Masterchef Australia – From Tuna To Tears
It is the last week before the finals, Claire is a known front runner now, and they give her ten more minutes in the immunity challenge. I thought this was completely unfair to the other contestants, who have had to do the challenges in the allotted time in previous weeks, where they might have had to opportunity to win an immunity pin. Also by some miracle she had managed to beat sushi chef Shaun Presland, she would have waltzed straight into finals week on this advantage.
The collegiate feel of the peanut gallery continued with them calling out tips to Claire.
It is obvious Claire Winton Burn does not like to fail, or she is totally exhausted, as she started crying towards the end of the 1 hour and 45 minute challenge, and seemed to take awhile to stop. She was still sobbing whilst waiting to get the judges results. To be honest it started to irritate me. Yes it was a tough challenge, however it is meant to be.
By the way how good did that chunk of tuna look? Tonight she had to “cook” a tuna plate, consisting of a tuna avocado roll, tuna taco, and tuna tataki on a daikon radish roll. Considering how difficult precise Claire found the challenge, it would have been an absolute disaster if someone like Jimmy or Aaron had had to front up for the test.
Speaking of Aaron he did crack me up when he said “You know you’re having a bad day when your themometre cracks in your oil”.
I love the way at judging when Matt Preston was talking about Claire’s dish he was gushing and saying ”There are amazing amounts of things that are right on this”. However when talking about Shaun’s, after he had smacked down Donna Hay for being too gushy, he said the taco shell was too dark.
Donna gave Claire a seven, as did George and Matt for a total of 21. Shaun was looking worried until Donna flipped him a 10, Matt gave him a 9, and George gave him a ten. I think he scored the highest of any celebrity chef this year.
So tomorrow night it is game on with them all getting to showcase their own styles for some special guest judges.

80 comments
She got an extra ten minutes? FFS. Turned over during the judging and couldn’t believe how much Matt was trying to make compliments for Claire’s dish happen. “What about this RICE!” gush gush. Had to turn it off again. Glad she didn’t get a munity. I’ve heard munities are now endangered, particularly since they have been so badly misused.
I think the extra ten minutes was just so she would get something roughly like the dish onto the plate for judging. It would’ve been a short show otherwise. They would’ve had to allot all the spare judging time to close ups of Claire wiping away the tears.
I’m sure they would not have given her the extra time if she was in the running to beat the chef. I think i remember extra time once before – in a group challenge?
I felt for claire tonight. I’m guessing she is not used to not being good at something. If I tried something I had never done before I’d give it a go but not expect too much, but she was crushed that her skills were not up to par.
The chef seemed like a nice guy.
It was a bit tragic how Matt P was desperate to find something better about claire’s dish – valiant effort at suspense building, but not really possible given she had had a melt down and needed the extra time to even finish.
i haven’t sat down to watch a full episode since Marion left. The inconsistencies are less tolerable now that the really skillful cooks have been eliminated; not because they aren’t good enough but because the group challenge structure protects the less skillful cooks in what is essentially an individual competition…i’m still finding it difficult to swallow that irrational concept.
The Masterchef producers may have sunk their own boat.
If I remember correctly, Japanese apprentices take around 10 years to be considered competent on bladework. I seriously think that no-one on Masterchef had a chance of winning this challenge – not Claire, nor Adam or Marion or anyone from this or last season. It wasn’t about how good you were at mixing and heating flavours (especially when Claire was complimented on one of the few cooked elements of the dish, the rice), it was about how precisely you could cut something. Probably the most stacked-against-the-contestant chef challenge I’ve ever seen in my opinion.
Seepi – extra time was given in the CWA challenge.
Suziwong – you are right if you get lucky and a picked in the winning team each week, you can minimise the amount of elimination challenges you face.
Anonymouse do you think they put this challenge in the last week to ensure no one won it so no immunity pin. Felt sorry for Shaun slicing his hand the night before.
I can not for one moment imagine Marion giving in like that.
I would like to have seen Alvin, who has been complimented on his knife skills by a celebrity chef, in this challenge. I don’t think he would’ve made such a mess of it. Her problem is that she obviously is too used to avoiding anything difficult or unpleasant by gently sobbing til some male offers her a shoulder, when she does’t get what she wants.
As for it being the worst day of her life, if that’s as bad it gets, she’s obviously effing Cinderella.
To think that the eliminated Jonno was being told off only two nights ago for his inability to plate up in time at this stage of the comp.
Agree with Seepi – if there had been any chance of her doing well I doubt they would have given her any extra time.
And the chef still got top marks with stitches in his finger!
They could rename the show one dimensional chef. Jimmy can only do curry, Callum only does desserts. Donna Hay only has one tone of voice. I never thought I would say this but bring back Jonathan
What can I say, Claire has good knife skills and does a mean tuna taco
Gary – and everyone in the peanut gallery – knew she couldn’t win – I didn’t mind the extra minutes given, I thought it was a kind gesture. But that poor woman is a BASKET CASE. I think she’s over it all.
RR – I doubt the producers would have minded too much if a miracle occured and the immunity badge was won; if they hated having certain contestants around at this late stage they could have long ago contrived a challenge the contestant was no good at to get rid of them (well, unless you’re Aaron going up against Marion).
It wouldn’t surprise me though if they let the last chef challenge be a hard one (as far as technique goes) to show what a skilled chef can do (it’s hard to show how great a skilled chef can make food taste on the tv. But you can certainly show how great a skilled chef can make a dish look and Japanese food’s some of the best for showing off visual style).
Lucky Claire didn’t have to carve up a whale..ie Matt Preston.
BDD – No, but she did get to blubber a bit
Has anyone tested that balcony for 6 amatas + Matt Preston
Or for that matter, studio oxygen levels when Donna Hay is judging
librarygirl – totally agree – Not even Julie would have ended up a sobbing mess like that and she could cry at anything. I actually felt embarrassed for Claire tonight. Must say the gallery were very generous though with their encouragement and suggestions, but I’d like it if someone had yelled “would you just stop crying and get it done.”
I didn’t find her crying to be irritating!
With Jonathan out of the comp, Claire is my favourite to win! I’m backing her because she’s likeable to an extent and she’s been a consistently good cook in the comp. Wouldn’t mind Alvin or Adam winning, but I wouldn’t be 100% happy.
I would hate to see Aaron, Callum, Courtney or Jimmy win! Courtney’s ok, but I don’t want an past eliminee to win!
Anyone watch the 7PM Project? JONATHAN WAS ON!
He was very awkward, but cute. He couldn’t stop laughing when the panel was making jokes about him. It was very endearing
Fides – of course the gallery was generous – one more night free of hearing her slumber to ” The Last Day on Earth”
I thought it a week or two ago, but I think Claire is just fed up with the whole thing – the waiting around, the set pieces to camera – she seems bored/ over it all.
Mind you, I still don’t like her – I’d prefer it if she either just left, or if she exploded properly and went down in a hail of … whatever it is that she CAN cook.
My metaphorical money is now on Adam.
If Claire got extre ten minutes to make her dish and then plate it,,, it would have been only fair if JONO would have got extra 4 minutes so he could have put some strawbrries and chocolate n rose petals that he made on the dish so he could have finished his dish and not just let him present that unfinished dish…
VERY VERY SHIIIIIITE DECISION MCHEF ,,,
Clair obviously didnt deserve this special treatment.
Thought I heard Snagglepus’ voice coming out of the TV during the 7pm project. Was it a Hanna Barbera retrospective, nupe it was Jono ‘coming down’ from Masterchef eviction…
‘heavens to murgatroyd, exit stage left’ – straight into really bad C10 panel shows from here on
Thanks Pollywaffle for the laughs and RR for the recap. It’s rare but I missed the show tonight,however was well hammered with the “World of Pain” teaser this afternoon.
If that’s the worst day of Claire’s life, I just want to see her candyass on a bike , flogging herself around France for three weeks.
Anthony, great tip!!
For those of us who missed it you can see Jono’s appearance on the 7pm Project here (Jono comes in about 2 minutes into the video).
http://7pmproject.com.au/video.htm?vxSiteId=7a6ab1fe-cd90-4143-bf79-ba376a096b2e&vxChannel=7PM%20Catch%20Up&vxBitrate=300
He does come across as nervous but endearing…I think like Chris B., Jono was the editors choice for “evil guy” this year and its a real shame if this editing and manufactured charicature also contributed to his early departure.
wow….two weeks off of Masterchef and Reality Ravings! Next time I stay with family it won’t be with a librarian sister without a television!
Yes, Jono seems quite dorky compared to his Masterchef edited persona. It makes me hope that in season 3 we’ll have someone get in who totally embraces having a bad guy persona and runs it to the hilt.
EvilChef, talking to camera: Tonight the mystery box challenge included some interesting items, such as the beef. It was really a really tender cut of meat… but not as tender as the freshly poached puppy I served for dinner to the other contestants last night. I told them it was veal. Mwahahahahaha! (twirls moustache)
Oh that extra 10 minutes was no advantage at all! Everyone knew that including Claire.
It was simply granted to allow her at the very least to present a damn plate to the judges. Personally it would have been kinda funny to see her present nothing!
Just saw Wednesday night preview…so 3 of them are eliminated one night? Woohoo!!
There was no way they could have thought Plate 1 it was Claire’s.
There was no cucumber underneath and there was just a piece of avocado on the sushi. It looked like it had been done by an amateur which is what she is. Doubt she’ll stand up to the stress of the finals so I predict it will be a male this year.
Adam is cool under pressure generally, so he should win. Australia could do with an Asian cookbook given it’s changing demographics and it would stand out in the “ocean” of western style cookbooks already on the market.
As to any of them actually becoming chefs I doubt it. It’s actually quite hard work, stressful and horrible hours. Not to mention after a while boring.
The lucky few chefs who get a name for themselves actually stop cooking and become executive chefs. The masterclasses that G &G do is the most cooking they’ve done in years! You won’t find George actually cooking in any of his restaurants. He couldn’t do MC and run 3 restaurants and write abook. However his restaurants are booked out thanks to his ability to market himself.
I guess that’s the bottom line – marketing yourself and one has to have something to diferentiate him/her self from the pack.
From that point of view this year’s lot have actually done really well even if they are being called “one trick ponies.”
I’m finding it really hard to pick a winner here, and I don’t mean that in a positive way. Adam and Alvin must be feeling pretty confident right now.
I think the 10 minutes extra was a kind gesture to make sure she had a plate, otherwise the show would have been ruined and the whole thing a devastating failure. There was no way they would have voted her to win, her plate was obviously inferior but they went through the motions anyway. Japanese is not something you just pick up and give it a whirl in one day, it was an impossible task and for once less about the “flavour” and truly about the skill and presentation. I felt for her and I’m glad they are cutting 3 tonight, it’s time to wrap up this show. I feel like it’s lost focus lately, all the momentum got messed up with the eliminees coming back. I don’t even know who I want to win anymore.
Extra time was given in a celeb chef challenge last year I think.
I felt for Claire – the pressure on these people must be enormous. Haven’t we all been in a position where we just wish we could run away? I didn’t find the extra 10 mins unfair. It was clear she wasn’t going to win – why humiliate her in the process?
And Jonothan was cute on 7pm – I’ve found him to be cute on the show and really can’t understand why he was so hated. Hopefully all those haters watched and saw what he was really like.
My son asked me this morning if we can go to Jonothan’s new restaurant today LOL
dmc,
agree. It’s about who is the least worst.
Would Gary have given any of the guys an extra 10 minutes? Last night was a repeat of his form from early in the season when he’d selectively give extra advice to anyone sporting a vagina. And would basically tell the blokes to suck it up, and work it out for themselves. At this stage of the comp, this was a pathetic and embarrasing performance. Made worse by Claire’s simpering impersonation of a medieval damsel in distress. Matt’s attempts at trying to justify a 7 outta 10 for a dish only worthy of 5 at most were equally absurd. So the art of sushi hinges on the taste of the rice? What crap.
I could just imagine Gary with his mother hangups hitting on Irmgaard.
Andre Ursini has a rort going here. There are online auctions for him to come to your place and do a four course dinner for eight.Value $2500
i noticed the editing was blatently falsified. when claires dish was tasted, i noticed donna clearly writing a ‘10′, as did george. makes me wonder if the ‘dish 1′ they had was actually shauns or if they just put it together in the editing room. i dun mind if the show is clumsy but when its just so OBVIOUSLY false it is very irritating.
They did write 10 – they wrote 7/10
If they’re cutting three tonight, I hope it’s Gary ,George and Matt.
claire gives little girl smile to matt , matt gets all excited asked claire how will you go tonight claire responds “bring it on ” the celeb chef comes out everyone goes ape pooh over him . claire gives him the little girl smile he of course falls for it matt calls out lets cook!! claire goes from “bring it on ” to can anyone help me pretty please and of course the celeb chef runs over and matt all goo goo gives her a extra ten minutes . what has happen to this series it is gone off the rails . at least matt is happy , ah claire, that baby girl smile !!!!
Claire de Looney
but would they write 10 before they write 7 cos im pretty sure donna wrote 10 first? my memory’s not good enough to say 100% that i’m right so i take it back masterchef if i’m not.
There’s some fun video footage on the MC website of the contestants doing a “5 minute challenge” where they each must create a dish in 5 minutes (with a timer on the screen). What’s fun is you can really see the rapport between them all, as each takes their turn and faces the challenge with everyone else watching around the kitchen bench at the MC house. (I think Adam begins a 10 seconds to go countdown for Aaron after only three minutes, which has Aaron almost rolling his eyes saying “that is my awesome friend Adam”. Marion is instinctively helpful and scoops out muck from Alvin’s hot oil without even being asked while he’s preparing something else.)
CG, from those videos, I can now see what you’ve been saying about Claire and how she loves the attention from the guys. She postures like she is queen of the kitchen.
Also from last night, I had this HORRIBLE image of Donna’s toes curling in her shoes when I went to bed – it wasn’t like she was orgasmic (which would have been worse I think) but rather, it was as if her toenails had suddenly taken a life of their own, grown uncontrollably and started curling up on themselves. And in those shoes she wears, there would have blood all over the kitchen.
Also, I don’t mean to dash hopes, but I’m pretty sure they’re only picking the bottom three to face elimination on Thursday (which is another 1 hour show), not actually throwing out three. So one more to lose and then we have our six worthy finalists, the best amata cooks in Australia. It is so hard to write that without scoffing, so I wonder how Gary will be able to say it like he means it?
@CG Thanks for that link. Jono looked so cute giggling like a schoolboy lol. Very endearing.
bdd@comment 37
LOL, best comment yet. And so obvious.
I notice Claire was showing no sign of her “world of pain” by the time of the judging. Even allowing for the filming time lag and makeup crew, she got over her annus horribilus in record time – not a puffy eye in sight.
Jonno seems to be having a great time, all these little insights and cheeky hints about Life in the MC House. He’s well out of it, methinks.
Claire’s dragged out “Shirley Temple” for the last leg of MC -Girlie Curls + ‘1,2,3′ …..’droopy lip, cry and smile’
Looking forward to her rendition of Animal Crackers in my Soup
There’s a song by Cream called World Of Pain.
Wake Up Little Sushi
brain dead dave, you just reminded me about something that got me so worked up yesterday!
I hate it when the contestants say: “i was in a world of pain!” SO ANNOYING!
But I think there needs to be a level playing field if someone else had received ten mins more in a previous beat the celeb challenge they may have beaten them and won a immunity pin, and still be in the competition or avoid elimination this week.
Culinary Boner – Don’t tell me we have vaginagate on Masterchef
Wallah – You’re back, I thought you had gone down in the plane with mining execs in Africa. You’ve been missed.
Brain Dead Dave – I guess considering last weeks fuckery is Claire, Adam and Alvin.
CG and Fides – Will check out 7pm link and masterchef footage, I think Claire just looks self conscious a lot of the time.
Jeanie – I think they are told to do that I noticed that last week.
BDD – I think its the new answer to whats up
I used to love reading this blog, but the comments here are so unbelievably cruel. They’re worse than the official site, even. Is there anywhere on the internet you can discuss or read about this show without people cutting the poor contestants to absolute shreds?
CoMe on,
Like the way you did, dear? Getting stuck into horrible Jonno and arrogant Aaron? And I think CG got a blast of your shredding tendencies, too.
We’re all guilty at some point. Even you.
Actually, it’s this hyperventilating tragedy queen act that annoys me, not just from Claire – most of the contestants do it at some point.
Watching the TDF and the ABC’s 4Corners doco on the Aussie troops in Afghanistan after MC does rather put these “worst day ever”, “stabbed to the heart” and “world of pain” cliches in perspective.
Sorry guys, I think Fides is right: I had another look at the preview, three are up for elimination – not three eliminated tonight. I guess you see/hear what you want to?!
But how are they going to get down to 2 persons by next Thursday?? I can’t remember how they did the final week of eliminations last year?
I had a sinking feeling last night that Claire was going to get the immunity. I started yelling at my husband how unfair it was (hubby doesn’t watch the show, he was in the other room). I couldn’t believe the advantages she was getting: using Shaun’s oil, extra help from Shaun and then the extra 10 minutes. Oi!
I think next year they need to re-think these celebrity chef challenges. As many have said, it is almost impossible for the contestants to beat a chef at one of his/her signature dishes they have cooked a million times. So keep the celebrity chefs but have both the chef and the contestant cook something new / a surprise or an interpretation. This would provide for much more interesting contests and perhaps a few more immunity pins could be won? Then have the celebrity chefs do their signature dishes for demonstration on Friday nights instead of the G’s doing 1.5 hour masterclasses.
Oh and Fides: thanks heaps for the image of Donna Hay’s deformed toenails that I hope I can erase from my mind before I go to bed tonight.
but I do think there is a bit of a big brother effect, in which the MC house becomes their reality a bit, and they really do get upset about their cooking missteps.
Claire and Callum seem to have bought into it the most this time around.
Yes, Raver. Vagina-gate is a good description. I demand a Royal Commission.
Just noticed that your site’s ads included this highly appropriate advert for a sushi-making machine – http://www.jlpackaging.com.au/food_processing_equipment.htm.
Perhaps instead of sneaking in booze, the peanut gallery – as you so rightly call them – should have snuck one of these onto the set to help Claire.
CG : lol that’s a pleasure! I’m a sucker for punishment, so I’ve now even googled “world’s longest toenails” – the toenails were not as bad as my visions, but the search also comes up with long fingernail images which are truly disturbing.
Here’s the link to the list of 5 minute videos – re Claire – it’s the bit when she stands with arms akimbo and says something like “right, any questions from the peanut gallery?”
http://www.masterchef.com.au/video.htm?vxSiteId=f8066236-e138-457a-95f4-298ed80718f8&vxChannel=S2MC_EditorsPicks
Sushi = Toe curling? What to make of this?
We know Matt has his moments stroking paella crusts, so imagine if Donna had started moaning when she saw the avocado on those sushi rolls. She kept it together pretty well, toes notwithstanding.
Fides – I have to be honest my ideal fantasy would be that sushi served by Adam Molenas.
I’m picturing that myself now… is your Adam M wearing a shirt?
I’m sticking to my fantasy of being fed something tall and sweet from Adriano
For me, its Geo dipping his head in chlorophyll and rubbing it all over Alvin
Alvin? Is that you?
Ahhhhh Polly – you’ve made me spit all over on my screen!!
Jono’s would involve Heston, a caramel bath and white chocolate candles. And they can feed each other his lust dessert.
Playing “is it pork or is it beef?” with Irmgaard….
My turn to spit on the screen!
yeesus!
no wonder Come oN ran creaming from this blog!
Have to concur with the blogger who yesterday reported no cooking caramel at Coles. You were bang on.
Fides – thanks for the link to the 5 minute challenges, they were kind of cute, and one or two even had useful cooking ideas/techniques!
Come On I just saw your comment now, I think this blog normally,(not all the time) is fairly balanced. I think most of the people on this blog want the best cook to win. So I suspect by next week, there will be a lot of Go Adam, go Claire’s and possibly a few going for Courtney. As with all forums people are judging from the editing they are seeing on TV. I think Adam is getting a great edit at them moment, as is Alvin and Courtney. Claire I am not too sure about.
Fides – I cannot see Claire on the Aaron – 5 mins Spag Cabonara, he is very natural on camera.
Brain Dead Dave – what is cooking caramel and if it was in the Masterchef Pantry then it must be common. Yeah?
Fides – of course Molenas is NOT wearing a shirt, it is only fantasies about Gary where the chef whites stay well and truly on.
Pollywaffle – I think any fantasy involving Geo has got to involve Callum.
Fides – come on liven the jono one up and stick a bit of nitro in there.
Brain Dead Dave – LMAO they have to bring Irmgard back as a guest for the final as one of THE judges.
I think any fantasy involving Geo has got to involve Callum. And sweat.
Raver – you have to watch the Claire making her flaming crepes (or Crepes Claire as the others name her dish) 5 min video to see her in action. She’s not sooo bad, but definitely different from the Claire we see at the MC kitchen.
Thanks everyone for helping me get rid of Donna toenail images – these new ones you’ve put into my head are almost as disturbing but strangely satisfying… I want MC to release a special calendar.
Wow. Someone told me about these blog sites where people get on and make incredible comments about people they don’t know based on edited situations shown on tv of people in pressure situations.
I wish I could be as perfect as all the people who comment on here. Perhaps if I dwelled in the cyber world too because my life outside was so boring, I might. I truly pity you all.
Horrified – Do you think these contestants would prefer no one talking about them at all?
Fides will check out the crepes video.
RR . Cooking caramel is caramel masakan according to Alvin’s recipe at Coles. I asked for it by name and the girl bless her ,took me a few aisles and pointed to a can of caramel for pouring on dessert puddings. Don’t think it’s that common, in fact Alvo’s recipe says one can substitute dark corn syrup.
Coles won’t have the Shaoxing wine either.This is for his caramelised pork gut greedout the other night.
Didnt see it. I’m Glad.
Bet the bloody tuna was cooked raw. YUCK
Geez, Horrified(74) , I feel smaller than one of Callum’s lamingtons.
I love it when people come on blogs and have a rant about people who get on blogs not having anything better to do. Pot. Kettle. Black.
Fides – checked out the crepes video, she seemed far more relaxed. But how long did it take to cook the crepe?
Leave a Comment