Masterchef Australia – OPEN POST – The Army Challenge
Sorry guys tonight I am out with Ms Injera, but the plus side is you get to discuss the episode so much earlier. Tonight the top nine are out at the Holsworthy Army Base for their cooking challenge.
Apparently the conditions were pretty tough, a camp out, plus the weather was abysmal.
Hopefully Gary, George and Matt went to boot camp whilst they were there.

177 comments
My (now ex) partner is an officer in the Holsworthy army base… From my personal experiences, I have to say that I’m not a fan of the military. Hope it will be a good episode.
Alvin “I’ve had a bit of experience with uniforms, uniforms do it for me”
Oh lord…
Surprise
First pick Marion DUH
CMON THE RED TEAM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If Claire gets out her English patient regalia, Im off
Hope key AA characteristics include cast iron stomachs
look after you’re fellow team members……ha
best quote of the night (so far): “uniforms do it for me” – alvin
I’ll be interested to see how they cook those army dog biscuits (teeth breakers we called em)
a sudden rush in transfers to Afghanistan, on hearing the news MC is feeding them today…if its peas it will camouflage well
that guys giving Julia G elocution lessons
Was anyone else expecting a contestant to explain to us when 1400 was?
I can see why Claire keeps her hair over her ears
Im not buying Claires ninja look….
Pep talk…you’ll need to show courage (not as much as the poor devils who have to eat it), initiative (make own stock)……
Aaron a bottle of ned kelly whiskey would be better
20 kg pack – should have left the nitro machine at home
Lots of spices – Jimmy’s rellies been tunneling into camp again?
Aaron and the school of the bleeding obvious
Cmon people… cook em some delicate French meal artistically arranged on the plates with barely any food (especially not much Meat!). That’ll make em happy
Callum is going the hard dessert route again
Jimmy’s doing a curry? Shock!
Here comes the Jeep of Jerks
Love the way Alvin has gone all Carson Cressley and jujjed his beret
I thought matt would arrive straddled around the gun of a tank a la cher on the battleship missouri
Yeps Claire’s responsible alright
extra head in the kitchen…..oh this epi is saucy
Matt looks like he is on jungle safari
Loving MPs game lodge look!
mind readers? no just dumb arses taking the lazy way
Paul wot are the odds of both teams doing the same dishes?
Makes yer wonder
Matt P would scare any Rhino away, he should run a safari
Aaron powering along in front of gazelle-like C – obviously decided to get fit after the Paris debacle – and he seems to be revving generally too, interesting that he did a tour entertaining the troops. But have to admit, it will be hard to go past Alvin’s spiffy uniforms interest. Just as well Australia doesn’t have a don’t ask don’t tell policy!
Gary has severe bouncitis
Cos only lawyers can negotiate…
give em snails
an green chunder
an wun a geos salads
An finish it of wiyh a batch of lamington scones
Will Callum crumble under the pressure?
meat mallet – why not use Aarons head
Yeah the lads are going to line up for the blonde curry alright
Koftas dont contain paprika and sultanas. Leave the Indian to Jimmy Alvin. A tailor must stick to his wurst ( Sorry w Semmel)
Oh wow – they actually censored an ingredient by blurring it out so we couldn’t see what it was.
Yeah Jono – pastry is your secret weapon
We get it jono – you’re doing Aaron a favour
Callum’s crumbled
Callums cooking last nights mixture but he’s coolur blind Steaming yellow splat YUCK and I dont mean yum yuck!
Callum, there goes your Western Star gig, but theres always Clearasil
What’s wrong with both teams doing the same dishes? At least it’ll be comparing apples with apples, so to speak. Then it will come down to taste, not luck that they pick a dish that the soldiers like regardless of the taste.
army marches on its stomach, Matt’s stomach is an army
Well G’s you had to make the complicated fancy French pastry in masterclass rather than showing how to make a basic sponge.
Aahh The old dog biscuits yum yuck
Callums ‘ wanting to make custard’ – subtle variation from Callum is making custard….she knows!!!!!
Hes doing other alaments alright ……. yes he’s doing in the oven’s element
Its the Mount Vesuvius of custurd
Steaming white splat
This is going to throw future recruitment back at least a decade
I think we should send Callum to Afghanistan to sort out the zyalibsn with his culinary weapons of mess destruction
Taliban….
So why did they miraculously hit on the same menu – yet again???!
Hope the guys tongues are wearing full metal jackets
wots wrong with scrambled eggs – thats just custard reformed into another gastro format….but better if you make it green
Yep The gen Yers know it all better as usual
Claire’s frustration with Callum (and beating her head with her hand) makes me like her a lot more.
Jono you are a superstar. and MODEST
Callums napalm upside down cake?
Masterchef massacre……they’d better get good food or else
now if this is the same as last years navy challnge we will no doubt see each soldier tasting and voting HA
is that war paint or the effect of eating the meeeals
Build up the tension MC you wankers. One good comment for each side at a time
yeah n0 – oh its yum yuk time
I’ll have some ears with my dessert, thanks
After 3 days in the bush on doggy biscuits they’d go back for seconds even if the main course was a crap sandwich
Alvin needs an arm extension – those guys not wanting to get too close to his jug of cream
the food is hot, we dont usually get meat, the standards of this assessment are blowing me away…and Im sure they will continue to blow through the camp for the rest of the day
Matt P would make a good target for afternoon practice
Matt too many words
Yep goood old handeeswipe. What a set-up.
Whaetverd oes not get “absawbed” the jedges will lick up cos it was all sooooooooooo gooooooooooood
After the comments obviously red lost DUH
No Callum You really didn’t perform the best.
I hope they made you clean up the field bbq
Yep johno you are superman
Callum , the Frank Spencer of MC
George
“basically i just f@#$ed up!”
Marion, the acting classes are going a treat
Thanks for telling us blue won it jono You just destroyed the carefully orchestrated suspense cunningly built up by MC.
I wanna see the votes!!
Callum , put it back on the Gs….. you lost me on episode 2 but I’ve had a great time
Skt – votes are proportional to amount of properly creamed fat
Spot the unworthy, with emphasis on Spot
Yah-Courtney’s ’snuff’ necklace as someone labelled it must be her lucky charm
As to the voting it was two chicks vs one…hope that isn’t too sexist
Boy am I a surprised duck
PAUL
My conspiracy theory May just MAY have been blown to hell. We’ll see after the world’s toughest most awsum most hardest most supercalifragelisticexpealidocious elimination.
(hope I spelled awsum write)
Red team had the advantage by having the meatballs. Its the perfect dish for the situation. The Blue team should’ve won, they were the better team. They were one down and still managed to make more dishes. And they didn’t really screw up any of the dishes that much. The koftas weren’t fantastic but they were at a disadvantage by having to change the main dish.
Why did Marion get to see the elimination challenge first and Adam doesn’t have that luxury
Who gives a rats what jono would do?
a long time ( yes 5 days)…..shaddup it was your khaki koftas that A bombed the team
Adam
Dont be so FALSELY NOBLE. just tell us you’ll use the wretched thing
Conspiracy theory still Holds after all.
Bye Bye Aaron
dodge the bullet….Gary I was hoping you could resist- I assume it was that or whether A pulled the pin
2 rounds, how convenient, covers odds of 1 goodie going in a first round G stuff up
Marion
Your nobleness is an inspiration
Yep jono
I already told you it will be the hardest yadda yadda elimination
DUH
Whether Adam believed what he was saying or not, you can’t blame him for doing the “trying to be noble” route – he would have been crucified in the forums/papers for being a bad leader if he hadn’t put up at least a bit of resistance.
Now, the real question is can Aaron get lucky and pull through another elimination, and thus oust one of the two favourites? It’s not a straight cooking challenge, so anyone can stuff up on one of these guess the item challenges.
Angel 86
boo hoo. I tried to tell them about the koftas but would the know it all numero unos lsiten ?
At least adam wont be getting the bone despite the crappy koftas
Great to se jimmy pick the right team
Anony M
Let’s hope so
Anon
Re Marion seeing the elim challenge first…. Its Obvious.
Sour, hanging head in shame
Anon
Please dont
According to Paul my theory is B/S (and of course also to her many admirers)
I’m totally angry! The blue team not only had less people.. They made MORE food! and nicer food! It’s rigged!!
sour,
add bitter ‘n’ twisted
I hope Marion doesn’t get eliminated…I really think she deserves to win. Even if she is the favourite to alot of other people too.
Oh Callum. But why didn’t Claire just tell him straight out just to finish the cake and forget the custard?
Whereas Johno did seem to do incredibly well in this challenge – the man is an enigma. And Aaron seemed to be full of energy too.
For once it will be very interesting tomorrow – I don’t want any of them to go.
Just to save anyone watching this episode, …
Its the Duds Army challenge – Gary knows nuuuuu-thing , there’s a Loose Callum , and Aaron’s getting the tootbrush out for the toilet block
Rusty
Dont forget ..and cynical
god i hope the favourite loses tomorrow night and we all know who that is !
the show would so much interesting ,all the amateur cooks would think i have a chance here, now that marion is gone . by the way was claire in lord of the rings with that hairdo “PRECIOUS” and for callum what a train wreck !!!!!
Thanks for the blow-by-blow commentary! Just… having trouble piecing together the end result. Executive Summary, anyone? From what I can gather, Adam’s team lost so it’s him (and he’ll use a munity), Marion, Aaron and somebody else up for elim. Who is the other body?
I thought Aaron was appealing tonight. As a result I predict his exit tomorrow- editing tonight was kind to him. Suck us in and then kick him out. Coinciding with a return to editing Jonno as a wanker with self serving commentary about bring a good guy (despite te fact that he was helping and a dessert making machine). Same editing rationale at play – remind us of his arrogance then keep him in.
Or I am reading too much into it and have just become oddly accustomed to Aarons beanie and rocklingo/hands.
Injera, happen to have one PPt slide @#105
Injerus: jonno Marion and aaron up for elim tomorrow. Result was 66 :34 against them. Adam vacillated about using the pin (he was captain abs his koftas were worst dish). The others told him to use it. He cried. Then used it. Garry said it was a good decision. Tomorrow is a 2 round “basic skills” and “guess that nut” sudden death challenge.
Interestingly, as has been pointed out here he had to commit to using the pin before he saw the challenge. I assume as it would have been a 3 round challenge if he had stayed. But still inconsistent.
Hope you enjoyed dinner with RR.
To be fair to Jono’s self love, and detachment behaviour tonight – he’s clearly sucumbed to the ‘Stockholm…. I mean ‘Campbells Stock only’, effect – after considerable hours in a vacuumwith mean captors that march you around like an Austrian singing troupe, it is known that people start believing what they hear about their cooking and some start believing they are actually good cooks
This is the second time (remember Press Club?) we’ve seen Callum explicitly NOT follow instructions and trust his own ‘instincts’ – i’m so unimpressed! I am definitely liking Claire a lot more after tonight… she was like, argh, Callum, no!
totally unfair that the blue team lost given how impressive their overall effort was, but hey, what team challenge IS fair?! it’s the most poorly constructed part of the whole show. jono could very well end up going home off the back of two amazing desserts, just like skye went home off the back of dishes she wasn’t responsible for.
defs sneaky of the Gs to introduce another 2-round elimination. surely that will be the necessary safety net for marion and jonathan. i’m tipping aaron to go. and about bloody time.
Will there be a challenge between now and the finale where Jimmy cannot find an excuse to make a curry?
Most disappointing thing about tonight’s episode: the G’s and MP got to ride up to the base camp in a jeep – like three Raj Princes going on a lion hunt in a game park. Would have loved to see them hike it up with the rest of the lot?? MP would surely have a heart attack and the G’s would be so winded we would be spared their cheesy one-liners for at least a couple of weeks.
As for the challenge, these guys were so hungry anything would have tasted great. I reckon it was Claire and Courtney front and centre serving up the slop (not to mention Alvin’s appeal to some of the soliders) that tipped the votes towards the Red Team? Otherwise, the desserts coming at the end should have tipped the voting to Blue.
And what’s the deal Claire’s and Courtney’s 6-inch stillettos when they appear in the MC Kitchen for the results?
Probably about time for a shock elimination to keep things interesting. Jono could go. Otherwise, I reckon Aaron “If I don’t know what it is I’m calling it a Walnut” is finally going to be released so he can get laid. He is really losing it.
At least the army follows OHS and they had to cover their hair for once!!!!! It’s getting so so so irritating hearing everything repeated after each commercial break.!!!!!
Marion in two eliminations!!
My conspirosy theory is that the blue team was the loser so that Jono and Marion could be in an elimination so that people could stop saying she’s the favourite. Also Adam had to use his pin which means they are now all equal.
Most of the team challenges have been uneven. This would not have happened if they had eliminated either Aaron or Jimmy last week.
How can Callun still be in the competition?
It’s really going downhill this year and it’s taking too long
So for Injera and RR, here is a the blow by blow, sans some of the colour and light above.
At the house its pick a team time – Claire is Red and Adam Blue Leader (yes, lots of manly posturing to come. Except from Alvin whose outstretched arms the troops seem to be trying to avoid for some reason. Or maybe they weren’t and that’s why Red…).
Adam gets what should be more or less the dream-team of Marian, Johno and Aaron; Claire goes for Courteney, Callum and Alvin (did she just pick for C’s before running out?). Lucky last gets to pick which team s/he joins….so to everyone’s surprise, Jimmy goes with Claire rather than the dream team, giving them the extra body advantage (which Adam subsequently whinges about several times, but he is right, it isn’t really fair).
Come morning the cameras are on to watch Adam do a mock drill sergeant act and get everyone out of bed and dressed in camoflage gear at some dastardly hour (well ok actually its a leisurely 7am) – off to Holdsworthy Army base, where the challenge is to cook for a hundred soldiers who have been out in the bush for three weeks living off cold ration packs (shown to us by the Colonel who doesn’t have a second career in the media in front of him).
Alvin is happy…because he has a thing for those in those spiffy uniforms. Aaron is pumped because he got to go on an entertainment tour to the troops in Iraq and Afghanistan not long ago, so knows what they like to eat and is thrilled to be honouring the troops. And close your ears to all the awful military puns to come from the Gs and M.
Actually I’m guessing this was filmed after they all had a bit of a break, because they all seem much happier and healthier.
They are dumped off somewhere in the wild to walk to wherever it is they are going to cook – not clear how long the walk is, but its wet and slippery, and they have 20 kilo packs on their backs (cans of food etc it turns out).
Weirdly, unfit Aaron from Paris has apparently reformed his evil exercizeless ways and is out in front, leading his team and pushing them to get there first which they do – gazelle-like Claire from Paris is no where to be seen.
And in fact Blue have chosen their dishes, set up and are starting to cook by the time the Reds finally drag themselves in.
Miraculously (because surely they didn’t peek or overhear what was being cooked…) the Reds choose exactly the same menu – curry, meatballs, apple and rubarb crumble. But though the reds have ‘overheard a few things’ they aren’t going to let that worry them, they just have to get going. Sure guys.
Stand by for the arrival of the Generals (I mean George’s plus Matt), standing up on the back of a truck like cattle going to auction, I mean Generals surveying the troops.
The G’s check in with the team leaders – and oh dear everyone is cooking the same thing. Big problem apparently, not honouring our troops enough, so the two team leaders are brought together to try and do a fix. Agree the curries will be different enough in style to be ok. Being lawyers, the negotiation takes five secs – Claire gives up the crumble in return for Adam giving up the meatballs.
And so to the cooking. Marion is doing a thai style chicken curry; Jimmy a ‘lightly spiced’ Indian with cocounut rice. Both look good. Also do roast beef. I’m sure I saw a vegetable there somewhere too.
A bit of fun adapting (Marian) or not (Callum and Adam) to the absence of all those whizz band gadgets, scales, recipes, etc etc.
Aaron is doing a giant beef pot pie with rosemary potato and honey glazed pumpkin, green beans. Adam has swapped his meatballs for kofta (with a few odd ingredients and time consuming garlic crushing) – and has problems with the grill so they don’t cook very well. Johno is on deserts – crumble, bread and butter pud. They all seem to be working well as a team, helping each other out (albeit with a bit of angst on Johnos part as to whether pastry is in the realm of the desert person!), and seem happy with what they are producing.
For the Reds, Courtney’s meatballs get the tick of approval from the Colonel and Matt, but Callum cops a bollocking from Gary – the first of several on camera critiques of his work from the G’s – as he struggles to make an apple upside down cake. Has to toss the first batter (same mistake as last week, failure to blend his butter and sugar properly). Then Claire tells him not to bother with custard because she needed his help on mains – but he starts anyway. Jimmy doesn’t want Claire to even taste it – because its burnt and nasty, but Callum is a clueless puppy.
Finally its two o’clock and the troops arrive – who quickly make it clear that they will eat and enjoy pretty much all of it…
Looks like Blue must be a winner with their two nice deserts and wider selection of dishes…and Matt certainly seems to think Johno’s deserts are a winner.
But no it is all a fake out. Turns out that Adam’s kofta and yoghurt were burnt and not very tasty; Aaron’s veges were a bit underdone. And for Red, Courtney’s meatballs were the star of the day.
So its a massacre, and the Blue not so Dream Team is in elimination. Some angst about whether or not Adam should use his munity pin given it was his dish that did them in and he was teamleader. But his team mates all make generous comments saying he won it fair and square, use it, and so, leaving with tear filled eyes.
So tomorrow its Johno, Marian and Aaron up for the chop on a nutty challenge. All a bit unfair really, given menugate and that they had fewer people to start with (and seemed to do a pretty good job).
The preview has Aaron saying he is going to guess walnut for anything he doesn’t know, so either he is out or its another fakeout and one of the two favourites is in trouble.
Meanwhile the CCCJA team is out to lunch….
I was planning on using some of the hotel’s whizz-bang free’n'fast internet thingy to watch some of last night’s episode on line… but now I don’t have to! Thanks Pinto and Kate (NTK). Excellent – feel as though I was there.
Dinner was fabulous, but I kept getting stuck in a Masterchef rut when trying to describe the food: “amazing” “awesome” “such textures” “flavour combinations”. Aaaargh! I’m sure I used to be more articulate.
I have a bad feeling it’s going to be Jono.
Hope I’m wrong.
Injera – yes, I too am suffering dysgastria during fine dining. I reach for a superlative, pause for what seems 5 minutes as I mentally cross off bew-ti-iful/goooorgeous/stunning/different, and end up meekly muttering ‘good’. Waiter gives me a FFS staredown and correspondingly the service levels decline….
Dysgastria! Brilliant.
Thanks guys it looks like the episode is going to be a good one will watch it later today. If Aaron dodges a bullet again…..
Why did Adam have to use his pin last night didn’t marion get to see it was a taste test first?
2 million viewers last night even up against State of Origin.
Traditionally there has been a slight drop off with MC when up against SOO but not last night.
SOO still rated 2nd overall and won in NSW & Qld.
With it being a skills and food identifying test tonight then surely Aaron’s days are numbered as these are both tests you’e expect Marion & Jono to blitz at.
Would be nice if MC contestants ‘refreshed’ their cliches for the last couple of weeks to keep us engaged:
“Im stoked’ , swap for’ Im fireballed’
‘Im gutted’ – flip to ‘Im deboned’
“Im up for elimination” – “Im poop shooted”
“Why did Adam have to use his pin last night didn’t marion get to see it was a taste test first?”
1) Yes, she did
2) Because he isn’t Marion!
Sooty – Double Cranko Masterchef
CG : LMAO at your comment re the three judges arriving at the field kitchen.
I want to know what Aaron did to entertain the troops. Was it stand up?
I thought Adam’s drill sergeant routine was hilarious. He’s like a big kid : don’t care if it was a set up, loved him running into Marion’s room screaming “Grasby you need to be up and changed in 15 seconds”. Can’t imagine Claire carrying on like that, though she did well with her assertive voice trying to reign “loose Callum” (love it Polly!) in.
Think Courtney might be taking over as first pick for teams. Reds could probably have only served two dishes, with those meatballs still taking most of the votes.
The horror, the horror
General MacArthur turned up wearing a cravat atop a tank. George wanted to be up in the chopper !
Callum is unable to follow instructions. Claire’s subtle instructions were too much for him.
Why did Adam not do a lasagne after the ‘negotiations’ ? Much easier than koftas which are afterall another word for meatballs, rissoles …
Courtney was taking her military experience very seriously.
I wonder if the judges realise they are inducing a Pavlovian response from Callum?
Each time he completely stuffs up -
they shout at him,
he pretends to do what he’s told, then secretively goes on making it worse;
they shout some more,
he looks hang-dog ( or is it sheepish?)
- and then gets his head patted and given a biscuit (given praise, avoids elimination, sent out to great restaurant) for eventually doing as he is told (Good! BOY !!)
not surprising then, that he keeps making the same type of mistake. It’s a basic puppy training error – lots of proud owners do it.
As for the challenge -
if you were a anglo-saxon male coming out of the bush after 3 weeks of iron rations, wouldn’t you head straight for Courtney? no matter what she was serving.
ha Rusty – problem is , Courtney is serving up Lemon Delicious
Too true rusty.
Pity that Courtney bats for the other team.
Rusty – think they ought to try controlled crying with Callum, and remove his blankee
PAUL
qLD NSW dead rubber who cares? Irrelevent ratings
Raver post 121Sooty post 124
As I said … its obvious! (the fix is in Paul)
Pollyw post 119
You shoulda used the word Whawsum. Then you would have received the maitre D’s sneer of approval
Skt _ good one – I was thinking of ‘fair shake of the nitro pump’
No-one has yet picked up on the best strategic move of the season so far – Jimmy picking the “weaker team”.
This was inspired, Survivor-like stuff (from a show where strategic smarts are sadly lacking).
Jimmy’s thinking (hopefully) went something like this:
Both teams are fairly strong – so roughly a 55:45 chance of going home if he picks the weaker team (and there’s no knowing that the smaller team won’t get Private Bloggs from the Catering Corps to make up the numbers). So roughly even chance of being in the bottom team.
So – forget about picking the team which you think is most likely to win. ASSUME you’re going to lose.
So which team do you want to be on? Red team – if you lose, you’ve got a one-in-five chance of being sent home. And that’s one in five against the weaker cooks in the competition.
Blue team, you’ve got a one-in-four, because Adam has immunity. And you’re up against Jonothan and Marion, so you’re probably thinking you’ve got maybe a one-in-three or maybe even just a one-in-two chance of going home, against Aaron.
So Jimmy’s picked a 20% chance of going home vs a 25-50% chance. No brainer.
The upside as well, is that if the red team does win, he’s created a situation where Jonothan and Marion have a 33% chance of going home – because Adam has immunity on a now-smaller team. If Jimmy was on a five-person blue team which lost, then Jono and Marion face a 25% chance.
So by picking red, Jimmy has minimised his chances of elimination and increased the chance of eliminating a much stronger competitor.
Inspired stuff. Finally, as we’re getting close to the business end, someone is thinking strategically.
What was it with Jimmy’s hamstring injury? Have they been at Twister.
Last night might have been subtitled “Inglourious Custerds” or “Aslopalypse Now”…”A Few Good Menus”
Nicely put Matt. I too thought Jimmy’s move was brilliant. Made me laugh when a few commented that they didn’t understand his choice!
Matt 135
I thought the same when he picked though I didn’t do the maths
Pollyw
how about fair shake of the MC unsplit hollandaise sauce bottle?
Matt
tend to agree, but that reeks of a SHOCK conspiracy on Jimmy’s part.
As
i said earlier I’m glad he picked the right team
Pity Aaron was on the blue’s. that is insurance for the 2 uber chefs not to get boned if blue lost.
yes paul i know that negates the big C theory. gimme time.
i’ll think of summat else.
RarelySeen – I thought lasagne or pasta with rich bolognaise sauce would have been a good choice too. Even a homey mac cheese would have gone down a treat. Maybe there was no pasta as part of their ingredients, or not enough ovens to have baked pasta and Jono’s desserts.
Matt – love your theory – very clever thinking on Jimmy’s part. But I’m tempted to believe that as the blue teams of both seasons have had such a terrible record (I think it’s a total of 2 wins, one draw) – no matter what, you never back the blue team. And you’re absolutely right – when blues inevitably lose, Jimmy would be setting himself up to be boned facing the likes of Jono and Marion.
raver
absolutely love your blogs
But judging from the number of posts here, it would seem that this open post on last nights ep was even more fun than watching the recent bonings in the Gummint!
wonder if being a contestant on MC comes with a life long therapist as part of the exit contract, can picture Callum to his psych….
” and then, after the lamington put downs, which we’ren’t really my fault cos I havent been to Laming before although been to Lower Lame, Gary took me aside and said Callum, son, I will take you under my wing and show you the basics. It was then after seeing Gary expected me to make a 17 tiered opera cake without any previous music experience that I choked, on the buttercream actually, Gary didnt cream it properly”
Injera 117
for higher culture you could have tried far gone exquisite
Matt – I love that theory and my opinion of Jimmy has sky rocketed because of this.
Sourkraut – Last year I put up open posts when the competition got to the pointy end. I will put one up and if people are using them I am happy to.
Hey Matt since you were brilliant on the Jimmy strategy then can you tell me why Claire picked Callum first. Just watching the episode now and Callum is a disaster and has been for a few weeks.
Matt great theory of how someone should pick a team IF they were being strategic but think you are giving Jimmy WAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYY too much credit!! I think the extent of Jimmy’s strategy was claiming a hamstring injury so he got a free ride to the field kitchen and got to conserve his energy.
BTW, why the hell was part of the challenge to carry 20kg backpacks along a muddy trail to the field kitchen. More Amazing Race crap. Arriving first didn’t seem to be much of an advantage. Although I think Adam should have said: we were here first, we get to keep our menu that we’ve already started and let Claire come up with something different.
What if there had been a grossly overweight and unfit contestant (don’t trust a skinny chef, remember!), who took hours and was shattered making to the field kitchen? Why was physical fitness and endurance part of a cooking challenge?
Agree with Matt on the logic behind the strategy issue, I’d been thinking the same thing, but just seems a bit above the level of thinking we’ve seen of Jimmy thus far. Can’t help thinking that personalities – isn’t he Callum’s best mate, and maybe wanted to stay with the other returnee and be protected from Aaron’s wrath? Maybe Claire picked Callum so that Jimmy was unlikely to be picked by Adam and would come along for free (he is usually ok on deserts even if not a team player)??
And yes the fitness sprints in this one and Paris are pretty weird. Would be much more fun if the producers made the judges do it too!
On open posts, I actually much prefer Ravers overview things as a discussion starter – that way one doesn’t actually have to watch the thing when its looking like a shocker as on Tuesday, whereas the meanderings above only made sense if you had watched! But hey…
notice how Geo kept Colonel Chlorophyl at bay in a real nacho potato environmen and
let out buutter love instead
NT Kate – I still do the recap, but it means people who want to discuss it can do so earlier. It does split the comment threads however. Will see how it works and see what people think.
And if you really want to think about strategy games, maybe Adam’s koftas (and presumably not checking Aaron’s veges) were a good choice. After all, he had immunity and losing gave him the chance to take out one of the better competitors.
Another factor in both Jimmy and Adam’s thinking could have been that in the team challenges, who has the best cooks doesn’t always seem to determine outcomes due to their crappy team skills, and both Aaron and Johno have proved more than a bit erratic of late.
I know Adam seems like a nice guy on screen, but he is a lawyer after all…
The open posts are great for people who are playing along at home – similar to watching and tweeting – but, as Kate (NTK) says, it’s easier for those of us who missed the ep to catch up with a real post. Of course, it’s pretty much my fault that RR couldn’t do the post last night! The comments posted after the show were more analytical/descriptive, so easier to get a sense of the overall show – and some of the strategies (thanks Matt!) that played out. Looking forward to reading tonight’s wrap-up and comments to see what I’ve missed, thanks to the ongoing Sydney Festival Of Eating.
RR – Claire picking Callum first? IF you can credit her with any strategic thinking, then it is for the same reason.
If she loses then she’s picked the one person she’s all but guaranteed to beat in an elimination. Using that logic, picking Marion is the worst strategic move you could make at this point of the competition. Except in this case, more of which later.
The group challenges at this end of the competition are much tighter, so your strategic thinking has to go a bit further than simply picking Joanne as the opposing team captain. Jono’s Joanne pick a few weeks back was another bit of inspired strategy. However, she won the challenge, which proves that you can’t always rely on your opponent to do what you’d like them to.
So if you CAN’T control your opposition, you need to make sure you are putting yourself in the best position not to be eliminated. The best way, of course, is to win the challenge. But That’s a 50/50 proposition.
So – best strategic move? Jimmy picking the red team, giving himself a one-in-five chance of being eliminated. (actually one in 10, if you consider a 50% chance of losing the challenge), as opposed to a one in three chance.
Second best? Claire picking Callum, thereby almost guaranteeing she’s safe.
Third-best strategic move? Adam picking Marion. What he’s done is (if Marion is as good as everyone thinks) give himself a slight edge to win the challenge. What he’s also done is ensure that if he loses the challenge, his strongest competition goes from a one-in-five chance of being eliminated (he’s assuming here that he’ll have the five man team), to a one in four chance. Or, if he ended up with the short-handed team, a one-in-three chance.
Now, all of this assumes that the contestants have a modicum of strategic thinking, which I’m not sure is the case. The scenarios above are based on what I think they SHOULD have been thinking when they made those choices.
But the strategy at this end of the show isn’t just to cook well. That’s part of it, of course. You need to be selling yourself (and your cookbook) to the judges. But the ONLY strategic reason for doing that is so that when there are three of you in front of the judges for elimination, they belive your tosh about your food dream.
Your main strategy has to be to ensure that:
(a) Your strongest competition is in front of the judges when you are not; and,
(b) When you are in front of the judges you are with the two weakest contesteants possible.
BTW, as a Survivor addict, I’d be the worst possible Masterchef contestant (and I can cook a bit). I wouldn’t be the one tearing up in front of the camera and saying “oh, it’s so heartbreaking that someone has to go”. I’d be the one asking myself “WWERD – or, What would Evil Russell Do?”, sabotaging team challenges and hanging over the balcony during eliminations calling out the wrong advice. And I’m not sure I could resist the temptation during Masterclass to say, “yeah, it’s got texture Gary – the texture of wet cardboard.”
That last paragraph settles it – Matt, you absolutely must try out for Masterchef next year! It would be (to steal a Masterchef phrase) AWESOME to have a strategic reality-show comp player on there. WWERD indeed. (Of course, ER didn’t win…)
So disappointed they played this episode straight.
Surely the army theme warranted Matt turning up as General Sir Anthony Cecil Hogmanay Melchett VC DSO KCB, with George as the Captain Kevin Darling and Gary as Lt. George C. St Barleigh.
Calum did however get into the theme with a superb impersonation of Private S Baldrick, the worst cook in military history.
Ironically, for those who remember, Baldrick’s signature dishes included “cream custard” – later revealed to be cat’s vomit.
Injera – If you could cook half decent, then a combination of good strategy and some evil pieces to camera would ensure that you’d avoid most eliminations and when you didn’t, the producers would be inclined to keep you around for ratings reasons.
You’d almost guarantee yourself second place. And let’s see, first place gets you the cookbook deal, $100k and a few appearances on the Today Show.
Second place gets you the ABC series, a cookbook, and the belief of the TV watching public that you were the better cook
So true, Matt! Second is the way to go. Which only leaves the question… are you going to apply?!
Injera
but in the second one he bloody well should have. Bah!
Matt
if you could cook half decent you would not have a celluloid doll in hells chance of winning (paul Odds please?).
Look what happened to EVIL Chris B!
Boner
The worst cook in history was the chef in Alaska who invented the BMTS. However Callum’s chunderiferous efforts come close and with a little seasoning… Who Knows?
Matt,
You must be a poker player because only a poker player could think that someone could run through all those permutations and calculations in that short a time frame under intense pressure and scrutiny.
Like the way you think though.
Personally don’t think Jimmy’s got that sort of guile in him.
Injera,
Don’t think I’d apply. I like to think I’d give it a red-hot go, but it’d be too long away from a young family etc.
Also, my food dream is to keep earning enough money to have the odd lunch at Rockpool, Lucios and Longrain. (also, for the Sydney types, try Bodega in Surry Hills – awesome stuff). I’ve worked in a kitchen and it’s hot, dirty and smelly. Best to be sitting beside the white table cloth, not washing it.
But I reckon next season will see someone get strategic. The show’s crying out for it.
sour,
If you had a genuine strategist on the show I reckon they could get through a few rounds easily.
Raver
I was not suggesting it for each ep, not by a long shot as it would lose the novelty value, and as I said i love your recaps.
What i was saying is that judging by the number of posts here (IS THAT A RECORD?) everyone seems to have had lots of fun lampooning a vey lampoonable show and ep
Paul – hilarious that you say that. I was winning an online tournament while writing that!
Part of me agrees with you re Jimmy. I’m not sure if anyone is really strategic on this show.
Masterchef doesn’t lend itself to the sort of Nashian game thoery that Survivor does, but there are flashes of strategic thinking.
No-one’s yet putting a string of stratgic moves together though. They’re thinking one challenge at a time, and while they’re under a lot of pressure, Survivor contestants do it all the time without food or sleep.
What’s clear though is that quite a few contestants don’t realise that strategy should be integral to this competition. Worst two strategic moves so far were Jake not standing up for himself when the team had to pick the people for the elimination challenge, and in the same one, Marion virtually volunteering herself and then throwing away her immunity pin.
In their defence, I don’t think we saw half of that discussion. Also, in Jimmy’s defence, there were a few cutaway shots, so we don’t know how long he took to make his decision.
Capt. Kevin Darling (played by George): [Darling and Melchett (played by Matt) are both eating a posh supper, which has actually been prepared by Baldrick (played by Callum)] I suppose the teams have have gone over the top by now.
General Melchett (Matt): Yes – God, Id give anything to be out there with them, dodging saucepans and flying custard instead of sitting here drinking this Chateau Lafite, and eating these filets mignons with sauce bearnaise!
Capt. Darling (George): My thoughts exactly, sir. Damn this Chateau Lafite! [He takes a nice, big, satisfied sip]
General Melchett (Matt): Uncle Bertie and I used to break wind for our college. [Eats a filet mignon in sauce bearnaise] Slightly unusual taste, this sauce bearnaise.
Capt.Darling (George): Yes, sir. [His face shows it tastes vile] And to be quite frank, sir, these mignons are a little, well… dungy.
General Melchett (Matt): What on earth’s wrong with that cook?
[eats a bit of Plum Duff, is repulsed by its taste and spits it out] Ah, Jumping Jerries! Are you sure these are real raisins in this Plum Duff?
Capt. Darling (George): Oh, yes, I’m sure they are, sir.
Everything will be all right once the cream custard arrives.
oh…
apologies to Ben Elton & Richard Curtis
As I recall, Survivor didn’t start to attract really “strategic” players until at least season 3 or 4. Which suggests that as MC continues, more strategic players will apply and more strategic thinking will go into player’s conduct, how the present themselves, how they choose teams for challenges, etc.
Then again, I could argue that Poh was very “strategic” last year in the most facile way: using her “charm”/giggle/fluttering-eyelashes/camisoles to win the hearts and other body parts of the judges and producers. And while her strategy turned certain segments of viewers off, it got her back into the comp after two eliminations and to 2nd place and the career opportunities that have followed.
Wouldn’t it be great to see someone get in next season who can cook but whose only goal is to stir up shit and excercise some of these strategic moves – ie like Russell from Survivor. Wonder what MC does to screen for these types?
While I don’t think Jimmy has the smarts to be as strategic or calculating as Matt, I do think those contestants who were earlier eliminated and got time off to think about things would be best-placed to come back with some strategic moves.
Of all the possible strategies last night, the one I can believe is Adam. By picking Marion and Jono and knowing he had the immunity pin, Adam was either going to win or if not, there was a good chance to knock off a top-three player. Adam’s over-acting about whether or not to use the immunity pin plays into this theory. It also demonstrates he has the nouse to make sure he looks like a good guy to the viewers. Of all the remaining contestants, I reckon Adam is the sharpest and has the potential to be the most conniving.
Agreed CG. That nice screen persona occasionally drops and gives us hints of the evil lawyer underneath in my view (I know the breed) and that end scene was certainly overacted (though not necessarily for this reason).
Though I actually do actually think it is also possible that Johno might have been being a bit strategic in stuffing up some of his earlier team efforts. After all he is has a pretty extensive food knowledge and basic skills and has shown pressure tests don’t phase him. It is obviously a high risk strategy, not least in undermining your cooking credibility, but if you do get through, getting the practice early on can only stand you in good stead for the finals given last years format.
So spilling the odd sauce to beat out someone like Joanne, or messing the odd desert doesn’t seem that farfetched…And his return to form last night could be a recognition that his potential competion in an elim round was tougher than he would prefer…
CG – funnily enough Poh was criticised in an Age GG letter today for prancng about in her presumably teeney Daisy Dukes in Malaysia in her latest ‘Look at Poh, oh Yeah I cook too’ episode – a sign of lack of RESPECT ( just a little bit) for her fellow countrymen
Matt – Just as I was reading your post I thought if you are ever on Survivor I want to be in your alliance. BTW they are filming two season back to back of Survivor in Nicaragua.
Injera -Like the royal family who all cannot travel on the same plane, I think the issue is that we cannot go out the same night when Masterchef is on…..
CG – Adam is my new fave at the moment shows a cheeky sense of humour and his great cooking.
@tom_colicchio has tweeted from Adelaide central Market in praise of Richard Gunner’s meats. He is in SA in holiday, tweeting that he is not doing any appearances just having a break BUT I am fantasising that he will be a judge for the final MC. That would kick arse!!!!
Matt, agree about most of the strategic stuff, and would love to see you on, but Jimmy choosing red dent give him a 1/5 instead of 1/3, the teams were even before he chose, so he had to be in the biggest team. So it was either 1/5 (red) or 1/4 (blue if Adam used his pin). I think he did make the best move though, both for that slight number advantage, and because there were weaker or more inconsitant cooks on the red team (callum, maybe Clair and Courtney)
Zibb – entirely correct. I had one in four in my earlier post and had a mini brain explosion writing the second.
But looking at tonight’s result, looks like the Jimmy/Adam strategy worked….
Matt – quite rightly you should take a bow. Oh and so should Jimmy.
Though even though I like your rationale so much better, I wonder if he just decided the blue team is always jinxed.
whoa, so many comments!
did any of you notice the shot of Jono cooking where some object on his bench was blurred out by the editors…?
why would they need to do that?
Leave a Comment