Posts from — August 2013
Masterchef Australia – Strategy Meetings For A Fresh Masterchef In 2014.
Christine Sam of the Sun-Herald revealed yesterday that late last week there was a strategy meeting in Melbourne to talk about the 2014 series of Masterchef Australia.
This year Masterchef had a dramatic drop in ratings with the show averaging about 800,000 an episode. TEN told the Herald it was satisfied that it still held it appeal among the 25-54 year olds and they think there is plenty of life left in it.
However they also say they are looking forward to a new fresh version in 2014.
Indeed there is life left in this show and even though My Kitchen Rules knocked it out of the ball park ratings wise it certainly has a great impact in relation to contestant post-show career changes and viewers trying recipes they see on the show.
What is interesting is Gary Mehigan, George Calombaris and Matt Preston are attending the strategy meeting. Sure they have been in all series and would have ideas on what worked this season and what was not so great but they might just be a little part of the problem.
However it also looks like TEN will be sticking with them as the judging panel for next year. Excutive Producer Margie Bashfield told Christine Sams the judges Preston, Mehigan and Calombaris are intrinsic to the show. She also said “I think they’re getting better. They have themost incredibly broad food knowledge. George, I think, has the biggest heart in television….. and Matt has just evolved to another level.”
They are not unlikable nor irritating but they are predictable. Also very glad that George Calombaris and Matt Preston stopped their pantomime routines.
Interestingly just yesterday a neighbour said to me that when they see the ads on television they think “Oh those three again”. So it appears he won’t be watching anytime soon. Admittedly that is only one person, but suspect with no new cast in the judging/mentoring roles they will find it hard to the people who used to watch to turn back in.
Now that does not mean flick the three completely but rotate them through. It also gives Gary, Matt and George the opportunity to have a different chemistry with other people. Matt Preston was fantastic with Marco Pierre White in Masterchef Professionals a show that deserved higher ratings. Though they needed to add a bit more drama in it like the trash talking you see on Hell’s Kitchen and Top Chef, and apparently it was there we just did not see it. Not that we will see that show again though all people who watched it thought highly of it.
Some women would be good. This year I can only remember seeing Maggie Beer early on in the season at Baross Bootcamp and Kirsten Tibbles set a pressure test. Maggie Beer might not be invited back due to her outburst earlier this year about reality shows using too many back stories and it not being all about the cooking. Interesting that reality TV is still an OK medium for her to flog her products through.
Also other interesting guest star chefs were Daniel Wilson from Huxtable who had a great TV personality as does Dan Hong who is a favourite of mine. Curtis Stone is a pure pro and one of the best challenges was when he and Shannon Bennett went back to their old high school and went head to head in a team challenge. But that was unique and hard to replicate each series.
One of the highest ratings weeks was Heston Blummenthal week which kills my theory that the cooking has to be accessible to viewers and the viewers can make it. People were lapping up his crazy cooking. Though word on the street is his Roast Lamb he made in Masterclass is delicious and easy to make!
Here are some thoughts on this series on what was good and what could do with improvement:
- Realising how much I miss the weekly routine of the mystery box and invention test would like to see them brought back as a Sunday staple;
- The contestants were not as strong as previous seasons but they were at their best when they got to cook their own food there needs to be more of that (see above);
- Challenges are fun and do break up the week however make them fun but only one a week otherwise some contestants get to coast through on others coat tails and others get put in elmination challenges because of others stuff ups;
- The girls v boys got people off side at the start particularly with the sexist ads. If they had just divided them that way at the beginning without all the gender war hype I doubt most people would have cared;
- Immunity pin challenges seemed to be fair this year except for the episode where it was certain one of the contestants would win one regardless of standard of cooking;
- Dubai was a bit of a let down, it was only two episodes after all the hype and only one really showcased the local cuisine;
- Hopefully next year they will go to India where there is a huge audience and it is an interesting cuisine;
- Keep in the come back week (I know I am in the minority on this one), but each year someone always gets unfairly eliminated and should have a shot of coming back in. However making it individual cooking not team challenges some good cooks were unfairly eliminated in this week this year. Twice people put up dish of the day and were gone.
- The four episodes are week are a good fit, and they could consider dumping Masterclass, or just have a couple of specials throughout the series.
What do you think would help freshen up Masterchef?
August 26, 2013 88 Comments
Masterchef Australia – Finals Week Kicks Off With An Old Fashioned Mystery Box
Finals week kicked off with a traditonal Masterchef challenge the Mystery Box followed by an Invention Test. This meant for both challenges the contestants were cooking their own dishes.
Before they started cooking the final five of Rishi, Lynton, Christina, Samira and Emma would have to compete in every elimination challenge this week but if they cooked the best dish they would gain an advantage.
The mystery box consisted of five ingredients that the contestants had described themselves as at the beginning of the series. Rishi was chilli, because he is red hot, Christina was chilli chocolate because she was sweet and spicy, Samira was Pomegranate Mollasses, Emma was coffee and Lynton had described himself as garlic.
The other five ingredients were ones the judges thought best represented the contestants.
They chose different ingredients for which best represented the contestants best. They chose kale for Emma because she likes to showcase unusual vegetables. I thought it may have been because it is a vegetable that polarises and people either love or hate it. Nuts for Samira as she used them a lot in cooking and prawns for Rishi because they are lean, kangaroo for Lynton as it is a protein that best represents him. I would have thought that was beef and onions for Christina as she is a cries all the time. Though Matt Preston kindly pointed out that it was because she is emotional.
Pomegranate and chili prawns with onion fritters by Rishi.
Lynton cooked kangaroo with kale juice and was going to make onion bechamel sauce.
Emma was making kangaroo and kale and Christina was making Chilli Chocolate Ganache.
Samira took off the prawns and thought i was undercooked but thought with resting time it would cook through.
Samira cooked Kale soup which had started off as puree with marinated prawns. The prawns were raw for some reason she thought they would cook through while they were resting. It was a rookie error.
Lynton was Kangaroo with Kale puree. It looked nice on the plate and he had changed it a bit from when Gary and George had done the kitchen circuit earlier turning his nose up at what Lynton had been cooking. Gary did not like the onions which had been cooked in milk as he thought it was bitter.
Christina’s Chocolate Chilli Ganache was too simple and she was told she was in trouble if she does not pull her socks up.
Rishi made chilli prawns with onion bhaji. It was middle of the road not helped that his split his mayonaisse.
Emma made Pan seared Kangaroo with Kale cooked a few ways. It looked like Jackons Pollock on a plate or ala George Calombaris and Matt said it was a cracking dish.
Emma won and she got to choose the protein in the invention test. She ended up choosing barramundi after she was told it was an open pantry. But her definition of open pantry is different from what Masterchef/Coles think it is. There were no clams or mussels so she had to chain her dish to a cumin and coriander crusted crispy skin barramundi.
Rishi was making a barramundi tagine which was different from the other four however he was told it was delicious but was it really inventive enough?
Emma was making crispy skin barramundi with coriander and cumin crust, leek and potato puree and a beurre blanc. Her sauce was going pear-shaped and Gary had to tell her how to fix it. Seriously it is final weeks the judges should not have to be so hands on. Just as she finished it she realised it was an inventive test and there was nothing inventive about her dish. Matt said nothing that is on that plate does you discredit but it was not inventive.
Samira made barramundi with puree and pickled vegetables. the fish was cooked beautifully. Matt said it was beautiful cooking. I did note that when she was testing it with a skewer she stuck it in the fish the put it on her lip and then stuck it back in the fish a couple of times. You really do wonder what goes on in kitchens.
Lynton’s looks like a dogs breakfast. It was Barramundi and corn broth and the fish was over cooked. George kindly said it was great flavour.
Christina made barramundi, mushroom with bacon dashi this was definitely the most inventive and the judges liked it and it was no surprise she made the top two along with Samira. But it was Samira who won and will gain the advantage in tomorrows elimination.
August 26, 2013 60 Comments
The X Factor -The First Live Show
It is a truth universally acknowledged that the first of the live shows of any reality singing show there will be nerves that effect their voices and the judges will be very positive about most if not all the acts. And that was how it played out on the first live show of The X Factor Australia.
The X Factor is different from the other shows is they put on a stage show as well which can be entertaining but at times can overshadow the singers.
The performances were:
Third D3GREE – #thatpower – They were first up and they were really good especially the two girls singers. Kelebek just has star written all over her and was so confident up on stage. Enjoyed it a lot and I don’t even like that type of music.
Barry Southgate – When I Get You Alone – sounded nervous and towards the end was very breathy indeed. Sure he is good looking but the dnacers overshadowed his performance. Also long time reality fans remember that other ‘fro Guy Sebastian singing it on Australian Idol, a show that Barry has also been on. Nat B was out of line putting Barry on the spot asking “what will happen when you get me alone?”. Reverse the genders and there would be a social media meltdown about inappropriate behaviour.
Joirdan Tolli – Smile – Redfoo is trying to bring her whimisical style into a pop mould. Which is smart for this show. Did she knock the song out of the ball park? No. But was it entertaining? Yes.
Taylor Henderson- I Won’t Let You Go – They are pulling out the small town boy back story again like last year’s Jason Owens. This time he lives in a town of six. His rendition was fine but not memorable as there were a few pitch issues. Lucky for him he did not have to contend with much razzle dazzle – no dancers or sets just a chair and some back up musos.
Cat Vas – Addicted To Love – She was a bit weak on the home visits but tonight she looked the part and her voice was interesting. Also it was an interesting rendition of the classic but overplayed Robert Palmer song. Also Dani Minogue was smart with her song choice as she said she wanted a song that made people know that Cat was going to be a contender in the competition as she has not been a standout in the last view weeks.
Adira-Belle – Run The World (Girls) – They started off strong but seemed to get a bit lost half way through then pulled it together again. This group have a lot of potential but the way the song was put together with them mainly singing together it was not that entertaining.
Ellie Lovegrove – Songbird – Redfoo must have only arrived for the dress rehearsals as there was no footage of him in the “first rehearsal”. She is one of the power singers in the competition. Great voice, dull rendition of the song. Ronan said the song got away from her. Though Nat B thought it was really beautiful but she was being nice.
JTR – Everything Has Changed Now – The boy band made up of three brothers is being positioned for the teen girl fans. They are cute and have an inoffensive vibe. Only issue their voices got drowned out a bit by the music. Ronan who was the only judge who had taken the truth serum told them their vocals needed to be stronger.
Omar Dean – Numb – And that was what that performance made me feel and not in a good way. His vocals were weak and at one point it looked like he forgot his lines or ran out of puff. The worst performance of the night. It was so bad even the judges had to make some negative criticisms. Nat B said she like the song choice but she said the flasetto was under. Dani wanted it at another level, Redfoo said he needs to believe that he deserves to be here and Ronan agreed but told him he is going to get better and better. I don’t know if he will be getting the chance to sing again.
Dami Im – One – Was the stand out performance of the night she played the piano which was flying (not as cheesy as it sounds) and hit every note including some big notes at the end. She marked herself a contender. Nat B said best vocal of the night by far.
Joelle – Sweet Nothing – I thought she was a surprise pick for the live shows, and she got lost with all the backing dancers. Her voice is OK but she does have a look but not sure there is anything really original there. However all the judges gushed over her.
Jai Waetford – Fix You – Was given the last spot hopefully for him all the fans that vote for him have not been sent to bed. He has a cute voice but it was not perfect. However definitely not the worst of the night and he is cute and can sing a bit. Also it was amusing when he said in the last few months life has gotten so much more interesting. Ronan Keating thinks he can win with the under 24 boys. I think he will struggle as none of them have got really strong vocals. He has to hope that Jai can bring it home for him.
Bottom two prediction: Ellie Goulding and Omar Dean
What did you think of the performances?
August 26, 2013 22 Comments
Dancing With The Stars – Kelly Osbourne To Co-Host?
There is speculation that Kelly Osbourne is the front runner for the role of co-host for the revamped Dancing With The Stars.
It is a bold choice by SEVEN picking another overseas star for the role of talking to the contestants in the green room. Mel B was not that good last year as they don’t have that Australian sense of humour and it was all very stilted.
This might explain why she popped up in the home visits on The X Factor in Los Angeles with Ronan Keating. It was a bizarre choice and all the other special guests on these visits were professional singers.
If this rumour is true how is she going to fit in her co-hosting role on Fashion Police on E!? Kelly will also have to repair some media bridges if she does take the gig because when she was out in Australia earlier this year, for the re-launched Cleo a magazine she writes a column for she managed to piss a few of the main entertainment writers off. See stories here and here.
The SMH who are running the Kelly Osbourne rumour are also saying Adam Garcia and Kym Johnston will be new faces on the judging panel. Kym who has been dancing in the US version of the show for a number of years was seen recently on NINE’s Celebrity Apprentice. She was nice but not the most dynamic personality to be on a television screen.
Contestant rumours include Tina Arena,Tony Barbar, Jesinta Campbell, Rhiannon Fish, Libby Trickett, Paul Cosentino, Sally Obermeder, twin brother models Jordan and Zac Stenmark.
Dancing With the Star on SEVEN later this year.
August 25, 2013 8 Comments
Masterchef Australia Andre Ursini Named In Top 50 Hottest Restaurants List
Congratulations to Andre from season one Masterchef Australia restaurant has been named as one of Australia’s Top 50 restaurants.
Andre’s Cucina & Polenta Bar in Adelaide has been named in The Australian’s prestigious Top 50 restaurants. He opened the restaurant three years ago as a polenta bar, however The Australian states the restaurant has “evolved into a broader, totally convincing package.”
Andre Ursini came seventh in season one of the show, however was probably best known for his strawberry risotto which started of the trend of risotto being known as a death dish. However for Andre after he finished his stint on Masterchef he opened his eating establishment in his home town of Adelaide.
This award gives credibility to Masterchef and goes to show that there have been some serious amateur cooks go on the show and not just media wannabees.
Check out is restaurant at andrescucina.com.au
Other Masterchef special guest stars that made the list include:
- Peter Gilmore’s Quay in Sydney which came in number one on the list;
- Ben Shrewy’s – Melbourne – Attica;
- Hadleigh Troy’s – East Perth – Restaurant Amuse;
- Katrina Kanetani’s – Bangalow called Town;
- Kylie Kwong’s – Sydney – Billy Kwong;
- Andrew McConnell – Melbourne – Golden Fields/Cumulus Inc/ Cumulus Up and Moon Under Water;
- Adam D’Sylva – Melbourne – Tonka;
- Alla Wolf-Tasker – Daylesford – Lake House;
- Martin Benn – Sydney – Sepia;
- David Chang – Sydney – Momofuku Seiobo; and
- Ben Milgate and Elvis Abrahanowicz – Sydney – Bodega.
Hat tip to Dr T for the mention of the article.
August 25, 2013 6 Comments
