Masterchef Australia – Jimmy Is Eliminated Because Of His Curry
Firstly I think all those botoxed, and lifted ageing women out there should take a look at Maggie Beer to be shown you can be gorgeous and over sixty. She looked stunning tonight both with her funky necklace, and black dress, but also her general exuberance and jour de vivre. That last phrase was dedicated to Sourkraut.
Secondly finally the right person was eliminated. Jimmy showed just how out of his depth he was with him creating much simpler dishes then the other three. All the others food was much more high end which is what we should expect at this time of the competition.
Maggie was guest judge tonight on the episode where the final four had to outline what their cook book would be about if they won the title of Masterchef.
Claire’s was going to be called From The Hearth to be about gutsy, honest and timeless food.
Callum’s is to be a Cook’s Roadmap, like a Stephanie Alexander but based on cooking techniques rather than ingredients. Gary said to George that this was something they had thought of as well. Which did get me wondering if Callum’s cook book had been workshopped prior to the episode.
Jimmy’s was to be called Flavours From My Home and it is about getting people to use spices. I am still not sure why he was one of the two chosen ones to go to receive a spice masterclass by Christine Mansfield.
Adam would call his book Two Asian Kitchens, it would be about the traditional and the modern dishes. I loved the scathing look Adam gave Gary when he butted in to say that is about you being from one asian country and living in another. Uh no Gary that was not what Adam meant.
Tonight the chefs had 2 1/2 hours to produce three dishes which would showcase their cookbook/food philosophy, and all of their plates looked pretty delicious.
I loved Adam’s Heston Blummenthal impersonation with using agar, and ensuring his ingredients were not too acidic.
Claire was first to be judged she had made scallops with crispy pork belly and apple. Maggie would prefer it without the pork.She thought this was a city dish.
The judges turned up their nose at the just which was served with a stunning looking roast beef with potato gratin. All the judges thought it had too much wine in it. George said if he got the receipe from her book he would be pretty disappointed.
Her dessert Matt loved the orange blossom pannacotta, and thought it was akin to kissing a girls neck. Which actually gave me shivers down my spine, but not in a good way.
Gary for once couldn’t decide whether he liked it or not even though any ingredient mixed with cream normally gets the thumbs up from him.
Callum was judged next, and I know he was doing techniques out of each chapter, however there was no consistency of theme. He cooked Coconut Mussels. Maggie thought it was exciting and perfectly cooked. This lent weight to the rumour that Maggie knows Callum’s mother, as Matt thought the curry was unbalanced with too much fish sauce.
However his roast pork belly with scallops with celeriac and his Chocolate Fondant with Orange and Date Ice Cream was met with raptures.
Jimmy’s to savoury dishes looked great, however he was criticised that his crispy skin duck with tamarind glaze - was over cooked. And his prawn curry sauce tasted soapy according to Gary. I was thinking it was all going to be disasterous for him, as his Chai Latte Brulee was not even set, however the flavour was apparently fantastic. And Matt Preston thought it was the best dish flavour wise.
Adam’s dishes were probably the most unusual and complex. He cooked Haianese Lobster Rice which Matt thought was rich and sophisticated but had not lost the soul of the dish. His next was a smoked Kingfish chirashi su. Did he smoke the fish himself? I did not see him do it but that doesn’t mean anything. George said “He is a legend.”
But Matt didn’t like the square of green tea jelly.
His dessert was a disaster, he was told his Chinese churos with salted duck egg custard did not appeal to the western palate. By the expressions on the judges faces as they were tasting it you would have thought they were eating cows lips.
It was a no brainer who was going it had to be Jimmy who has been out of his depth since he returned to the competition.
UPDATE: Jimmy to open an Indian restaurant. The press release says:
He plans to open his dream Indian restaurant later this year in Surry Hills, Sydney.
“I’ve already found the premises, I have a head chef and I’m devising menus,” he says. “My favourite part of any day is walking down the street and someone coming up and saying they want to taste my curries – they’ll soon be able to come to my restaurant.
“The benefit of being eliminated the first time was that I had some time at home and I knew that I really wanted to open up a restaurant. When I was cooking in the competition, I wasn’t thinking about winning or beating the others, I was just thinking about my restaurant.
“It’ll have a cocktail bar, nothing pretentious and good quality Indian food. I’ll be mainly doing front of house work but also in the kitchen and dealing with the menus. I can’t wait!”


-->
75 comments
Maggie Beer’s glasses were nice
Busting Up The Hearth should be an awesome read.
Why does Gary lick his knife ? Because he can?
Double dipping/tasting Callum. Give me a road map to get away from the overpraised grub.
Bye-bye Jimmy. I think you will be the most remembered contestant ever on masterchef! Jimmy is curry, it was his signature. Shame that he didn’t realise his full potential. He was actually really good with desserts. He probably wasn’t top 4 but was definitely top 20…
Moving forward, I think the final will be between Callum and Adam. Callum has become hugely popular and would definitely sell the most cook books. Callum trending on twitter is proof he is the most popular with the viewers.
Adam’s dessert didn’t cut it with our “Western palate”, according to Matt Preston who has eaten all over the world! Adam has the most credibility with the purists like MP and probably deserves to win – but I believe he will be the bridesmaid.
As for Claire, the crocodile tears will flow tomorrow night for sure. The last refuge of a scoundrel. She can cook but is destined to finish third.
Maggie was great and I would vote for her to replace Donna next year as a guest judge.
Jimmy’s cookbook should be called You Can’t Curry Love
Nicky – very funny
Geelong Deano – I like your logic however I think Adam will win, the stress will get to Callum.
Brain Dead Dave – I did notice the knife lick, never a good look.
Ruffys – agree very funky
Callum’s idea of breaking the cookbook into chapters based on techniques sounds a lot like the thick blue Women’s Weekly Cookbook that my mother gave me. I’m pretty sure that was also broken up by Roasting, Baking etc. If I recall correctly, it began each chapter with an overview of the technique and some tips, followed by a series of recipes using that technique. I’d check but I left the book at my boyfriend’s house. Its a great concept though, but I don’t think its original. Claire’s concept sounded good as well. I’d probably buy Claire and Callum’s books, not sure about Adam’s as I’m personally not a huge fan of cooking Asian.
Once again, Jimmy was convinced he had done wonders. Ha ha ha ha ha!
Little boy Callum’s cooking has certainly improved, but not to the extent of winning the title. I shall be Very Pissed Off should he win. Go Adam!
GeelongDeano, I would second your vote to replace Donna with Maggiw next season. But hey, MC2 has squandered a a significant amount of goodwill this season so it may not be a smart career move.
Thankfully, some of the spoliers predicting Jimmy in the top 2 were red herrings. Though, for a minute I thought Jimmy would get through despite the running brulee. (If he did, could someone go of MC3 and cook nothing but variants of chocolate cake get through to finals week?)
Claire’s concept-meh-had visions of the ‘Republican Motherhood’ and its domestic and public spheres. When she produced the pannacotta it immediately reminded me of this rant http://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/blogs/table-talk/panna-cotta-alert/20100715-10boj.html
Well, looks like we won’t be getting the hilarity of the public’s reaction to Jimmy winning Masterchef. The fallout from that happening could have been highly entertaining. I guess the one thing Jimmy couldn’t curry was favour.
All jokes aside, if Gary’s to be believed when Jimmy cooks a good curry, it’s a great curry. So if he can maintain quality in his cooking his eventual restaurant could be really worth checking out.
Good god … I washed my hair during most of this ep, but did not enjoy the vicarious shiver brought on by your MP/neck comment, RR.
The bits I did catch included:
Callum STILL mopping his brow, bless. He should be the handee-man, not MP.
Claire being all wan and stoic, but still cooking good food.
Jimmy, sigh. I like Jimmy and I like curries. But he’d be better as ‘Iron Chef India’
And Adam … CHILL THE FREAK OUT DUDE! Where’s the zen gone? Why soooo Claire-like in your need to please? Get a grip man!!
Callum is such a cutie
He’s one that I wouldn’t mind winning but he probably won’t and probably doesn’t deserve to win it over someone like Adam who has been consistently good and consistently creative. But he’s so happy, hard-working and adorkable
I love Maggie Beer. She is so happy, caring and her smile is infectious. Look at Clare! She was smiling even through criticism tonight and I believe it was Maggie’s influence. And when she eats, she eats with love and appreciation. Even when she didn’t like Adam’s dish she was gracious about it. She is so awesome!
I’m scared Adam won’t win because not all his food is suited to the Western palate. Kind of like Poh but not as strong I guess mainly because Adam’s food is more Japanese inspired which is generally less confronting than other forms of Asian food. Like for me and my family, Adam’s custard probably won’t be met with faces of horror because the eggs he used are things that we eat pretty often at home.
I’m sad Masterchef is almost over. It has actually made me kind of want to learn how to cook more than just 2 minute noodles. I mean I’m not too into cooking, I’d rather eat, but its just inspiring to see people cook with such love and passion and it makes me want to learn how to cook too. And their food looks great as well which is a total bonus!
Callums fish sauce soup and claires vegemite sauce should be combined and reduced to zero liquid and sold to horses as salt licks!
Jimmy You clown. Why did you cook the duck? dont you know the foody idiots like it semi- hemi raw? and yes the soap powder with the prawns was probably a little more adventurous than even the ggs wanted.
loved the way Gary had to change his mind about J’s runny brewlay after maggie b praised it.
So finally to the three wise men plus one for the judiciary findings. jimmy you cooked curry again. big crime we sentence you to a week licking the sweat off Geo’s brow.
And on and on goes Matts verbal Dire Rear….UNTIL
The Oztrayan Inquisition. Bet noone expected that!
“I,m innocent cardinal fang” blathered Claire in Lawyerese, me too blathered Adam in lawyereze as a tear or three squeezed out. O h the pathos, the tension, the buzz, the atmosphere…….. The dollars as 2 million odd morons including me wasted another hour of their lives on this crap. it’s almost as bad as having an election, but wait, who was that red streak? it was either a ranga sanger or a pair of speedos. Back in yer box both of you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And the winner is …..Jimmy…he no longer has to stay in the stupid competition and cook curries for ignorant judges.
BDD – hmm all of their hygiene practices worry me a lot, but especially callum, who I genuinely like, but who cooks like a grub. Has a judge ever refused to taste a dish because of food safety concerns?
Geelongdeano & anon, in a smackdown between donna and maggie I would also be barracking for Maggie
Ruffy – yes I loved Maggie’s glasses too. They were easily the best glasses to appear on the show : not Alvin’s, Marion’s, Aaron’s Kylie Kwong’s or Christine Mansfield’s. Heston’s were cool though.
I thought Adam’s salted egg custard was a savoury dish. Maybe it was meant to be a savoury dish – did they specify that they had to make a sweet one? I love salted egg, but it is an acquired taste (like century eggs) – the yolk can be so salty it hurts the brain… I thought the idea of salted egg custard was great and would love to have eaten it as a savoury dish. Actually, don’t know why I am comparing Adam to Poh – I suppose b/c they both are innovative Asian inspired cooks – but I thought Poh’s martian cookbook idea last year was much more interesting. Of all the cookbooks, Adam’s is the least appealing to me and I wouldn’t feel I’d have to rush out and buy it, but that could be that I’m Asian and don’t like cooking Asian food.
‘From the Hearth’, gustsy food for Lawyers who havent had a thing to eat since the 1pm 10 course degustation .
‘Roadmap with Callum ‘ comes with a CD of Gary berating you while you veer off course
‘Two Asian Kitchens’ For eggsperts
[Must thank Buzz for the Chihuahua visual. There was however, a Pomeranian at work tonight with a bit more endurance. An untimely reference to kissing a girls neck lost the mood all around.]
Is Matt P now wearing monochrome because he was diluting the MC brand? Next year ( if it lasts) I want all to wear a MC Ghost Buster inspired corporate look – orange fireball embellished jumpsuits,goggles and heatproof visors.
Pollywaffle – please! No more references to MP and neck-kissing I find it strangely unsettling and don’t want any weird dreams tonight.
At least it wasn’t an Irish wolfhound. I expect we need a REALLY disgustingly good dish to get that expression seared into our subconscious forever and ever …
Yawn.
At least Jimmy’s gone.
Callum is a cutie? IMHO, I think he’s kinda creepy. :\ It’s the eyes. It’s the way he stares, widens them, and then goes OOGALABOOGDALA with them. O_O!!
Maggie is love.
Glad Masterchef is almost over. I can’t wait until next week, when they pop out and go “BWAHA it’s all a joke! Marion won, sorry.
”
I liked the show again tonight. this is what I watch for = seeing them talk about their food as they cook it, then seeing the finished food.
I think Adam is trying a tiny bit too hard. His dishes look great, but seem to have a few too many embellishments or fancy ingredients. And he pulled out the Claire tears too!
Callum’s food looked great. but how many times does he stick the tasting spoon back in?? I don’t even do that at home if anyone is watching, let alone on camera.
Jimmy should have named his dessert ‘Chai latte sweet soup’ and they would have loved it!
And Claire’s entree looked great to me. I think that is the plate I would taste if I could have one from tonight.
Thank god this farce is almost over and I can reclaim the 7.30pm timeslot.
“‘Roadmap with Callum ‘ comes with a CD of Gary berating you while you veer off course”. LOL, that was great. Still laughing. I’m declaring myself firmly in the Callum camp because I think he’s come the farthest, but I sort of hope he doesn’t win because I’d like him to do an apprenticeship and go on to be a fine chef. So Adam for first and Callum runner-up. Sorry Claire, too much boo hoo hoo.
Was that Maggie’s Vespa parked outside MC central or Jimmy’s Tiffin delivery service ready for take off
I think the final will be between Callum and Adam, too. And Callum to win, most probably.
Which, bizarrely enough, I won’t mind after all! Someone must have pumped weird drugs into my airvents as I’ve gone from Monday night (and the 600,000 nights prior I have watched this weighty juggernaut) screeching at the screen at Callum
NO! He said to start the sauce from SCRATCH! Noooo! She said DON”T make the custard!!! etc to at some point tuesday night falling in love with his eager blinky little ways…. ah, he’s just like a gumnut baby.
His book concept is the only one that would sell a reasonable number. Yeah, it’d be cheaper and more reliable to buy the Commonsense Cookery Book – but where’s the glamour in that!
Adam would be the fitting winner, but they don’t (even though producer profits would be minimal compared to other sources) want a flopperoo winner’s cook book and I can’t see that flying off the shelves. Foodies, yes. General public, no. So it’d sell maybe 2,000 copies max!
I am surprised it took me 2,000,000 episodes of MC1 and MC2 to figure out that the winner is in fact getting a $100,000 advance on a cookbook, as the show can’t force them to go and use it to open a cafe, restaurant, fishburger shack etc. Therefore the fecking cookbook had better do well and sit on the shelves of a lot of shops for a bloody long time and sell in record numbers to keep advertising the Masterchef brand.
Julie’s has sold 105,000 last I heard, so that is a high bar set.
Or this might all be mumbo-jumbo magic to prevent the horror against family values that would be the hearty (limpid) love-filled (tear-soaked) warmth (cold and wan) of the hearth-busting tome that would be unleashed upon us if Claire (who is probably a very nice woman but I am an equal opportunity bitch, and if I am going to infer the show’s favourite was disingenuous (sic) for her dumbed down ways Awesome! i won AGAIN?!! Little me?!!! then it is only fair etc.) won. So therefore Claire can’t win. Maybe.
How horrid to be so close to the end with no-one I really care about to barrack for left. Sigh.
Good luck people whose names I will forget soon: Jake, Aaron, Alvin, Courtney, Jimmy. Sharnee!
“Good luck people whose names I will forget soon: Jake, Aaron, Alvin, Courtney, Jimmy. Sharnee!”
Who? :\
if Callum’s cookbook fails he could star in the Skippy remake:
” whats that Skip? A profiterole, a profiterole stack with a chocolate ganache, yes sure I’ll make you one Skip. What else did you say Skip? We need to save Auntie Dot from the crazed crocodile? OK just wait till that creme pattiserie cools down a bit more in the blaster, and then I’ve got seconds if anything stuffs up”
Skippy, Skippy, the bush tuckeroo!
If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then Callum will do well – maybe as well as Julie. What does it take to win MC? Think back to basic learning in school. Mr M teaches you the a,b,c’s, the next week you stand up in class and recite the alphabet. Mr M pats himself on the back for teaching you well. You get an A+ for effort. At the end of term you stand up in front of all the faculty and say that Mr M taught me and I learned. Hi fives all round. It’s called “Demonstrated Learning” and if nothing else, Callum has perfected it!
Kudos to Fides, Little Petal, Kugel and the others who in the spoiler thread predicted the final 3 based on their “forearm and hand” analysis. Even if you weren’t sure about Jimmy, once it came down to Jimmy v. Claire we were sure of the outcome. For those of you who choose not to read the spoiler thread: MC editors screwed up once again and Claire’s head can be seen in the previews for the Gov General dinner which they started showing Sunday night.
Well, we live in Surry Hills and all I can say is that the last thing Surry Hills needs is another Indian restaurant, especially when we already have some of the country’s best and most authentic Indian restaurants: talking about Maya on Cleveland.
Jimmy’s plans also lend credence to the spoiler theory that Jimmy is behind the recent fire-bombings of a Surry Hills Indian restaurant and a curry van?! Gotta make space and eliminate some of the competition!
Seriously, I know what the rents are for restaurants in Surry Hills and I would suggest that Jimmy must have a backer, especially if he is going to set up something more “high end” and not be on Cleveland Street. In fact, I think based on some recent DA’s that have been sent to us by Council, I know where he may be setting up (on Crown Street).
I really hope Claire Kidman goes tomorrow night. I’m so over her selfishness and angst. She played Maggie like a violin and I get the impression that the judges are afraid to eliminate her. But loved it when George said her red wine sauce was crap..and like many of you, I got a serious case of the heebie-jeebies when Matt talked about necking. Yucko.
Can anyone explain why MP said in the 3.5 months they had ben together at the start of giving feedback and announcing who would be elimanated. I thought they started filming in January. Does he mean that was the actual amount of time they filmed? If so they actually got to go home for quite a while gievn it is now almost July
CG-Jimmy’s restaurant is going to be in Devonshire St. He took over an existing business and have already hired a head chef. Will be tough but good luck to him.
Have you try the fusion Indian French restaurant called Guru in Surry Hills (chef is Opel Khan)? Opened in Jan 09 but already closed in Jun 10. Lovely food.
Crabtech- 3.5 months is when the show started on tele. They lie when they say one week. One week on tele could be 2-3 weeks in actual timeline.
LP – Thanks! Where on Devonshire – near the Shakespeare in the old Mohr Fish spinoff and Thai place were or further up near Elizabeth? I thought he might be going in on Crown beside the new SH Community Centre. An old Indian takeaway place collapsed (literally fell down and had to be demolished) while they were building the centre and a DA came out last week advising they are building a new 2-storey restaurant and cocktail lounge in its place. Very swish and very expensive (rent wise). Either way Jimmy will be only minutes from where we live so I will check it out. I did not get to Guru before it closed but did hear some good things about it. A number of restaurants in the St. Margaret’s complex have come and gone. Not sure what the problem is?
Thank god smarmy Jimmy went tonight-he doesn’t give a rat’s as he has a restaurant opening up and his family spice business to go with it(and no doubt a book in the works)
Thank to Buzz-everytime he rolled his eyes back in his head I imagined him being humped from behind by a chi(make that a Pomeranian-thanks Polly, you are back to your comedic best in this thread)
MP also had his cowhide boots camera shot today…
Love Maggie but think she had too much of a soft spot for Gollum.
Didn’t mind Claire idea and temperament today but Adam was a nervous wreck.
Thanks RR for the blog and thanks to most(not all but lets not go there) for comments-its been great to read it all
http://www.couriermail.com.au/entertainment/confidential/masterchefs-jimmy-seervai-from-the-pan-into-the-fire/story-e6freq7o-1225895290298
Ironically, while I’ve been bagging Jimmy as a potential Masterchef winner, he is one person whose restaurant I actually MAY want to go to because he’s actually very good at something. I’ve had so much dodgy Indian in my life that I’d like to try something good.
Ha, CG, my thoughts exactly about Jimmy opening an Indian restaurant in Surry Hills…..to paraphase “We don’t need another Indian”. Even in the ‘burbs (Beverly Hills) there are several….so rather belies Gary’s comment that we need more. Maybe you could do a little survey of the restaurateurs as to Jimmy’s chances. Another thought, as Jimmy has hired a chef do you think he has poached one.
Regarding Callum’s cookbook idea, I have one by Elise Pascoe arranged in the manner he has suggested.
Another thought, a moot point as Jimmy has been eliminated, but I feel that Jimmy’s dessert should have been given an immediate fail for not even resembling a Creme Brulee but more a custard. Surely at this stage of the competition it is not enough for a dish to taste good but should have the appearance of what it purports to be. Even the sugar crust was uneven.
After Sunday I am so going to miss this forum.
I’m betting on Claire and Adam for the final – I’ll be pleasantly surprised if Callum manages to get through the pressure/chaos of the GG catering challenge. I admit it, I just can’t stand Claire from whatever I’ve seen of her on this show. I agree with someone on Twitter who said that she reminds me of one of those smarmy girls in school whom the teachers all liked but the other girls all hated.
Meanwhile, ILOL at the amusing recap of Wednesday night’s episode in The Age (http://is.gd/dBgbT). I love Adam and thought he was very sincere but I still had to laugh at this:
“Now Adam, sweet, shy, nice-jumper-wearing Adam pulls out his trump card. He says it’s about ‘what you make for someone when you love them and…’
Oh my God, he’s been saving up his crying scene all this time. The sly dog! Out it all comes, ‘and what your parents and your grandparents make for you, sob, sob.’ See Claire, you wasted that stuff too early. Adam is like those guys who save everything for the final sprint in the Tour de France.”
Just a bit scared after last night’s cat’s bum faces from tasting Adam’s dessert that the final 2 will be Claire and Callum.
Bland and marketable.
I think Jimmy’s restaurant has got a better chance then many people opening up eat establishments. As he is known for his MC experience, so it will get people, critics, food bloggers, and a possible reality TV blogger through the doors.
Why is Surry Hills the hub of indian restaurants? I normally go to Faheems but you have got to be in the mood for spice.
RR – Michelle Griffin in The Age is copying your re-caps style in today’s paper! Check it out. Brazen.
Library Girl – sweet of you to say that, however I think MC does open itself up for snark. I am about to link her recap in a masterchef reality tidbits blog post. So much media around.
I have notice media orgs have started doing MC recaps due to popularity of show. Karl Quinn I think did a funny one a few days ago.
RR – your writing is better! She’s a bit over the top trying to be funny. Your style is more subtle. Going to miss the MC re-caps.
Jimmy – thanks for being there, at least you gave us a few laughs.
Claire – presumably we bid a fond farewell to you tonight, with our Handee towels at the ready.
Callum – the great regurgitator aka the reflux kid. Previously, it was stuff from Masterclass, last week wasn’t it the pheasant pie from Aaron’s challenge cook-off with Maggie Beer, last night wasn’t it the chocolate fondant your mate, Matthew, did for the Qantas A380 challenge, and now also it looks like it’s the cookbook idea whether that was the GGs’ idea or someone else’s. Anyway, as teachers’ pet, he can probably resolve who’s going to do what with the GGs.
Adam – you’re still probably the best cook of the 3 amachas left and the most inventive but your cookbook idea unfortunately doesn’t have mass appeal and that’s all this show is about. Also, you are currently the favourite to win but if Matt P is supposedly out there yesterday twittering away to “expect the unexpected” with the result on Sunday, then that sounds like the “kiss of death” for you. On that theory, the winner is the reflux kid which is probably what the MC producers wanted from way back.
So I’ve missed two episodes of Masterchef in the final week. I feel a bit stupid for having persevered with it for sooooooo looooooong and then finally get jack of it now, but them’s the breaks. Perhaps it’s just that I know I can get the most out of it by just catching up here!
“From the Hearth” seems like the wrong title for Claire. It’s a warm, homely, folksy image and that is not what I get from her. Still, perhaps it was just targetted at the judges.
Callum’s idea – well, do I want to buy a book on technique from an amada? No. I don’t. Particularly one who has shown resistance to following clear instructions.
Glad Jimmy’s opening a resto and not just going into cooking demos for kids at fetes/trying to hustle a TV show.
Not being snobby here, but wouldn’t Jimmy’s restaurant fare better a bit further afield than Surry Hills? One would think that quite a few people who live in the area wouldn’t give it the time of day because of the reality tv hype surrounding it. Add to that the parking nightmare that normally comes with travelling into the area, you’d say he’s better off opening in the burbs.
Phew….. I was really worried there for a moment
that dahling Jimmy was going to get through on the fiver he tucked into fat Matt’s chai slushy.
Callum and Claire’s ideas are more about their personal fantasies than what they could actually put out there. At least Jimmy knew what he was and where he could go with it.
Claire couldn’t cook from the hearth if she smocked up and joined Outback House for year. Trust Maggie Beer to spot a phoney first dish up. Orange blossom pannacotta is about as country hearth as a Mosman mummy.
and Gutsy and Honest? that’s her Mills’n’ Boon take on her new relationship, not her cooking. Her cookbook should be called “The Princess Diaries”, subtle little dishes spun with tidbits of advice on how to entice men into your boudoir.
and Callum, how many people are going to buy a book on cooking techniques from a 21 year old?
unless you market it to Junior MC wannabees, in which case it’s a winner. He could have a whole section on techniques not to try when you’ve just stuffed up judge George’s Special Smoked Yoghourt Soup.
Don;t get me wrong, I think, barring Jimmy and no Marion or Jonno, the right contestants ended up in the last week, but the reality gap between Adam and the other two, now that they are about to re-enter the real world, far outweighs their market value.
Great wrap-up! I didn’t manage to catch the show last night, so this was a great read! Thanks! I am rather cynical when it comes to contestants opening up restaurants, but I will still go and try Jimmy’s curries! Go Adam!
Jimmy was just on The Circle via link from Sydney. Nothing we didn’t already know and no winner speculation. They did note that tonight’s evictee will be “in” the studio tomorrow with Matt P. Most of the other eliminated contestants have been via link from where they live. Who lives in Melbourne? Claire.
As there was a lot of noise when I was watching the ep, I was gobsmacked when I heard Claire say her book would be called “cooking from the heart”…worst concept ever – not even Kylie Kwong could pull that off. So it was a relief when she talked about the hearth and I thought, yeah, OK that’s not such a lame idea. She’s still dreaming though. Also, I didn’t think the judges thought her pitch of always giving her best ie her perfectionsim was necessarily such a good thing. With people like that, she’ll never feel she gives her best, no matter what. It’s like every dish she makes could and should have been better…
Jimmy’s the genius here. Was he showcasing food for his cookbook or for his restaurant? His cookbook concept was the most appealing to me though I don’t think I could trust the actual cooking instructions. And I definitely wouldn’t trust Callum : is he really an expert to tell us all about braising, confiting, roasting etc? Remember this is the guy who can’t cream sugar and butter properly…
And Adam pulled off a classic Julie with his tears last night. I thought it was funny and sweet – he was really speaking “from the heart” (sorry!) and I thought the lawyer in him would be much more articulate and composed.
Yes, Claire is from Melbourne. Both Adam and Callum are from SA.
“From the Hearth”: a book specially for people with the Ita Buttrose speech impediment.
When I heard it last night I started laughing so hard I was ‘thor’.
Liberty: Good insight re the Circle interview tomorrow – might mean something, might not. But yes, Claire lives in Melbourne. Callum and Adam are both from SA (but they could be staying anywhere at the mo).
RR good job! Thanks for a great blog and everyone who has contributed on the forum that have given me hours of entertainment. post Sunday, I will miss RR re-caps and this forum more than the actual show.
Strategy thoughts…
And what a barren strategic wasteland this was last night.
If you’ve got this far, this is the one challenge you absolutely know you’re going to get. This is the challenge in which Julie nailed the competition last year, with her cookbook idea that was streets ahead of everyone else in marketability (even if it should have been called “What do ya call these darl? Rissoles…”). This is the challenge which if you think you’re a shot at winning the comp, you’ve ben practising for every night.
And what do our four doofuses do? (well, three of them)Yep, stuff it up.
Claire at least had an idea of what her recipes were. However her strategic mistake was picking a piss-poor cookbook idea. (I actually thought she said “heart”, and that it was just her funny little lisp…, but no…). Completely unmarketable. Claire’s best strategic move was in doing enough to get through. She’ll be banking on the fact that the producers may not want to have an all-male final. Once Courtney left, she’s got an edge over the remaining men – not much of one, perhaps, but you need every advantage when it’s two of you sitting in front of the judges waiting to see who’s in the final two.
Adam’s mistake wasn’t in his cookbook idea, which wasn’t too bad, but in trying stuff he’d never tried before. Bad move and it could have backfired.
Jimmy – what can we say. I actually thought that this was the night where Jimmy had the huge advantage and wasted it (not the previous night when MP the bully said he was “on a precipce” – try that in a real workplace big boy and you’ll have a HR on your back…). Part of me wanted Jimmy to really let rip and say “bugger you, I’m not doing three dishes – I’m doing 12 tasting plates to showcase the best Indian food…” He would have knocked it out of the park.
Jimmy’s known he’s on borrowed time, so this was the chance to advertise himself – and maybe, just maybe, squeak through. I thought Jimmy should have tried something really simple to showcase his restaurant, not weird-ass Mc stuff.
And the best strategy? Callum. He’d clearly thought out his cookbook idea, and it’s pitched at young people who want to learn the techniques, not slavishly follow recipes. Nice one, with pretty good food to back it up.
Not sure if he’s pulled a Julie with this cookbook idea, but if you remember back to last season, Poh was pretty much the favourite at this point, in terms of “best amateur cook”. Pretty much where Adam is now.
IMO the only independent “strategic” thinking last night was (i) Claire kissing up to Maggie Beer; and (ii) Adam being smart enough to differentiate himself but I think he went too far by trying stuff he had not tested and as a result, almost blew it.
Jimmy’s failure to use the opportunity to showcase his new restaurant to 2million+ viewers was a strategic failure. His restaurant would have been well underway prior to the taping of this episode in mid-June. He now owns the building so the restaurant idea was a “go” prior to him returning to the show.
As for Callum’s cookbook, as I mentioned earlier, the idea smells of MC producers/judges/Forum5 working with him well in advance of last night’s episode to come up with a viable concept. A themed cooking book – ie homecooking, Asian cooking, etc. – would never go over – the guy is only 20 years old and has very limited life experiences. The techniques-based cookbook is a briliant idea for Callum. Hasn’t it already been announced he is going to play a role in Junior MC which would just reinforce a basics cookbook although the recipes he used last night were not exactly kiddy fare (except perhaps the dessert). So Callum’s only strategy was/is to go along with what the producers and Forum5 tell him to do. The glowing comments about the “Barossa Boy” from family friend Maggie Beer didn’t hurt, either.
Based on the above and the judge’s swipe at Adam’s dish not being attractive to the “Western palate”, I have a sinking feeling that Callum may be the winner.
Well its long been about other things than finding the best amata cook in Ozzztraila so I expect Callum will win(although I was worried Jimmy was going to win until his many chats to camera last night-and his no idea what cookbook I am going to o as I have the restaurant opening up soon). I wouldn’t bother with his restaurant myself-plenty of good curry houses I ould rather give my money too. I keep imagining on Sunday that they will bring out Jono and Marion for the final cook off…thank god its almost over.
Matt – so right! If I was going on MC, the very first thing I would be thinking of would be “If I got to the end, what would my cookbook be and what dishes would I cook”? I guarantee that Jono and Marion would have been better prepared. As soon as Jimmy said he had no idea (OMG – I can’t believe they’ve asked me to cook three courses, wot kinda curry am I gonna cook – shock!!), it was obvious he’d be finished in the comp.
I wouldn’t buy any of their cookbooks. In saying that if I found an Adam cookbook in the $9.95 cheapo bin at the bookstore, I could be tempted.
RR – best thing about the show is this forum!
New Poll-what do you prefer: MC the show or the forum? I vote forum
Re Callum’s techniques cookbook idea. Justin North (Becasse Restaurant in Syd, also celebrity chef earlier on in MC2) has a very good book called French Lessons (sure Sourk has one at home###). Comprehensive, great presentation and keenly priced at $45.
It was interesting to hear Maggie Beer say she has published 7 cookbooks so far and sales of over 400k. If Julie can get 100k+ sales for her book without the cred of a Maggie Beer, what do it say about the present marketing power of the Masterchef brand to move product?
Chuck – agree with you re the Justin North cookbook.
It is by far and away the best cookbook I’ve ever had – I bought it following his appearace on MC, which says something about why the celeb chefs go on…
Buy it from bookdepository.co.uk, which has free delivery and will cost your about $30, NOT from his publishers who want $80 plus postage…
We need a separate thread on best cookbooks perhaps.
My choice:
Justin North, French Lessons – all the basics and some awesome recipes. I’d also recommend his “Becasse” cookbook, if only for the Blood Orange Tart with caramelised sugar.
Woman’s Weekly Italian Cookbook (only because it’s the one which taught me to cook).
Jamie Oliver’s Naked Chef – for the “hey, it’s ok to cook if you’re a 20-something guy” factor. Also Jamie at Home and Jamie’s Italy.
Longrain – when you really want to step it up. Every MC contestant seems to have pinched the pork hock in masterstock recipe out of this one.
Anthony Bourdain’s Les Halles Cookbook. Because any cookbook which uses (liberally) the word “mother f**ker” in a recipe has to be respected.
I’d be interested to see what others think.
Also, for some excellent cooking advice, especialy for those in Queensland, check out http://paradisetoplate.blogspot.com/ .
The girl who writes it is shortlisted for the next My Kitchen Rules and is a pretty awesome cook.
I don’t need any more cookbooks. I don’t need any more cookbooks. I don’t need any more cookbooks. I don’t need any more cookbooks. I don’t need any more cookbooks. Oh, screw it, I have a book depository discount voucher… might as well check out the North book. Thanks for the rec, Matt and Chuck!
I also love the Bourdain Les Halles book. Love the way he writes so that you feel as though he’s actually in the kitchen alongside you, urging you to break open that second bottle of wine. My first cassoulet was from his recipe – very methodical. Even Callum could probably follow the instructions!
At the moment, I’m loving the Ottolenghi books (my last Book Dep order).
Missed a lot of last night’s episode so thanks for the recap, RR.
I also thought Claire’s book was ‘Food from the heart’. How unoriginal, I scoffed, only to later realise it was ‘Food from the hearth’. I can’t remember who asked her (Gary?) if she’d be cooking on the hearth and she smiled sweetly and responded in the affirmative. Yeah, right. None of what she cooked last night would work that way or even summed up that concept. I hope, I hope, she goes tonight. I don’t think it will happen though. For someone who keeps saying she doesn’t like overt displays of emotion, she’s pretty good at turning on the waterworks…just as the judging panel are pretty good at getting sucked in.
Interesting to see Jimmy won’t actually be cooking but will be trading on his Masterchef persona as ‘front of house’. Make the most of it, Jimmy, the fame is but fleeting.
Should probably be a separate post… Here’s my top five.
1. The Cook’s Companion by Stephanie Alexander (bit of everything)
2. Nose to Tail by Fergus Henderson (the best corned brisket recipe EVER)
3. Sunday Lunch – Gordon Ramsay (Pork Belly)
4. Simple Chinese Cooking – Kylie Kwong (Chinese salads)
5. Edmonds Cookery Book (Basic everything) and no, I’m not a Kiwi.
Injera – too true – best way to get drunk is to open Les Halles and start cooking.
Anything.
Not quite related to the above cookbook posts, but does anyone think Callum’s cookbook (should he win) will be pretty much ghost written?
Wurstsemmel – thanks for reminding me of Jimmy’s front of house experience on the show. It’s telling that when he was team leader at Press Club challenge, he chose to be FOH, which didn’t impress Gary. Wonder what “eye candy” he’ll have working there at his restaurant.
Continuing with cookbook line. Myer often have 30-35% off cooking books on regular basis (usually over weekend) which is good value for the more expensive ones such as Steph Alexander. I did see the Justin North book there after I had purchased my copy.
Good tip, Chuck. I picked up the Bourke Street Bakery book at a Myer sale. In fact, I have to say I would never pay full price for a cookbook! They’re a want, rather than a need, so I can wait for a sale or a Book Dep delivery…
CG (at 55) – I have the same sinking, sickening feeling that Callum is going to win and your notion of the MC producers, judges and Forum 5 workshopping with him in advance sounds plausible. Plus wasn’t it a bit coincidental that the GGs were thinking of doing something along the same lines?
Chuck (at 59) and Matt (at 60) – yeah, Justin North’s book French Lessons is tops. As we know, he’s been on MC 2, so maybe that’s where Callum regurgitated his idea from?
Plucka – Justin’s cookbook has a slightly different format.
But (and don’t get me wrong here, I rate Callum and will gladly buy his cookbook – in 15 years time after he comes back from his two-star restaurant in London) – but, I reckon Justin North will be sick when(if) Callum’s cookbook outsells him.
Has Callum ever cooked an original dish? No.
The only things Callum has cooked he’s either taken from Masterclass or other contestants? Yes.
Has his cookbook idea been done before, and by a lot more talented people? Yes.
That’s why he shouldn’t win.
Which, unfortunately, is probably why he will.
-.-
Blinky Bill to win! Yay! /sarcasm
-.-
Matt. Have Enjoyed reading your bits on contestant strategy.
I think the key strategic player is the MC producer/s. While I appreciate the marketing potential of the show, the key goal is to give Ch 10 a top rating show, which in turn helps the network’s overall sales revenue. Without that all the other (top dollar for spots in show, product placement, cookbook sales and so on won’t happen.
(My argument is too much is at stake rating’s wise for the producer to be a passive particpant in the process. Don’t believe results are rigged but certainly jigged or strategically setup to maximise viewer ratings.)
I’ve had a bit of fun for the last 6 weeks or so playing producer and picking who is to be sent home each. So from a ratings/entertainment point who would be the ideal contestant? Someone with obvious cooking skills and the ability to generate chatter (water cooler talk /forum /twitter comment).
So I listed each contestant at the start of the week and gave each a rating out of 10 for cooking skill and a rating out of 10 for chatter. Add the two scores together and the lowest goes home. My theory: someone can go home who is a good cook but fails to generate chatter (can be positive or negative) or a poor or average cook can remain for a long time if they create a lot of chatter. I saw Joanne as a good point for the latter. Adam’s cooking skill has kept him near top but is vulnerable because he doesn’t generate as much chatter as say Callum or enen Claire.
I was able to accurately pick the bottom 2 for several weeks. The theory sort of crashed with Marion and Jono going (I reackon Marion’s was a stuff-up and Jono lost interest and wanted to go home). The model has returned to form for the past week. You have to do an update each week because as a viewer you can only make subjective judgements on what cooking the producer/s show and what contestant comments/judging decisions are show). Of course the real producer/s have the inside knowledge of who actually has cooking talent and what incidents they can highlight to generate chatter.
For what it’s worth, my take on last year’s result was that the final 2 wasn’t the predictable (Chris/Poh/Justine) outcome (producer milking the interest cash cow to the end). The winner I believe was based on who suffed up the least on the night (Julie). My hunch is it will be the same this year. As long as the finale get the ratings That is the key strategy.
Anyway that’s my take, not taking it all too seriously but along with the RR forums (thanks RR) and comments, it has added much more to the MC experience for the year.
Matt and Chuck,
have either of you thought of getting a life?
I hear you can get them cheap from next week on. at Bunnings.
Anon, Yes you’re probably right. I’ll have to go early because there’s certain to be hugh queues.
Matt and Chuck: thanks for the cook book tips
The close up of MPs cow skin boots was funny.
I think the editers were taking the piss!
Leave a Comment