for those who have reality tv as their guilty pleasure
Reality Ravings | Australia's leading Reality TV blog!

Posts from — May 2009

“Beat the Chef” – sorry, “Masterchef”

Having won the “Invention Challenge”, Julia faces off against chef Peter Evans, or Peter Evans Chef as he is known to the internet.  They are both cooking his signature dish, tea-smoked duck with a duck ravioli, which sounds yummy, if a bit confused. If she wins? It’s out of the competition until the final week, which some have pointed out might be a handicap as it will be hard to maintain her “edge” without daily exposure to the kitchen.  If she loses? She’ll have to be a team captain and will be a target for elimination by the “Mean Girls” a.k.a. Josh, Sam and Kate.  Makes winning the Invention Challenge a tasty prospect, doesn’t it?

Evans gives Julia a lot of advice, but doesn’t follow Martin Boetz’s precedent of doing some of the cooking.  Aaron acknowledges that Evans is really helpful, but says that if he were the chef, he’d just stand there, staring, trying to psyche the contestant out.  What would that achieve?  Aaron really doesn’t make sense, ever.

Dishes are cooked and presented, labelled 1 and 2, to the judges.  The judges seem to like both of them equally, if we are to trust the editing.

The judges come out.  Evans has the look of a man who has agreed to take a fall.

On Gary’s mark, Julia’s ahead.  He’s got the grin of a man who knows the professional is taking a fall.  George also puts Julia ahead of Peter.  He tells her she can work in his kitchen any day.

It all rests with Matt.  Has he read the script?  Sarah reminds us that Matt is a feared critic.  After a well-timed ad break, Matt reveals his score and… he’s read the script!  Julia wins!

Peter Evans graciously offers to mentor Julia over the next few months, so she should be in fine form for the finals.

May 19, 2009   4 Comments

Reality Tidbits

homeMADE struggles

Ratings were dismal for homeMADE, prompting speculation that it won’t be long before it’s squirreled away in another timeslot. It only held this viewer for two episodes.  I wonder if Nine will be as brutal as NBC was with its version of The Chopping Block, which disappeared and hasn’t been seen since after only three episodes.

American Idol – Clay eyes Adam

The Chicago Sun-Times reported last week that former Idol contestant, Clay Aiken, paid an unexpected visit to the Idol set in a bid to arrange a duets album and/or concert tour with the man who will be America’s next Idol, Adam Lambert. He’s not the fave person in those parts, due to breaking with the Idol-approved management company, 19 Entertainment, and was apparently prevented from making contact with Adam. Looks like Clay will have to find another star to hitch his wagon to.

May 19, 2009   2 Comments

Ajay Rochester – Leaving The Biggest Loser – No Surprise For Anyone

You would have to be living in a cave to know that after Ajay Rochester’s fraud court case she was never going to have her contract renewed by Channel Ten.

However Ajay Rochester appears to be relieved on her Facebook page she wrote “..glad to not be selling her soul anymore”. Sounds a bit bitter to me.

It appears she is off to try her luck in Los Angeles. I hope she has her visa sorted as last time I looked the US is notoriously difficult to get a visa if you had any court history.

May 19, 2009   2 Comments

Masterchef – elimination

Sometimes, just sometimes, I wish reality TV would surprise me.  Michelle’s had the loser edit for most of the season so far, whereas Kate and Sam have been given loads of positive air-time.  No surprise, then, that it was Michelle to go and the Sam/Kate/Josh alliance lives on.  Boo.

Things that particularly bugged me tonight:

  • Josh saying that he hoped Michelle stuffed up.  Look, I can understand that he wants to have his mates around, but hoping for a bad performance by the other contestant is just poor form.  It also undermines the idea that the “best” chefs will get through; it suggests that he acknowledges that Michelle is a better chef, overall.
  • If they are booting based on the worst dish – which they restate until the phrase “worst dish” is nearly bleeding from my ears – why do they need to speak to the contestants?  Surely that means the decision is made based on the dish.  These guys are chefs/critics.  They taste food for a living.  What impact can the input of the person who cooked the dish have on whether it’s good/bad, best/worst?
  • Stop with the “do you really want this” questioning.  Jesus.  These people have left their families/loved ones to be stuck in a house with their competitors for the competition.  If they want to leave, they’ll leave.  Remember Nic?  He left.
  • And Kate?  Shut up.  You got through – let the others miss Michelle.  God.

Tomorrow – Julia cooks off against Peter Evans, “celebrity chef”.  It’s being billed as the “closest” chef vs contestant match-up yet.

May 18, 2009   6 Comments

Masterchef (UK) – “Whoever wins, it’ll change their life!”

And so it has, for the winner of the most recent season of the REAL Masterchef, Mat Follas.  Given that Mat spent a lot of his life in New Zealand, I’m amazed that nobody here has tried to claim him as a local.  That’s gotta be a first. Anyway, Mat has just found a venue for his own restaurant and is working to get it open in just over a month.  He keeps a blog, which includes recipes, news on the food he loves, and some inside goss on his time on the show. Here’s hoping it goes well.

Other finalists

One of my only criticisms of the current version of Masterchef in the UK is the section in the quarter finals where a contestant is eliminated without getting a chance to cook.  This decision is made on the basis of their performance in the “ingredients test” (identifying, say, particular birds, cuts of meat, spices…) and in the “passion test”, where the prospective semi-finalists have to demonstrate how much they want this (and, for those who have only seen the local version of the show, “this” seems to be nothing more than bragging rights – there is no $100,000 cash prize, no book deal… just a trophy designed to go straight to the pool room). I dislike this, particularly, as it seems to favour the articulate, as well as those who are willing to pimp out their emotions for the camera.  It’s the only time of the UK Masterchef week that I really talk back to the TV.

This is all preamble to the news that finalist Andy Oliver was, indeed, a finalist who really wanted “it”.  Despite losing to Mat, he has chucked in his job to follow his dream of a career in food.  He’s recording his “journey” over at The Cook’s Broth.  I don’t know how many of the local contestants would be willing to do this:

i went about making a list of london places which do the food and have the kind of style & vibe i love, so these are the places i’m planning to work in: Bocca di Lupo, The Modern Pantry, Moro, Nobu, Brindisa

There may be other places too, but as i’m mainly offering to work for free it cant last forever, so plan is to take full time cooking job at one of them or somewhere similar in perhaps a month or 6 weeks. In the meantime i’ve got to be Frugal McDoogal because the bills still gotta be paid!

Now that’s what I call having a calling!

According to the Evening Star, the other finalist, Chris Gates, has made a few TV appearances and has had some offers from restaurants, but is still working in his old job.  He’s blogging over at the creatively named Christopher Gates.

It’s hard to compare the skills of these guys and our local contestants, given that cooking plays such a ridiculously small part in the local version, but I haven’t seen anything from the locals so far that matches what these guys turned out on a regular basis.  Subtext: don’t give up your day jobs, MCAers!

May 18, 2009   Comments Off on Masterchef (UK) – “Whoever wins, it’ll change their life!”