Category — Junior Masterchef
Junior Masterchef – Not Everyone Is Feeling The Love
Junior Masterchef is rating fabulously well, and it deserves to be as the kids are dishing up some fabulous food, however not everyone is feeling the love for the show.
I stumbled over this very interesting blog post on Cake Cake, who quite rightly points out that as the show progresses the kids from the higher socio economic backgrounds will have the advantage.
Cake Cake writes:
Yes, it is impressive that at their age the Junior Masterchef contestants know about, and can, temper chocolate/make short-crust pastry/whatever. But in order to get those skills, and to get them to that level, there has been a lot of effort, and a lot of money.
Learning to cook salmon/squid/make pasta involves cooking salmon/squid/making pasta. Often over and over again. For many families, where food is simply for sustenance, not entertainment, buying salmon/squid/fresh pasta isn’t even an option, let alone allowing your eight year old child cook with itmultiple times.
In the beginning I’m sure that basic techniques and ingredients, the classics, will be able to get past the judges. As the competition continues, however, contestants will have to pull out increasingly impressive dishes. Leaving the lower-income participants (if there even are any) in the dust.
I think she is correct in what she says and the show is paralleling real life. There has been a plethora of articles about how people from lower socio-economic backgrounds do not eat as much freshly prepared food due the higher cost and the health ramifications of this. But it does explain why there are so many Sophie and Isabella’s running around the Junior Masterchef set.
In the Adelaide Advertiser Rose Matto also talks about why Junior Masterchef is not great for kids.
She said:
Rosa Matto says she has cancelled her regular children’s classes because of the unrealistic expectations of parents, who demand instant results.
“They should enjoy being in the kitchen. Now parents expect them to produce – and not just a muffin. They want a croquembouche, for goodness sake,” she said.
“They just want the spectacular. If I say to them: `I’m sorry, we have to start with knife-handling skills’, they say: `That’s not going to be very exciting’. People don’t want to do the hard yards. Teaching people to cook requires discipline and a great investment of time. What are we doing to these poor kids?”
Ms Matto, a former high school English and drama teacher, said such TV shows as Junior MasterChef had made cooking classes the latest fashion to fit in beside sport, music and other regimented activities in children’s lives.
Also Angela Mollard questions on The Punch whether Junior Masterchef was child abuse or character building. There are some academic saying the former.
Anyway what do you think?
September 24, 2010 14 Comments
Junior Masterchef – The Top Twenty
Sorry a belated post on the latest Junior Masterchef episode.
Again the 8-12 year olds showed they are better cooks then then Come Dine With Me contestants and thankfully not as lushy.
As discussed last week better they are also better then a few of the top 50 of the adult version of the show.
Just few thoughts on the show:
- The toned down real articulate Matt Preston is much better, then the dramatic Matt Preston we saw in Season 2 of Masterchef;
- The knife skills of these kids are amazing, did they come in with them or were they given a few lessons prior to filming?
- There appears to be no Jake type kid in this show, as yet I have not seen a knife injury or a burn, but then this might not be seen as being tasteful;
- With only 45 minutes to prep and cook I am impressed with some of the dishes, one kid made fresh pasta this week;
- They must have recipes secreted away somewhere as there is no way these kids could remember the measurement required could they?
- Also I am presuming for this first challenge they actually are given time to decide what they want to cook, as I doubt truffles or rabbits are typical pantry items on the show.
The show is good viewing once I start to watch it, but not something I need to watch straight away. It rated 1.75 million viewers losing over 400,000 from the previous week, however this is still fantastic ratings and great family entertainment.
September 21, 2010 11 Comments
Junior Masterchef Smacks Down The X Factor
The Masterchef love continues for the Junior version of the show with it debuting at 2.2 million viewers, it easily beat The X Factor which had 1,074 viewers.
Even if Junior Masterchef sheds 500,000 viewers it will still be a successful show. It definitely is out rating last year’s Celebrity Masterchef, so expect a second series next year. I am sure there will be a lot of parents wanting their kids on the show so they can get their hands on that fantastic scanpan set.
Also in a nicely timed PR exercise the tickets to Masterchef Live the stage show and festival are on sale now. Go to the official website http://www.masterchefliveaustralia.com/ to buy them.
September 13, 2010 4 Comments
Junior Masterchef – Well The Kids Can Cook
I really liked the way Nick aged 12, thinks. He said that Anna Gare will be the toughest judge as he didn’t know what she liked to eat. Fantastic he is thinking strategy from the start, when he is 18 I hope we can from an alliance on a Survivor series as this kid is savvy.
Also expect high fat, and it was. He cooked baklava with a cinnamon sauce on the side. George said that he would serve it in his Hellenic Republic restaurant, but it is obviously not good enough for his hallmark dining establishment The Press Club.
Tonight was the first episode of Junior Masterchef which is the offspring off the highly popular Masterchef Australia and the top 50 were starting to being whittled down to the top 20.
Now it is fair to say all of this top 50 can cook to a pretty high standard, in fact all of them can cook better then Kate from Season 2 Masterchef Australia. Which again it must be asked how did Kate get through to the top 20? She scored well with the casting agents?
The first heat tonight was international food and the children appear to be matched in heats that suit their cooking skills.
Isabella (one of the many Isabella generation) decided to cook french and Iron Chef style grabbed the truffle. I was amazed she knew what a truffle was let alone identify it. I presume they got to tell what they wanted to cook and the ingredients were procured. Her dish was a perfectly cooked poached egg, with mashed potato and truffle.
Points to Anna Gare who was prepared to give some constructive advice and tell her more salt could have been in the mashed potato. However the only other negative comment I heard in the judging was to do with the Chicken in Pomegranate and Walnut sauce he was told that it needed more salt. The Heart Foundation will not be happy.
Just like that child psychologist who was in the papers today saying the kids on this show may have long term issues form because of the program. Her reasoning was pretty lightweight. (Full article on SMH)
Sophia and Isabella who are twins want to open a restaurant together. Isabella cooked Ricotta gnocchi with eggplant salsa which they all loved. Sophia also wowed with her veal with fried eggplant dish. Gary thought it was the best eggplant that he had tasted all year. Well it was fried.
Taylor, Nick, Isabella and Sophia were through to the next round.
The next ten kids had a dessert challenge. Riley was making Lemon Meringue Pie, and it looked pretty good, but he put the grill on instead of the oven, and he burnt the top of it.
Also poor Tegan cooked her cake in the plastic ramekins and they melted in the oven she was bereft.
Lucy was cooking a heart shaped sponge and it looked delicious.
Angus cooked a chocolate lava pudding which had not lava in it.
However Clarrie’s rhubarb crumble was more successful and Gary thought it was delicious.
Sam who seems to really want to win cooked Quatre-Quarts and tempered white chocolate something Johnathan Daddia will be extremely jealous about his skill. George thought it was too crunchy the cake not the chocolate.
Lucy was through, as was Ashley with another heart shaped dessert. Clarrie with his crumble was through, and Sam was so overwhelmed when he made top four he was in tears.
It was a good start to the series, thankfully it is only once a week proposition at this point, as nightly it would become tedious quickly.
September 12, 2010 29 Comments
