood in Asia and new immigrant to Australia stories behind all his dishes. I reckon he is being coached. Will make a good schtick for his inevitable post-MC book. Very similar to Poh’s schtick without the sexy (unless I guess you consider the target audience for Alvin’s men in uniform comments the other day?).

If Courtney is eliminated tomorrow night then Claire is the only female left in the group. I think she is the type of woman that thrives in a near-all-male environment and will play the “lone female” to full advantage. I also think she will win the celebrity cook-off on Tuesday and get a bye to finals week.

10 hine { 07.12.10 at 1:07 am }

This is a great site by the way. I was wondering if anyone else thought George was pulling a lot of faces today(liked he could smell poop in someones pants)?

11 hine { 07.12.10 at 1:11 am }

I found a link to an article on the Junior Masterchef. wonder what this will be like. Shame they are toning down the pressure as would be interesting to see if they cry as much as the adults and see them reacting to Matt dropping plates.
http://www.watoday.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/masterchef-unveils-its-newest-ingredient-kids-20100710-104st.html

12 di { 07.12.10 at 1:13 am }

I thought George was rather dismissive with many contestants until he lounged for dramatic affect.

13 Reality Raver { 07.12.10 at 1:15 am }

Hine – LOL at the Jimmy and the sloth comment, he does come across that way, like he cannot be bothered to think about cooking something else.

CG – Agree if the judges like your dish they don’t really give a rats what the story is.

14 hine { 07.12.10 at 1:32 am }

Just saw this on Matt Prestons twitter
RT @MasterChef_Aust: News Flash! MasterChef Australia season finale confirmed for 7:30pm Sunday, July 25. RSVP Now! http://fb.me/C6ZqlQ7m

15 hine { 07.12.10 at 1:56 am }

Wow found lots of clips/promos etc on youtube re: Masterchef NZ and USA. Here’s one(sorry to bore you all :) ) and hope the USA one will be accessible somewhere on the net.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2czDoS9c2FI&feature=related

16 hine { 07.12.10 at 4:28 am }

Sorry me again. After watching the first two episodes of MCNZ, its like deja vu.Not only the hosts but the contestants also seem to paraphrase MCAust1??albeit with a Nu Zeelund accent.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hScrHgiIeHg&feature=channel

17 hine { 07.12.10 at 4:42 am }

ok last one i promise(WC final about to start) MC Jr UK
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3b98xCZgSk&feature=related
sorry :)

18 dmc { 07.12.10 at 8:13 am }

I nominate whoever has been editing this show for elimination, along with Jimmy. But it won’t matter because they’ll make sure they have only two judges who won’t agree who cooks the most awful dish so both will be kept in.

BTW I love the comment that for the sake of his sauces Jimmy should eliminate himself.

19 AniMotek { 07.12.10 at 8:46 am }

This challenge exhibited the eternal mystery of MasterChef (both the Australian and UK versions, I might add): why contestants in pressure situations insist on trying to cook something (croquembouche in Jimmy’s case, white chocolate in Jonathan’s) that they’ve never cooked before or know they have trouble with. They always claim it’s to impress the judges but you’d think they’d learn from past experience, which all of them have had, that they’re just going to stuff up and that it’s much better to cook something less difficult but flawlessly. It’s a sort of weird combination of self-doubt (“They won’t be impressed by what I know I can cook, I need to cook something snazzier”) and arrogance (“Sure I can pull off something really difficult that I’ve never cooked before”).

That said, I’m with everyone else in hoping that One-Note Jimmy is knocked out tonight. I think he’s by far the weakest of everyone left.

20 Gillian { 07.12.10 at 9:58 am }

I don’t understand why the contestants are not tasting their food as they are cooking. They are told that time and time again.

I have no problem with Callum as a person per se but he seems to have a problem with listening, taking direct orders and learning from his mistakes. These are not good personality traits even for an apprentice.

I hope he watches the footage when he gets off the show and recognises this pattern of behaviour and tries to change.

21 Culinary Boner { 07.12.10 at 10:47 am }

Now maybe if Adam plated up an ‘angry prawn’ they may have given it a second – smirking – look.

Claire made the biggest mistake of her life last night, with her snub of Jonno.

For the rest of her working life her office computer will now be subject to sub-par performance and unexpected crashes as the secret guild of IT dudes extract their revenge on behalf of their beloved comrade, Jonno.

22 Matt { 07.12.10 at 10:57 am }

Some (really long..) observations on strategy:

First of all, either Adam is the best strategic MC player in history, or he’s a weepy girl. If he HAD engineered Marion’s inclusion on his team last week (because of his immunity pin giving her a three or four-to-one chance of going home rather than a five to one shot if she was on a losing team), then the perfect way to deflect attention from your evil plan was to look all sooky on the balcony and tell the audience you feel sad. After all, the producers want a cuddly, feel-good Julie Goodwin or Poh type to win this, not a Richard Hatch/Evil Russell/Chris Badenoch. That said, if Adam is showing the usual level of Masterchef strategic nous, the tears and pancakes were probably genuine.

If I was in the house I’d need those pancakes, because I would have been into the Cristal and partying like it’s 1999 after the
elimination of the strongest competitor.

Anyway, for once, the hyperbole about “most important prize ever” was spot on. Win this, and you’ve got roughly an 88% chance of making the finals week (One in seven chance of losing on Thursday night, less the tiny – about one in 10 – chance of you winning immunity against the celeb chef).

Keeping with the MC theme, there were three strategic pressure points in last night’s episode.

The first one was winning the Mystery Box. My thinking on the box has always been this is where you don’t play safe – so it was interesting to see a few competitors doing just that. There’s no short-term penalty for losing an invention test. Long-term, you lose enough of them and your skills may get questioned. But at this end of the competition, the judge’s either like your skills or they don’t.

Jimmy’s croquembouche was inspired strategy. He didn’t have the skills to pull it off, but it was the sort of dish that if it had worked, Jimmy’s given himself an awesome aqdvantage. Frankly, Jimmy realises that he needs the advantage, so it was a clever play. If he’d played safe and done a curry – well he could have done a gold-flecked curried swan that wiped the judge’s arses for them and they would have just yawned. He needed to be spectacular, and he was. A spectacular flop, but, as Pierre the Famous French Fighter Pilot says, “when I go down, I go down in flames”.

Callum was a strategic disaster. He’s tried to be inventive, but what he needed to do was play to his strengths. Callum is proving to be a one-trick pony, but unlike Jimmy, his desserts are different enough that he can get away with it.

Which leads me to another, very important piece of strategy, and, I think, the strategic move of the night. Jonothan played it safe, which is usually the kiss of irrelevance in Mystery Boxes, and sure enough, he didn’t make the top two. However, there’s only two weeks to go, and you’ve only got a 16% chance of making the final two. So while you’re trying to win the competition, you also have to realise that the odds are very much against you. So you also need to position yourself for your post-MC career (because you’re not going to do six months of TV hell for no return). What Jonothan has done is play safe with a (for him) fairly easy, but elegant dish. It’s advertising for his new restaurant (or at least for his future equity partners in the restaurant), and it’s paid off brilliantly.

Courtney’s doing the same. I think she’s a real contender, but she’s also positioning herself to headline a small bistro or her catering company post MC. Good, honest food – and she’s using her pieces to camera to ram that message home.

Adam and Alvin? Pandan leaves, blah, blah…yep, good shot at it, but uninspired.

Claire’s dish looked a little too safe (for her), however it was awesomely put together.

And then she went and proved what a bumbling strategic doofus she is. If she was working in commercial law, no wonder she wants to get into the food industry after the flaky performance last night (and I’m talking strategy here, not cooking, which looked superb).

As with all stages of this competition, because everyone is roughly the same standard on a given night – and we’ve seen enough winners of mystery boxes stuff the invention test – the objective isn’t to give yourself the advantage, it’s to put your opponents at a disadvantage.

This is the old Survivor schoolyard pick game, but unlike Survivor, because the contestants don’t vote for you, there’s no strategic disadvantage in revealing your thoughts on who is strong and who is weak.

Claire needed to be thinking about who she wanted in finals week with her. She definitely doesn’t want Courtney – the last thing the producers want is an all-male final four (or six), so if Courtney’s out, then Claire has all-but locked in the pointy end of next week.

You do want Callum (because he’ll blow up on about Monday night), Alvin (not as marketable – I know, I know, but the sexuality thing does limit the wider appeal in the burbs), Aaron (one-dimensional. ok, two, pasta AND Mexican) and Jimmy (he’s a baby seal ready for the clubbing).

You don’t want Jono (food is too similar to Claire’s – you need to have a clear differentiator in the final four), nor do you want Adam (he’s really solid, marketable, and may be able to fly under the radar into the final two or three).

So you want to give your preferred finals week competitors as much chance as possible to succeed, and limit the chances of the strongest.

Instead, she’s picked Courtney first. At first I thought this was strategic and she doesn’t rate her – except then she goes on to pick her friends first. It appears that Claire doesn’t get on well with Jono and Jimmy, and she’s picked on emotion.

If she was thinking about strategy during these picks, she thought about it at the wrong end, picking Jono and then Jimmy. And, if you’re going to pick Jono towards the end, pick him AT the end. You’ve already identified him as a tough competitor by picking him towards the end, so limit those choices as much as possible.

Which leads to the third pressure point – getting through the Invention Test. This is where you REALLY need to play it safe. No-one’s ever been put in the bottom three of an invention test for cooking boring, but beautifully prepared and flavoured food. Stick with what you know, do it well, and watch for the others to stuff up.

Adam’s done the right thing here – the fact we didn’t see his dish shows that.

Even Jono almost pulled it off (I don’t buy the white chocolate problem thing, I think he was just unlucky). Callum too has realised that if he just cooks macaroons, he’ll make it to finals week. He’s got them nailed, and I fully expect to see them in Coles in a couple of weeks.

Aaron’s done two things right here: he’s cooked to his strengths (yep, both of ‘em) and also advertised his post MC-career. He’s realised for some time that he’s not going to win, so he’s positioning himself well for the “Rock’n'Roll Cook” show, or for the Mexican sauces. Nice work.

Jimmy’s also done well here strategically – he’s both gone for the curry (advertising the post-MC product) and played to his strengths. Unfortunately, he doesn’t have many strengths.

So where are we at? More through accident than design, Claire actually has two of the people she should have wanted in the bottom three, with Jono and Courtney. Jimmy should go home, and on last night’s performance would have probably been in the bottom three regardless of where he was picked.

But Claire missed a fantastic opportunity to stack the deck even more. Imagine how she would have set herself up with Adam, Jono and Courtney in the bottom three?

So – best strategy? Jimmy’s crocquembouche. Culinary disaster, but a solid strategic play.

Second-best? Jono’s safe dish in the Mystery Box. Excellent advertising for his future restaurant.

Third? Adam’s weepy pancakes. I’m going to give him the benefit of the doubt here, because I REALLY want to believe that he engineered Marion’s exit.

Worst? Claire’s all-over-the-shop schoolyard picks.

23 dmc { 07.12.10 at 11:12 am }

Wow, now there’s a breakdown! Great analysis.

However I’m not sure I agree with the statistics completely. To say that someone has a 16% chance of making the final two implies that people on Masterchef succeed randomly, as if their names are pulled out of a hat. It implies that all contestants are equally good and will produce their best at all times. Now, the competition is not designed for this to happen and has been manipulated at times to produce ‘tension’ results, which can make for good television but can allow for some good people to get kicked out and some muppets to remain. It’s like saying their were two teams on the pitch today so they each had a 50% chance of winning.

I don’t like it when people on Masterchef say ‘There is a 50% chance of me going home’ when they are in an elimination. No. If Claire came up against Jimmy in a cook-off that was really designed to test their skills I would say Jimmy’s chances would be much lower. Better to say nothing or be like Marion and be super confident!

24 pluck a duck { 07.12.10 at 11:16 am }

RR – you probably hit the nail on the head with your question “Or are people being judged by different standards?”, to which the answer seems to be at least a bit of a Yes.

Even though her first dish last night was OK and she is in tonight’s pressure test (possibly just to make up the numbers), the judges seem to be fawning over Courtney now, as well as their other favourites again. After all, Courtney was originally eliminated at no. 19 and has not had to go through all the trials and tribulations of the other contestants who hung in there before she breezed back in.

BTW TV Week out today (it’s the one with Marion’s and Matt’s mugshots on the front cover) has Gary prattling on again about MC having “the best .. (insert relevant number if you can count) amacha chefs in Oz”. This spin is wearing a bit thin and is inadvertently a bit of a put down in the case of Marion, and Jono if he gets eliminated tonight/soon – unless of course, one or both of this pair get a call back and are in the best 6 Gary is talking about.

25 seepi { 07.12.10 at 11:25 am }

Claire is still taking this all a bit seriously. Her comment about ‘people’s lies in my hands’ while choosing the order of Sins was very over the top. For this one it mattered less than usual. I mean Aaron went early and picked Pride, which would have been my hardest one to think of anything.

Courtney was overthinking – anything green would have been fine. And why did she make two dishes – i was a bit lost with her dish.

Jimmy should have served his up on a mirror! With his croquembouche he should have just arranged them on a plate with some nice garnishes, rather than persisting with the tower when it wasn’t working.

Adam I think is also a bit of a one-trick pony. His food does look lovely and interesting, but it is fairly standard Asian (I think?). Unlike Poh, who was good at desserts as well, and often tried a variation on a standard Asian recipe.

Not showing Adam’s dish was just ridiculous. It shows they are totally locked in to showing Best 3 and Worst 3, even when there is only one other dish. they have totally forgotten that a huge part of this show’s appeal is the audience getting to see what the contestants like to cook, and imagining which 3 we think are the best, not just taking their word for it.

And on Johnno’s comment about ‘she’s picked me at the end as I am a threat’, I think it was clear to the contestants that Claire was picking on a friendship basis, and Johnno was a bit embarassed. that’s why he made a face when he was picked before Jimmy (ruining his theory that Claire was leavint the biggest threat to last.)

26 Matt { 07.12.10 at 11:30 am }

DMC – I think the stats are valid only as a baseline. You’re correct, of course, that Marion against Aaron, for instance, probably wasn’t a 50/50 shot.

But it’s as exact as you can get – it’s objective data, rather than subjective.

Point being that – as in last week – if you’re Adam with an immunity pin, you’re putting Marion in a position where her chances of losing are greater. Say that in a five-person elimination she’s got 10% chance of going home (because she’s so good). In a four-person elimination (once the pin is used) that’s increased to 16%. Adam got even luckier because Jimmy realised how he could stack the deck even further, giving Marion a one-in-three baseline of going home.

The objective is to put your competition in the best possible situation to lose. They might (and indeed, if they’re better, should) still win.

And at this end of the competition, everyone is pretty much on the same level anyway. Marion really only stuffed up two dishes that I can think of – once got her into an elimination, when she used her pin, and the other was the producer’s set-up satay.

27 Anne { 07.12.10 at 11:37 am }

Matt – the problem with your analysis is that Claire and Jono are actually good friends and get along really well. I don’t know what her strategy was in picking people (I suspect she didn’t have one and was going really randomly), but it wasn’t based on emotion.

28 Fides { 07.12.10 at 11:46 am }

Seepi #25, you’ve said it perfectly!

This year it has been so frustrating watching the Sunday night shows because there is no suspense. Having rewatched some of last year’s Sunday night shows to remind myself how good it used to, and could have been, that was exactly the fun of it all… seeing what the contestants choose to cook and wondering what it would taste like. I liked seeing something of their methods, and then hearing the judges verdict even if it was not going to be a dismal failure or something superlative. The only time they can manage to do that this year is when they’re paired up, but even last week it was pretty obvious who was safe by who didn’t get any airtime.

29 Matt { 07.12.10 at 11:55 am }

Anne,

You may be right. Her picks were so random I’m clutching at straws here a bit in trying to explain them!

Just goes to show her total lack of strategic thinking. She’s also been lacking in thinking strategically about post-MC. Not only did she completely burn her law career, she hasn’t, I believe, positioned herself as well as she could have.

You need to be positioning yourself to either sell the cookbook (MC winner) or to sell the sauce range (knocked out in finals week). Right now I’m not sure if she’s done enough to convince people to buy either.

I’m not anti-Claire, by the way. I think that with Jono and Marion she’s one of the most technically proficient cooks in the whole competition, with a light and elegant touch.

She’s also smoking hot.

But as we’ve seen with Marion, just being a good cook doesn’t mean you’re safe. She came afoul of strategy and a brilliant and underrated
performance by Aaron, despite the best efforts of the producers to keep her in.

When you’re given strategic power (and you get it rarely on this show – really only when you’re a team captain), you need to be ruthless in using it.

30 Jenny { 07.12.10 at 12:06 pm }

If Masterchef had cut out all their dramatic fillers – such as Gary getting Callum to taste his salty sauce – then maybe we would have seen Adam’s dish! Actually Cup Fever took off Masterchef and their dramatic editing last night – lol –

http://theworldgame.sbs.com.au/promotion/cupfever/video/279317/Santo,-Sam-And-Ed-s-Cup-Fever!-Ep-26/

I hope Courtney gets through tonight! Jimmy to go! But who knows after the dumping of maid Marion last week. Sob! I thought it was funny when I heard stories on twitter that some people’s kids were sobbing and unconsolable after Marion left. Even the kid’s love her. She can do no wrong!

31 NT Kate { 07.12.10 at 12:19 pm }

Matt – I don’t think I agree with a lot of your analysis.

First you didn’t need to win the mystery box to have a (rigging and immun aside), on your methodology 86% chance of getting to finals week – you just had to not lose the invention test.

And I don’t think your probabilities are quite right – depends on how the mid-week challenge is structured of course, but not 1/7 chance of being eliminated on Thurs but if two teams, product of 50: 50 chance of being in elimination then 1/?3 or ?4 of being eliminated.

Secondly, Jimmy certainly needed to do something non-curry to continue to be a contender. But if he was trying to persuade the judges he didn’t just have one string, a dramatic failure isn’t the way to do it! Surely he could have thought of something a bit more doable (and tasteful!) in 30 mins.

Thirdly Johno – given that there was a big prize for winning the mystery box and no penalty for losing, and a big penalty for losing but no prize for the invention test, the sensible strategy was to do something ambitious for MB and something safe for the invention test. Johno did the reverse. Pretty silly, and if the editing is any indication, he is going to pay for that tonight (though Jimmy and Courteney both still deserve to go first on more objective criteria).

As to what Claire was thinking…it’s a mystery! Not sure that getting to pick your sin really seemed to be much of an advantage. What counted in the end was being able to come up with an imaginative story and presentation to justify whatever you did choose! Perhaps she realised that no matter what, Courtney would flounder on that point…

32 Matt { 07.12.10 at 12:40 pm }

Hi NT Kate (and I love the name :) ),

The mystery box stats are right (although a touch rough). If you win, you go from a one in eight chance of making finals week (12.5%) to a on in seven (about 16%) . Yes, you can get the same outcome from not losing the invention test, but you’ve only got a four in seven chance (a little better than 57%) of not getting in the bottom three. That’s not much better than a coin toss.

The objective here is to, as much as possible, guarantee you’re not in that bottom three. Anyway, if you’re in the bottom three with Jono, you’re a one-in-two chance of going home :) . Anyway, the key thing here was IF you won, to put your strongest competitors in the worst position, which was what Claire didn’t do.

I agree with you on Thursday night – we don’t know how it’s going to be structured, but I’d be surprised if it’s a group challenge, given how small the competition is now and the disadvantage a small team would have. Can’t remember what they did last year.

You’re right about Jimmy – but I was trying to make the point that he realised he needed to step it up for the Mystery Box and then revert to type for the Invention test. It was just that he was so inept that no amount of strategic smarts was going to pull him out of the bottom three.

I actually think Jono did try to play it fairly safe for the Invention Test. As with a few competitors, he was only a minute or two away from having a sensational dish. Or put another way, if Gary and George didn’t come around and ask him what he was cooking, he would have plated up a masterpiece.

I suppose my point here was that his strategic smarts was thinking about what happens AFTER he loses. He’s analysed the chances of actually winning the Mystery Box, decided they were too small and made a dish that markets his post-MC restaurant.

An observation though: Didn’t the judges a couple of weeks ago judge Marion (or someone) on the dessert immediately AFTER it was made, not waiting 30 minutes until it melts on the plate? Surely they couldn’t have wanted the extra TV tension of having Jono present a collapsed mouse? Surely not…

33 Matt { 07.12.10 at 12:51 pm }

Another observation – I love writing “Post-MC”.

Makes me think we’re writing about Sons of Anarchy.

34 Chunks { 07.12.10 at 12:52 pm }

All this talk about the future of the contestants cooking in their own restaurants is overlooking one big thing. None of them are chefs and a few weeks on TV doesn’t make them a chef’s little tornail. As much as I enjoy the show I am not going to a restaurant run by Johnno until he’s served an apprenticeship. Why would I want that disastrous dessert served up to me for $15-$20 or so?

Most of these people are not interested in cooking; they are interested in being famous. If they really want to cash in on their fame they should buy a KFC franchise, put their face on a sign out the front and cash in while the going is good and sad celebrity-deprived Australians are willing to queue outside their outlet for a glimpse of someone who’s actually BEEN ON TV! OMG, OMG OMG!!!! It’s HIM/HER. As for Marion and Jimmy and their sauces. good luck with that. Yes, Coles – the place where Masterchef’s go to buy their pheasant breast if we’re to believe the ads – will of course help promote the products with their faces on them. Marion’s cooking Kan Ton, doesn’t take long for the word to get around. Jimmy feels like Marsala Curry Chicken Tonight.

That’s not food. It’s chemicals mixed together masquerading as food. But a new lot of contestants come along and in five years no one even remembers you. So cash in while the cash is coming in and fools are easily parted from their money.

What I really don’t get is why Tetsuya, Neil Perry, Matt Moran, Kylie Kwong etc lend their names to this stuff given the consequences. Can’t they see how it’s undermining the real food industry and making a m0ckery of the years or decades they spent honing their craft?

35 Matt { 07.12.10 at 12:58 pm }

Chunks – I tend to agree with you, but the sad number of sad people who bought Julie’s sad cookbook would tend to argue against us.

As to why the celeb chefs go on this show? Because since it started I’ve bought both of Justin North’s cookbooks (awesome, by the way), and am trying to get a group together to go to the Red Lantern.

I think that far from undermining the food industry, it’s given it a whole new lease of life. You only have to look at the way Coles (yes, Coles) stacks its vegies now. Masterchef is changing the way a generation of Australians not only eat, but shop for the best ingredients.

That said, it’s truly hilarious watching the ads for preprepared food during MC. A bit like last year’s McDonalds ads during season one.

36 Reality Raver { 07.12.10 at 1:45 pm }

Hine – I don’t know why Matt Preston thought it was a news flash that the final was on Sunday 25 July, I thought it had been out there for quite some time. Also I don’t get the point of that FB page they have set up.

DMC – LOL I agree the editor has got to go.

Animotek – I don’t know how he thought he was going to do that all in 30 minutes. That is why Alvin is still there he cooks stuff he knows or versions of it most of the time.

Gillian – my money is Callum to make it to the final week.

Culinary Boner – ha ha, there probably hacking away right now.

Matt – I like your thinking, however I think Claire picked Courtney first because she ran second in the mystery box challenge to her.
I don’t think Claire has a Phd in ratfucking to be strategic like that.
I could not stop laughing a the Jimmy is a baby seal ready for clubbing comment. Also after last night I got the feeling maybe courtney would not be a force in the final’s week if she made it as I think she is great with flavours but her technique and confidence to do something complex. I am pretty sure that cheesecake was out of a Australia’s Good Taste Magazine. Not that there is anything wrong with that but that is really where her level is. Having said that I would eat what she cooked, ahead of Aaron’s mole.
Also agree with you re: Claire what has she set herself up for post masterchef. I am not sure she has the personality to have her own show, but then again Julia Jenkins got one…
The having the garden restaurant just seems a bit pie in the sky stuff.

Fides – so you think the editing was better last year. I don’t remember it being so obvious last year, but I may just be more masterchef savvy this year.

NT Kate – I thought Jono’s strategy was sound for the mystery box he did something he was confident with and it was fairly complex dish to be completed in 30 mins. In any mystery box challenge he knows at least 50% of the field will stuff up, and he just has to have a better dish then two of them. Last night he didn’t. Again he just had bad luck with that second one, he underestimated the time it would take to set in the freeze blaster.

Chunks- I don’t think any are capable of cooking in a kitchen because they don’t have the skills for the timing or the numbers. I think Callum and Matthew will become professional chefs. Why the chefs go on the show – to increase their profile outside the usual PR circles. I know after I see Christine Mansfield’s food tonight, I am going to be itching to go to Universal.

37 duke nukem { 07.12.10 at 2:08 pm }

RR, I’m finding your blog posts and the readers comments
infinitely more entertaining that the show itself.

38 Chunks { 07.12.10 at 2:19 pm }

Dunno if you have already been to Universal RR but I’d go there every week if I could afford to (and lived in Sydney haha). I bought her Fire book just so I could own it, because even the most adventurous home cook would blanch at the list of ingredients and the preparation involved in most of her dishes.

And Matt, yes, you’re probably right. Was there anything ever printed less inspiring than Julie’s cookbook?

I guess if MC does inspire people to eat outside the square then it’s all worth it but I can’t help but feel that the appearance of great chefs on the program just encouages more silly airheads to clog up restaurant kitchens with apprenticeships that will never go anywhere because they give up as soon as they realise that it doesn’t involve being on TV and becoming a celebrity. I’m exhausted at the end of that sentence.

39 Reader { 07.12.10 at 2:27 pm }

Masterchef is a fast way of getting from point A to point B for the chosen few. Callum may never become a chef, he just never learns. Same mistake two weeks in a row is unforgivable and should have seen him eliminated.

Sadly Jonathan underestimated the time it would take to make his complicated dish.
We never got a chance to see Adams creation.

Aaron should be in the bottom 3 instead of Jonathan. I have a feeling that judges want Jonathan out this week. Courntey, Jimmy, Aaron, Callum and Claire should go before Jonathan.

Skills challenge to get back into the show is pure nonsense, Kate and Jake had no business being in the top 24, let alone allowed to come back.

Aaron can only do 2 things well, Mexican and Pasta and he still somehow managed to serve up dogs breakfast in the last nights episode.

Universal is great, expect big flavors

40 dmc { 07.12.10 at 2:28 pm }

Is Zumbo really tipping Jimmy to win in todays’s SMH?

I think he’s been sucking too much on the macaroon pipe….

41 Culinary Boner { 07.12.10 at 2:30 pm }

“And Matt, yes, you’re probably right. Was there anything ever printed less inspiring than Julie’s cookbook?”

Chunks, try the following for size: “The Wit and Wisdom of William McMahon”, Thomas Nelson, Melbourne, 1972

42 Chels { 07.12.10 at 2:33 pm }

Best quote of the night:

Aaron: “Food doesn’t lie… Only people do”

43 Fides { 07.12.10 at 3:01 pm }

Raver – yes I’ve rewatched some of last year’s Sunday episodes at the same comparative stage ( eg eps when there were 14 contestants left to compare with how they did it this year) so see if it’s just because we’re all more cluey to the editors’ tricks. There would definitely be contestants that the Gs focussed on (ie in their little discussions as they cooked) who would inevitably end up top or bottom 3 with one red herring but we would see every dish with its title and during a tasting, even if it was just Gary pulling a face and saying “I don’t like it.”

It amazes me that the producers have not seen this as a problem, especially given Matt P talking up the show before the season began about how they’ve made the best bits better and tried not to change the formula too much. Can they not see that the focus on “the story” and silly stunts this time round is not an improvement? Suppose at the end of the day, it’s the ratings that count, so I guess things won’t change.

Also on the MC website, there are fewer contestant recipes being published this year – I’ve just had a look. This year, from official start of top 24 week (not dishes made in Top 50) until last night, there were 24 contestant recipes. Same time last year (top 20 to the week before finals), there were 36, and a total of 43 if you count the final week. It doesn’t matter that some of those recipes are pretty simple, I liked to see which 10 or so ingredients they chose, or look at their method /see how complicated their steps (or should I say “processes”) were. This year they are having the contestants do video demos of their winning dishes, but I think that is simply to assess who has TV talent in a presentation role. I’ll admit from that angle, it’s pretty interesting and Aaron, Adam, Pete and Jono are good. Alvin not so much, Claire surprisingly good.

OK, rant over!

44 Anonymous { 07.12.10 at 3:23 pm }

OMG Matt, You have way overthought last night’s show and the contestant’s strategies. Nice yarn but full of flaws and nonsense. This week’s mystery box was the first ever that gave a straight thru to the celebrity chef cookoff. Ususally it is the winner of the invention test that gets up against the chef. So the mystery box challenge should have been (each week in fact) where everyone goes all out as there is no downside to losing. While the weakest players like Jimmy and possibly Aaron are positioning for some future opportunities (like Jimmy’s sauces), I highly doubt Jonothan is cooking “pretty” dishes in the mystery box challenge to attract future investors to his restaurant. Ditto Courtney. And this week’s invention test was wide open. By this I mean there was little advantage to Claire picking someone third or sixth because they were not constrained by ingredients or really anything and any story could be told to link a dish to the “sin”. I don’t even think she had time to think things thru given the nature of the challenge and her order of picking persons seemed quite random. Perhaps two of the deadly sins gave advantage because it was obvious what to cook, like gluttony and lust, each suggesting a rich dessert. But Jonothan got lust so what does that say. You must be a great poker player but poker strategy and gaming theory cannot always be applied to business, let alone a reality tv show involving so many subjective variables including producers, editors, advertisers and the eight notsogreat cooks and stress cadets that are left in the competition.

45 Buzz { 07.12.10 at 3:37 pm }

Matt, I’m with anonymous on this one … Conspiracy or Cock-up? I’d pick cock-up based on the poor editing, production, scripting etc. If they can’t get basics of reality tv right how are they going to think up all those macchiavellian moves? Love reading your theories though – keep em coming :)
Culinary boner, love the thought of an IT Support revenge conspiracy!

46 OdieWan { 07.12.10 at 3:40 pm }

agree with duke nukem

47 hine { 07.12.10 at 3:41 pm }

Matt-thanks for your comments and everyone else. Its great to hear everyones points of view and analysis(although comment 44 seems like an angry person to me :) )
Lust seemed like a great one-surprised it was picked near last and even if the dish worked out I didn’t find it appealing or lustful. I agree that many of this years crop seem to have ulterior motives in regards to their participation in this program. I am only disappointed that the % split between it being a cooking program and a reality drama has erred on the wrong side in season 2 in my eyes.

48 hine { 07.12.10 at 5:21 pm }

OOps I was just thinking, next year they may make the jump and have a half hour BB style show prior to MC showing them in the house and then an uplate prog too. If they had it this year, I wonder what we would have seen?Adam playing his ukelule in the bath…Aaron practising his bits to camera in front of the mirror. Wish they would go that road since they have gone so far already(agree with Fides ‘rant’ above :) )

49 LivingLaVidaLoca { 07.12.10 at 5:40 pm }

Yeah Jimmy’s got to go… really sick of Indian food from him and Asian food in general. Last year was much better with Julie, Julia & Justine. Most people don’t even eat Curry or Asian food all the time. Maybe once a month!!! Jimmy to go then Alvin and Adam.

50 Matt { 07.12.10 at 6:15 pm }

Anonymous and Buzz,

Unfortunately I think you’re both right – it does tend to be more cock-up than conspiracy.

What my comments are about though is more the strategy that SHOULD be followed. Unfortunately not many of the contestants would recognise strategy if it tapped them on the shoulder and whacked them over the head with a big stick engraved with STRATEGY in capital letters…

In terms of Anonymous’ comments re the mystery box advantage – I think you’re actually agreeing with me here at first. You NEED to go all out on this because there’s no penalty for losing (and optimum strategy on MC is not necessarily to win, but not to lose). My comment re Jono’s dish was he broke the rules, but did so in a very strategic way. If he won the challenge, great, but if he didn’t he’s still put up a cracking dish that’s a great ad.

In terms of the invention test, there may not be any big advantage in the order of picks – no matter where you pick someone, they may still end up with a great dish. The strategy here is to LIMIT their chance of getting the dish/sin they wanted. The other thing you’re doing here is limiting the time they have to plan their dish (although I’m not sure how much real time there was between choosing and cooking).

Claire didn’t have this strategy (in fact I doubt if she had any at all, despite the producers’ attempt, with Jono’s piece-to-camera, to make us think she did). If she did, she might have put herself in a much better position to win.

As it turns out, her two biggest rivals ended up in the bottom
three, more through their own general incompetance than any actual strategy.

Fingers crossed for Jono tonight.

51 Injera { 07.12.10 at 6:17 pm }

DMC: where can I get a macaron pipe? Sounds like just the thing to get me through the rest of the week if anyone but Jimmy goes tonight.

CB: I had to google the McMahon bokk – was sure you’d made it up. Now I’m considering getting it just to check whether, like Julie, there are blank pages in it to add one’s own wit and wisdom. Alas, it’s out of print.

52 brain dead dave { 07.12.10 at 6:28 pm }

Jimmy’s favourite holiday spot- Cloncurry
His favourite bird-the Currawong
When Jimmy dies he’ll be curried to his grave.

53 Chunks { 07.12.10 at 7:28 pm }

Injera, there are bound to be plenty of copies available very cheaply on Ebay!

54 NT Kate { 07.12.10 at 7:41 pm }

Matt – My point was that the three people who do not go into elimination from the Invention test have exactly the same odds of reaching finals week as the winner of the invention test (unless she manages to win immunity). And that Johno’s long term campaign (if has one – he stuffed up his classic french dish in Paris!) would have been better served by doing a classic french invention test recipe that came off then tossing away, on this occasion, his chance of winning the mystery box which was obviously going to be judged on inventiveness rather than just failing to stuff up given the prize and the way the judge’s think.

In any case, tonight will be interesting….

55 Matt { 07.12.10 at 8:11 pm }

NT Kate – but you’ve got to not lose the invention test. If you didn’t win the mystery box then your chances of getting through are dramatically reduced.

You are correct in saying your chances of getting through are the same as the m box winner – but only AFTER you sneak through in the invention test.

56 Culinary Boner { 07.13.10 at 12:12 pm }

Injera, I also am keen to view (though, perhaps not purchase) little Billy’s book. It’s spine would look good on my bookshelf, perhaps alongside the much more useful Don Dunstan Cookbook. In fact some of Don’s recipes would be well worth replicating for a MasterChef challenge…with the boys all donning Safari Suits.

57 SydneyGirl { 07.13.10 at 3:05 pm }

Even though Jonathan was a touch arrogant he was also a really good cook, though a couple of times put up a bad dish, so I don’t think he deserved to go home. But Marion leaving was a joke – that elimination was unfair anyway. it should have been the worst two on the team – so the elimination would have been Aaron and Adam. Then Aaron would have gone. Aaron is arrogant and mean-spirited, and is an inconsistent cook. He won’t win, so what’s the point in keeping him? The people who deserve to be in the finals week are the people who have a chance of winning (aka Claire, Adam, Marion, Jonathan, Courtney) and the rest should be battling it out.

58 SydneyGirl { 07.13.10 at 3:08 pm }

I’m sorry LivingLaVidaLoca, but I (and everyone at my school) think Adam is an amazing cook and does not deserve to go until late in the finals week or make it to the finals. Not to be rude/offensive or anything

Leave a Comment