for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Posts from — May 2009

Australia’s Next Top Model – Clare Not So Posh After All

clare

Clare Venema the stunning 16 year old on this year’s season of Australia’s Next Top Model, has been stereotyped on the show as a “prissy princess”.

In this week’s NW Magazine she reveals she is more working class then she has been portrayed on the show.

The article states:

Debating champ, school leader, fussy eater – Top Model contestant Clare Venema has made a name for herself as the “prissy princess” of this year’s competition.

But the stereotype couldn’t be further from the truth, with Clare revealing to NW  that her mother was homeless as a teen (for reasons she doesn’t know), while her dad is a rail employee who’s worked hard to provide for his family.

“My parents have worked for everything – my dad’s a train driver and my mum was homeless at my age,” tells Clare. “So they’ve had to drag themselves up from the gutter to get  me and my sister a good education,”

Clare feels she’s been unfairly typecast as stuck-up by both the show’s producers and the other contestants.

“I think you kind of get stereotyped from day one, and it’s really hard to break that,” says Clare. “It does get really frustrating when I get called a prissy princess, because I know that isn’t me.

“And it’s really bad when people have expectations of you and you feel like you need to rise to their expectations of you. It’s a really tough thing to break.”

The portrayal of Clare as uptight has led to bullying at the hands of fellow contestant Cassi Van Den Dungen, with growing tension between the two eventually resulting in the infamous “shower scene”, in which Cassi barged into the bathroom as Clare was showering and verbally and physically threatened her.

While Cassi was later reprimanded and sent to anger-management counselling over the nasty confrontation, Clare admits she’s never told Cassi about her family history.

“Cassi didn’t really know all of that,” says Clare. “And after the whole shower incident I just tried to distance myself from her as much as possible, so I didn’t really get a chance to tell her about where I come from and everything. So she had the stereotype of me that she wanted to have and she just clung on to that for dear life.”

The 16-year-old’s well-modulated accent has also made her the target of teasing from some of the other aspiring models, but the Adelaide student says her voice is just the result of getting a scholarship to a private school, St Peters Girls.

“I know that I do have a manner of speaking well,” says Clare, “but it’s because I’ve been lucky enough to have a good education.

“And that’s only because I’ve worked hard and I’ve got a full scholarship to go to a good school. If that makes me a prissy princess, then I’ll wear that badge of honour.”

It would appear on ANTM if you show half a brain or an inclination to study you are going to be portrayed as stuck up as Alamela Rowen was in last years show. This is not great role modelling by the show’s producers, since a high proportion of their audience is younger girls.

I also found this story from last year where it shows Clare has has modelled in Milan. I think she will go close to winning this year’s series.

May 26, 2009   9 Comments

MasterChef Australia – Contestant Confirms The Show Is More About Entertainment Than The Cooking

In TV Week eliminated contestant Michelle confirms what we thought, that MasterChef Australia was more reality TV show than cooking show. Apparently she thought she had signed up for an educational experience.

The article said:

“The emphasis was on making dramatic television rather than a learning curve.” she said.

“I felt that perhaps I woud’ve learnt more from the caterers had I spent a week in their truck!”

As one of the older competitors, Michelle felt that she’d left it too late to start an apprenticeship and had hoped MasterChef  would fast-track her cooking career. But she was underwhelmed with the show’s main teaching vehicle, the master classes with judges Gary Mehigan and George Calombaris. ” The classes kicked in about two weeks into the show and they were fantastic, ” she says, “but the judges didn’t offer that much tuition. You had to watch what they were doing, take notes and implement it later. We thought we would be learning a lot more about cooking and food.”

Michelle is also critical of the lack of a female voice in the judging team. “Personally, I would’ve liked to have seen a female judge on the panel,” she says. ” The token host, Sarah Wilson, who’s gorgeous and incredibly intelligent, did not get enough commentary. On every other reality TV show where there are three judges one is female.”

I have to agree with what Michelle says about Sarah, a robot would be able to recite the small amount of lines she has been given. She should be on the judging panel as well, the pre-show press made out how she used to do restaurant reivews but I have yet to see a morsel pass her lips.

In other MasterChef Australia news TV Week also has a blind spoiler alert saying the tension is rising in the MasterChef house. Another contestant will forfeit their place  in the game by the end of the week. With a divide evident among the contestants and separation from loved ones taking a toll, someone throws in their apron.

Also the Kiddie Mafia have come out saying they are not bullies.

Again TV Week reveals the Kiddie Mafia which consists of close friends Josh, Sam and Kate are refuting that they’ve been bullying their fellow competitor Aaron.

Josh who was eliminated last week said he was no bully.

“Aaron was getting on people’s nerves in the house because he’s opinionated, but in the end he wasn’t delivering good dishes,” Josh says. “I tried to encourage him to concentrate on the food but he didn’t want to listen. I can be blunt sometimes,” He adds, “but I’m an honest person and I would never bully anyone.”

Kate agrees, saying she’s “not that kind of person” and that Aaron has taken their attempts to help him the wrong way. “He stepped on a lot of people’s toes, especially in the first couple of weeks in the competition,” she says. “We did see him as a mate, that’s why we wanted to help him out. The conversations we had with him were very calm. We’d sit down and say, ‘You need to stop giving criticism to people’, but I suppose he just didn’t want to hear it from us. I’m hurt that that’s how he saw what we were saying,”

While Aaron claimed he felt outcast by the group, Sam says that the three friends never intended to leave anyone out. “I hope our friendship didn’t alienate any of the other contestants,” he says. “We just wanted to get the best out of each other while enjoying eveyone’s company.”

May 26, 2009   3 Comments

MasterChef Australia – Supposedly An Elimination Night

Firstly a big thank you to Injera for kindly neglecting her own fabulous blog to keep my one going whilst I was away. Hopefully one day I will be able to repay the favour to her. And it is with some nervousness that I start blogging again on MasterChef Australia after all her brilliant posts on the show. Also the wordpress Gods must be in agreement  as it keeps on crashing as I try as publish this, three hours and counting.

I hope she will continue to give her opinions and observations in the comments section. Anyway here we go….

MasterChef Australia – The Contestants Have No Problems Kicking Out Each Other Why Can’t The Judges?

MasterChef Australia producers/editors need to look up the definition of suspense and memorise it. Anyone watching the end of last nights episode had a sneaky suspicion none of the contestants up for elimination were going to be sent home.

The episode started with Trevor, Sam and Tom heads on the chopping block facing the challenge of cooking Warm Sticky Date Pudding with Butterscotch Sauce with Almond Praline. They had one hour to do it before presenting their dish to the judges who would decide who they would send home.

Gary Mehigan showed early in the episode that he was going to soft cock it (metaphorically speaking) when he said “None of them should be standing here.” Well who should be? You guys put them there last night.

Also George Columbaris wins the Stating The Bleeding Obvious Award when he tells the three cooks “We need it to be delicious.”.

All three cheftestants were on a level playing field as none of them cook desserts.

Kate was like Juliette to Sam’s Romeo. Ok I am exaggerating, but there was a balcony and dialogue involved, and I am just wanting  to whip up a bit more of the Kate/Sam frenzy after we saw they share a bedroom in yesterdays episode.

She kept yelling out advice and instructions to him, which I think should not be allowed.  They should have to cook without assistance, and also it would be extremely off putting to the contestants who are are trying to avoid being eliminated.

I note Justine and Lucas decided not to point out to Trevor that he used brown sugar instead of white in his first attempt to make the praline.

Tom who is meticulous, which I presume will be his Archilles heel at some point of the competition, turned out a beautiful looking dish.

The judges tasted them all and were very impressed and said there was very little separating them. Trevor’s butterscotch sauce was even described as “liquid gold”.

Now at the beginning of the episode, host Sarah Wilson, tells us the person with the worst dish will be sent home. So what is the point of the judges talking to the contestants? I know this point has been raised before on this blog but I am so bewildered by it I just had to write it again.  My only theory is it is filler to ensure the episode goes the whole hour. Also I agree with Injera and others that it should be a blind tasting, like they do on beat the chef episodes, so the judges cannot show preferential treatment.

Anyway it was decision time. Tom and Trevor were told they were safe. Then it was time for some standard reality TV trickery with Matt Preston saying it was time for Sam to go, but not just yet. Cue much surprise and happiness from Sam.

Back at the house the contestants gather to find out who has been eliminated. This reminded me of last year’s Make Me a Supermodel. Kate says she was prepared for Sam to go. Then she has a mini meltdown when Trevor and Tom enter the room. Then relief and jumping over Sam after he reveals himself.

The best bit was the death stare Poh gave Sam. Remind me to never get on the wrong side of her. Also Chris was not happy either. His reasoning was it was unfair that you cook the three worst dishes of the challenge and you are rewarded by not being sent home. Also he points out if you are in the top three you don’t get any rewards. He must have conveniently forgetting he will be playing beat the chef tomorrow night.

I wasn’t buying his reasoning as I think he just is not a fan of Sam’s or maybe he has seen too many episodes of Gordon Ramsay’s Hell’s Kitchen where the winning team gets whisked away in helicopters to Napa Valley wineries for lunch.

I am not going to enter the Kate debate yet as I have not seen enough of her, but she does appear to be unpopular with her housemates, particularly the older ones. But was it necessary for her to be interviewed whilst lying in bed at the beginning of the episode? Or Sam entering the shower cubicle? Now I don’t mind a bit of gratuitious nudity but can it least be someone hot?

Now on Thursday night I am sure the knives will be out for Kate or Sam when the contestants have to vote out one of their own. I am sure they will not allow them to wiggle out of making a tough decision. I am sure as the show continues the peer eliminations will become more on personalities rather than cooking skills.

May 26, 2009   9 Comments

HomeMADE – Episode 5 – How To Deal With A Control Freak Client

I must confess I have not watched a reality TV show for two weeks beside the American Idol finale, so even if this had been an episode of The Bachelorette Season 26 I probably would have gained some viewing pleasure out of it.

Obviously for any Top Design fans there are going to be comparisons. The question is why they did not take more of the format from Top Design? 

Renovating a house in five days is just not enough time for the designers or builders to do a good job. On Top Design they are normally given two days to design a little wooden room. Also with all the different challenges it allows the Top Design contestants to be extremely creative and interesting.

I know for Channel 9 Backyard Blitz and those make over programs have been successful for them in the past, but normally there is limited owner input. Here the designers have to cater to the whims of Mr and Mrs Suburbia and lets face it this means they want to keep it pretty bland.

Speaking of the owners maybe they need to psych test them prior to allowing them to be on the show, as Olly from last night was quite the egomanical control freak, and he seemed to think his tennis pro job gave him high level managerial skills.

Seriously the bones of their house was fantastic noone could stuff up a renovation job but he was wanting to sign off on every decision. Which was particulary strange considering looking at the state of their house it would appear they had no design flair and little taste.

I suppose unreasonable and demanding clients are probably a something all designers have to deal with on a weekly basis.

However I did wonder what carrot the producers were dangling to get the boy team to stay on the job.

The other thing is the deadlines appear to be flexible. The five days  are over but they designers appear to be  still working on the houses. Either have a longer deadline which would  appear to be a bit more realistic or make them down tools.

I agree with Injera’s post on HomeMade that David Heiman the mentor is a natural for TV, however I don’t see the point of him visiting the houses right towards the end of the renovation, it would be better if he got their earlier to help them sort a few things out.

Also I would have liked to know who decides who gets what room. It seems a bit unfair that some people have to do two rooms whereas others did one. For example Leonie had two bedrooms to do, whereas Stacey had a tiny baby’s room to do.

The other thing about Top Design in both series there were about a dozen of contestants I would have loved to have come to do over my house. At the moment I would not be touching any of this lot. Annie spent three days picking tiles for the kitchen, now if I am paying for an interior designers time I want them to be a bit more efficient then that.

Even though she felt the girls were ganging up against her did she really help her cause by going for a coffee on the beach after she finally had picked the right shade of turquoise of the tiles.

She will be lucky to survive an elimination.

For those wondering about the house the contestants are staying in some eagle eyed SMH The Guide reader and clearly a reality TV fan spotted it was the same house used in the TV show Single Girls.

May 25, 2009   1 Comment

Masterchef – Mystery box

Well, so much for a graceful exit. I should have taken my cue from Josh, who – despite the graceless behaviour of a particular friend in the house – departed with dignity last week. Anyway, Raver is back – as those of you who have checked out the pic of Kara Di Guardio in her bikini already know – and is tackling homeMADE tonight as a way of countering the effects of jet lag. For tonight, I remain your Masterchef poster and will endeavour to convey the excitement of the mystery box challenge. A word of warning – I have set up macros for the following: Kate pouts (Ctrl+K,P), Kate sulks (Ctrl+K,S), Kate cries (Ctrl+K,C) and Julie panics (Ctrl+J,P). I’m hoping not to need them, but forearmed is… something… an RSI case averted? Anyway, let’s go!

Keep us on our toes, narrator. This week, instead of “working alongside Australia’s top chefs”, the winner will be “working in Australia’s top restaurants”. I still need the details of this part of the prize clarified.

We see Justine very early on, which bodes well as far as I’m concerned. Did Justine just say “eh?” at the end of her sentence? Is that why she’s been ignored so far?

In case you had lagged behind, Sarah makes one of her brief appearances to let us know that we’re down to the lucky 13. What do these lucky people have in front of them? 30 minutes to create from the mystery box, which contains a whole snapper, eggs, potato, chilli and beer. Chris cracks a smile at the beer. Again, the judges (which this week includes Matt) will only taste three “stand out” dishes.

Gary tells our hopefuls that “it’s about winning, not avoiding losing”, although I haven’t seen much (any?) evidence that winning the mystery box challenge is any advantage at all. And today there’s a twist! The judges are magnanimously prepared to taste five, but only if there are five dishes that appeal to them. What’s the bet there will be?

Sandra’s making ceviche and the judges are excited. This means that it doesn’t matter if the dish is a mess – the judges are going to taste it.

Andre (Andre!) is doing an open lasagne. I’m not sure what that means and his explanation doesn’t really help. He’s never made it before, and seems stressed, but the judges seem interested. Tom is savvy enough to name-check The Red Lantern, with his whole snapper, so naturally the judges are hot for that. Kate chooses to completely ignore the fish, which means she’s working with eggs, potato, chilli and beer. In the words of Sir Humphrey Appleby, “Very courageous”.

Time’s up! Sarah recaps and Kate pouts.

The judges want to try Sandra’s dish (wow, big surprise). Sandra gives us a brief lesson in “cooking” with acidity. Gary’s judgement uses words like “fresh”, “healthy” and “acidic”. George says it’s a cracker. Julie’s pleased that they want to taste hers, as she’ll get some feedback, which is a clear criticism of the process so far. Geni’s lemon potatoes are undercooked, which is something you don’t want to serve to George. Tom’s praised for taking the learning on board and he’s pleased to get positive reviews from Gary and Matt. Clearly he cares nothing for George’s opinion. Andre’s dish has bones. Cue the fail SFX.

Tom wins! Sarah continues to try selling this as a “massive advantage” and Trevor’s had a decent swig of that Kool Aid. The theme for the invention test, for which Tom is streets ahead of the competition, is French. Justine is happy, and we all offer a prayer of thanks to the editing gods for actually allowing us to see her in the previous ep, so we’d know she was still in the competition.

Tom is given a choice between gruyere, sweet shortcrust pastry and rib eye. In his five pantry minutes, he selects blue cheese – amongst other things – to stuff his beef, so to speak. Stuffing rib-eye with Roquefort seems like an unusual way to squander his advantage, but there you go. The remaining contestants run around the pantry in their two minutes. Julie panics.

The “inventions”

  • Chris: Gary explains that steak tartare is raw (thanks, Gary) and queries the cheese Chris has. Chris says it’s “to eat”, and I’m just a bit in love with him for that.
  • Trev’s doing a red wine sauce with beef, carrots and onions, or – as he describes it – steak and veg.
  • Poh’s says she’s cooking “beef and fries”, but instead of “fries” she’ll serve “smashed potatoes”,
  • Aaron’s making pastry. Ambitious.

Gary and George say that Chris is looking good, while George thinks “the world’s concerned about Aaron”, but that he has a soft spot for him. Tom starts a bonfire. Sandra thinks Sam looks nervous, as well he should. His celeriac puree has escaped from the blender.

“Cook like you’re going to save the world!” exhorts George and… really? That’s where we are now with this?

With the clock ticking, Chris settles back for a nibble of cheese. Trev thinks his looks fancy compared to the others, which obviously means that it’s going to be crap and he’ll get stick from the judges for trying to polish a morceau de merde (translation courtesy of a free online tool – feel free to correct it!).

The good

  • Sandra’s steak and mushroom sauce gets a furrowed brow from Gary, which means it’s nice. George likes it, as do the helplessly-raised hands of Matt.
  • Lucas’ is fine
  • Chris’ tartare looks good and Gary says he’s “achieved the freshness” of the raw beef. Surely the freshness of the beef has about, oh, nothing to do with Chris? Still, I’m happy for him. George doesn’t like raw beef and I think he even uses the word “icky” to describe how he feels about it.
  • Julie’s gets a rave.
  • George loves Andre’s.
  • Poh’s is fantastic.

The bad

  • Geni’s
  • Justine’s… sauce doesn’t pull it all together. WHAT!
  • Tom’s stuffed ribeye is overpowered by Roquefort and garlic. Also? It looks like a hideous mess.
  • Trevor’s dish is described as “a funny little dish” by Gary. His heavily reduced sauce is reminiscent of vegemite.
  • Kate’s is too much
  • Sam’s looks a bit crappy and is “on the verge of being overcooked”. I’m now regretting making Kate macros, as Sam is pouting. He doesn’t take criticism at all well. Also, he’s crying, so there’s another wasted technical effort. Gary tries to press him on the “ya still want to be here?” but Sam’s not biting.

The it’s-hard-to-call

  • Aaron’s pithivier :”weirdly nice”

Matt has his hand tucked into his blazer and looks even more pompous than usual as Sarah limps through her lines as though she’s learned the spoken language phonetically and has no idea as to the meaning of her utterances.

Called forward: Aaron, Justine, Geni, Andre, Julie, Lucas, Kate. They are all through, but not top three.

The six left are the top and bottom three. Called forward: Poh, Sandra, Chris. No surprises for guessing that this is the top three. Chris is the winner and will have a crack at the cook off. This time, his competition is being billed as “one of Australia’s most respected chefs”.

Sam, Tom and Trev will cook for their lives. So, I guess that winning the mystery box is not such an advantage. Do you think the narration next week will be changed to reflect that?

Prediction:

  • Sam goes, and that is what prompts Kate’s threat to leave.

May 24, 2009   7 Comments