Posts from — June 2009
Masterchef – and the winner for most overwrought dramatic pauses goes to…
As always, the elimination show starts off with a clip package of almost all of the previous episode. This means I tune out and start thinking about more important things: have I fed the cats? Is there any more cat litter? Did we use the last of the Spray’n’Wipe? Are there any garbage bags left? Did Poh only hug Andre? Oh, okay, we’re back to the show. I didn’t see Poh hugging anybody else, but I was going through my shopping list and might have missed it. Sam and Chris share a big hug, which shows that they got over all the kiddie mafia bitterness. That, or there was no KM bitterness in the first place and it was all an editing beat up. Surely not…
As the top four head off with Matt to enjoy lunch, Poh and Sam retire to the upper level of the House of Blue Leaves to debate the options for their challenge. Sam thinks they’ll cook off against each other, which is different to what normally happens how? Poh thinks it’s going to be a taste test.
As they wait it out, we get the usual pre-emptive eulogising of clip packages and interviews. Poh tells us she’s learned about people and human nature. As she confides this, we see her cackling again over the croquembouche with no base. Oh, Poh, it would be such a tragedy if you were to go home tonight. You only stuffed up about 95% of the time, after all.
Sam’s happy to have come so far but would still like to stay to continue the learning. His clip package underscored the fact that his contribution to the show was negligible. Either that, or there wasn’t a clip package.
Let’s cast off the stench of the losers for a moment. The glorious top four are at est with Matt Preston, who gives them tips about fine dining and the difference between fine dining and bistro food. They meet Peter Doyle and he takes them into the kitchen for some of that valuable professional kitchen experienceTM. As they learn stuff, Julie interviews that Poh and Sam aren’t far from their minds. I hope she’s not wasting the lesson worrying about them.
Back at Masterchef HQ we discover that Sam’s spidey senses are all out of whack. There will be no cook-off! It’s taste-buds at dawn. Sam’s initial reaction is to deflate, somewhat, as he acknowledges Poh’s superior palate. He brightens when the dish is revealed. A minestrone – no matter how much of a special secret my mate Steve recipe it is – will be easy! He has an Italian background!
Gary and George explain the rules. There are 18 ingredients, yeah? Each person will take it in turns to identify an ingredient, yeah? The first person to incorrectly identify an ingredient is out. Immediately. Yeah? They tell us it’s a penalty shootout situation. I know less than nothing about soccer, but the reluctant TV viewer (RTVV) snorted that this in no way resembled a penalty shoot-out. Apparently penalty shoot-outs (shoots-out?) are not sudden death. Or something. I muttered “golden minute” but was really clutching at straws.
Things start off as you would expect. Celery? Dramatic pause. “Are you saying you think there’s celery in here?” Incredulous eyebrow pop. “Do you want to taste it again?” Slow walk towards a covered plate to reveal… celery. Poh’s turn: Carrot? Dramatic pause. “Are you saying you think there’s carrot in here?” Incredulous eyebrow pop. “Do you want to taste it again?” Slow walk towards a covered plate to reveal… carrot. Sam: onion? Dramatic pause. (At this point, the RTVV reached for the remote and we were almost launched into the early screening of Colbert until I yelped “the blog!”).
Poh obviously believes that she does, indeed, have a superior palate as she guesses “parmesan” without even tasting again. George seems to be a bit pissed off that she’s not going through the proper process, and he queries her confidence. He is not reassured when she tells him that she puts parmesan in her minestrone at home. Doesn’t she get that this is his mate Steve’s super special minestrone? All the histrionics are for nothing – parmesan is revealed as one of the eighteen ingredients.
This does make me question Poh’s strategic intelligence, though. At this stage, neither has identified salt, pepper or garlic and they are down to the last five or so ingredients. Parmesan is something you wouldn’t see in the soup and the other person might overlook it, so I’d think it would be best keeping something like that up your sleeve (not literally, of course).
Sam guesses something – cabbage, I think, that you could see floating in the soup – and then it’s Poh’s turn again. Unless the editors have decided to be particularly unkind to Poh tonight, she has another guess without a taste. Barley. Remember: salt, pepper and garlic are still up for grabs.
George and Gary are sorry, Poh, but your time as a Masterchef contestant is over.
Poh misses painting. Painting misses you too, Poh. Buh-bye.
Back at the house, four of the final five are waiting. They discuss the possible Poh vs Sam results. It takes them longer than you’d expect, given that there are – realistically – only two options. Justine has a soft spot for Sam, but it’s a tad patronising for a 23 year old to refer to a 24 year old as a “kid”. Julie loves them both. Julie loves everyone! Chris accuses the others of fence sitting and says he thinks Poh should stay. He obviously hasn’t read the Daily Tele. Or he has, and he knows that it’s all part of the game and respect for a competitor’s skill is more important to him than sheer likeability. That would be novel.
There are footsteps. “Sam walks in and I get surprised, because he walks like a girl.” (Julie)
Was it a good result? Sam has certainly outlasted what looks to be a fairly weak skill set, but Poh was becoming a regular in bottom three, and seemed to be out of her depth on the big challenges. The overwhelming sense that she’d received favoured treatment from the judges also probably damaged potential book sales.
Tomorrow night? George will over-enunciate his way through yet another masterclass. God help us all.
June 18, 2009 28 Comments
Masterchef – everybody loves a wedding
There are all sorts of people in the world. Well, duh. Some differences arise when people air their attitudes towards marriage. There are people who go weak at the knees over the mere thought of a wedding; people for whom their wedding is the most memorable event in their lives; those who celebrate their commitment in quirky ways; those who marry for practical reasons; those who never marry… and then, I guess, there are those who mouth all the clichés about the “specialness” of their day, but who then invite in a TV crew and a group of amateur caterers.
So, on the basis that I really do not understand the premise of this Masterchef challenge, here goes.
At the end of Justine’s pear battle with Matt Moran (sigh!), a couple of strangers wandered onto the set. When it was announced that they were getting married – the very next day! – and that our little crew of cooks was catering, there were expressions of excitement. The WTF? moment did not come until they were told that they were also required to make the cake. At this news, Julie came over all “who leaves organising their cake to the last minute?” and, as many have observed, the answer is clearly “the loonies who’d leave the food at their wedding up to you guys”. Julie obviously has a talent for holding what appear to be conflicting beliefs. To wit: she believes that weddings are super-duper special occasions; she does not feel that this is cheapened by the incursion of a reality TV crew. She believes that the food at a wedding is what people remember; she accepts the idea that an untried group of cooks should be responsible for this.
Anyway, the group learned that they would work as a team, but be evaluated on their individual performance. The menu, which had been devised by the bride and groom, was divvied up between the contestants. Julie and Poh each took a canopy… sorry, canapé… and an entree. Justine and Andre each took a main, and Sam and Chris – oddly – took desserts. From this point on, we got a lot of footage of Poh saying that she shouldn’t have chosen two dishes that went out first. Julie had the same courses and seemingly none of the same panic, so this episode goes straight to the “shut up, Poh” file.
Before the team could even hit the kitchen, there was the small matter of the cake to sort out. The Masterchef kitchen had been stocked with ingredients, recipes and a pastry chef from the bakers of Sydney’s finest wedding cakes. My provincial nature means that, not only had I not heard of them, but I didn’t bother to catch their name. Sorry, marketing people. The cake, we were repeatedly told, would take seven hours. They started at nine pm. This seems like an arbitrary challenge just to tire people out and – oh, I dunno – hope that drama is created through the sorts of mistakes overly tired people make. But, of course, I’m just being cynical.
The previewed drama of Justine prophesying that her team would kill her over a mistake she’d made turned out to be a confection of hype. The cakes were turned out, everything seemed okay, and Chris and Poh stayed on to decorate whilst the others got some sleep. Poh did a sterling job on the piping and you’d think this experience would bond them. You’d be wrong.
Wedding day! Poh started on the canopies… sorry, canapés… and made me question why I ever created a macro for “Julie panics”. She got the usual attention from Gary and George, and a time-out in the cool room with Chris, who stepped up (that’s for anyone playing reality cliché bingo) to take on the role of leader. We saw everybody chipping in to help everybody else and when, at the end, Chris realised that his leaderiness might have got in the way of his cookeriness it seems like there might be a surprise upset. Poh interviewed that she’d be really pissed off if Chris got the credit for a dish that so many people helped on. She didn’t acknowledge any of the help she’s benefited from over the past few weeks.
In fact, this was the only real drama in the kitchen, apart from the injuries Sam sustained. Now, I’m one of those viewers who greets every appearance of Sam with the question “Why is he still here?”, based on the complete lack of skill he’s demonstrated to date. Some might think I would be relieved to have my opinion confirmed by his performance in this challenge, but no. Okay, I think sticking your hand in the blender is a pretty daft thing to do. Doing it twice is particularly moronic. Why wasn’t I railing at the TV, then? Because this is exactly what would happen to me if I’d been up all night, and recently married myself and a professed believer in the importance of the wedding day. And this must have been what was intended when the cake challenge was on, because the cake? Didn’t figure at all in the judges reckoning of their performances. Badly done, Ten, badly done.
Sarah got a starring role in this episode, being Matt’s arm candy and an official taster. Yay, Sarah! I loved the way she gazed at Matt while he was eating and brought all her editing skills to bear on slightly rewording his opinion every time she was called on to evaluate. Actually, it was good to see another opinion on the food, and both judges seemed to accord with the general opinion of the guests.
So, how did it all turn out? Poh’s canopy… sorry, canapé… was tasty, but the pastry was too thick. Julie’s was good. Poh’s entree had nice flavours, but the chicken was dry. Julie’s was lovely. Mains: Andre seemed to be getting away with serving meat that had bled into the potato and Justine’s generous salmon portions were spot on. Sam’s lemon tart pastry was too thick, and many guests left the crust on their plates. Chris’ fondant was superb.
Back in the Masterchef kitchen, the contestants were told how their dishes went, and there was potential for drama when Matt waxed lyrical about Chris’ perfect fondant. Chris did’t string out the drama and immediately gave credit to the others for helping out. Poh looked pissed off. Who’s safe? Julie, Justine, Chris and… Andre. Meaning that Poh and Sam will go head-to-head (drink!) in an elimination battle the likes of which we’ve never seen before!
A coupla things:
- Sam had a rough day. He was given credit for helping turn out perfect fondants, but he is up for elimination. I felt sorry for him, especially since Gary was all “uh, der” when he asked if he had to make the pastry. Guys, you’ve given the contestants packaged pastry every other time, so it wasn’t that much of an assumption.
- Poh has been getting the judge-love all season so I did feel sorry for her last night. It’s one thing to have a melt-down; it’s completely another to be pasted for it having been nurtured and babied through them before.
- Why didn’t Julie just use gluten free flour for all the potato cakes? Would have saved having a stingy looking six set aside. What if some of the guests also needed gluten free and assumed that the menu would be tailored for them, knowing the bride’s needs?
June 18, 2009 22 Comments
Australia’s Next Top Model – Somebody Is Not Going To The Mother Country
I thought it was ironic NIDA got involved with filming with Australia’s Next Top Model. All the actors I know complain about reality TV because stations produce it because it is cheaper than proper drama, therefore they are out of work. Will NIDA be expanding to a reality TV acting class like the New York Reality TV School.
The girls certainly need acting skills in this genre, and it would appear the lesson was part way successful due to the way they had to pretend a puppet show had surprisingly been set up in the next room and they had not heard a thing.
One of tasks for the episode was casting for a Telstra advertisment. Tahnee who appears to be peaking at the right time got the lead with Franky and Clare in the support roles. Clare however was told if she did not tone down the prissyness Cassi would take over her part.
The only part Adele was ever going to get was if it was a zombie flick. I agree with host Sarah Murdoch she is dull.
Cassi has an attitude where she thinks that she has been on ANTM therefore a successful modelling career will just evolve. She said at the Telstra shoot “I’m really not jealous, as I know I will be able to get stuff like that when I get out.”
Also speaking of deluded, what was that hideous yellow jacket Johnathan Pease was wearing at the Ford fashion shoot? Did he really think he looked good in it? It could be the fashion crime of the year and quite possibly the decade.
The girls were going to be modelled on a style icon of a particular decade and of course pose with an iconic Ford of that era. Christ how dumb are these girls. Tahnee didn’t know who Elizabeth Taylor was. Adele didn’t know who was Greta Garbo. And Franky was a vague on what Grace Jones did. Why don’t they get their phones out and google the names to find out a bit about them.
Cassi thought being Victoria Beckham was to be Posh, but she didn’t realise the Posh title was ironic.
Sarah said Clare did well doing Twiggy, but Sarah thought she” did not give anything else.”. Franky got big wraps.
Cassi then had another drama about not wanting to go to London and told her boyfriend she would be happier modelling at home. She said she was going to nominate herself to go home. The girls cheered but were dubious this would occur. It would appear it was just more attention seeking behaviour.
Obviously the producers knew there was going to be drama, as for the first time they had a camera in the girls ante room at the elimination set. Adele burst into tears when Cassi came back from her solo talk with the judges where they hinted she would be staying in the competition.
I thought is was interesting that Sarah Murdoch was outvoted and Franky was eliminated and Adele got to stay. My bet is Adele out next week and Clare, Tahnee and Cassi to be final three.
June 17, 2009 16 Comments
MasterChef Australia Justine V Matt Moran
Have you noticed the closer the MasterChef prize becomes the quieter the peanut gallery becomes? Barely a peep gone are the days the balcony were as vocal as a Greek chorus. More on that later.
Tonight it was Justine’s second time in the beat the chef challenge, and tonight she was up against talented chef Matt Moran. I loved when they introduced him and said everything he had done they did not mention he had been host of The Chopping Block. That would have been promoting another TV station.
Matt Moran showed tonight why he is such good TV talent he was nice, cheeky, mentored Justine well, and he looked damn hot. Hopefully this will not be the last time we see him on the show.
Real chef’s make desserts as tonight’s dish was to replicate an Aria dish pear tart, with poached pear, crumble and caramel. I don’t know why so many chefs just think the dessert course is beneath them. There were a lot of components to the dish, and I thought it was a bit rough Justine only had a 15 minute head start.
She did not help herself by forgetting about the crumble and burning it. Now the way it was edited would indicate that Poh noticed that Justine had the crumble in the oven, however did not say anything. Funny how she managed to shout out to Guy Grossi in a previous challenge when his plating collapsed.
To be fair to Poh none of the others said anything either, and Julie definitely knew as Poh whispered to her about it. Maybe they are all getting worried there will be no places for them in the final week if people keep on getting through.
Justine’s plate scored quite high with a score of 24/30 overall. However what cracked me up about tonight’s judging was how sychophantic the judges were, particularly Matt Preston, and Gary Mehigan were to Matt Moran. Very different from other weeks. Gary gave him 10/10 funny considering he said he had preferred the flavour of the tart on Justine’s plate, and Matt Preston gave him 9/10 “I would have given you a ten, but I know you prefer a nine.” There was so much love in the air I thought a group hug was going to evolve.
Justine has been annointed the one to beat at this stage. The only other three that are in it at this stage are Chris, Lucas and Julia.
June 16, 2009 14 Comments
Geni From MasterChef Australia Confirms Sam Cannot Cook
Here is Geni’s interview with TV Week. In this interview she again says she is surprised that Sam is still in the competition as he cannot cook.
In her answer to who do you think will win she said:
To be honest, I don’t believe that Sam is still in there. Sam cannot cook. If it’s personality “” maybe they go for that. And Julie being a housewife, they may go for that, [but] I don’t think she’s the greatest cook either. I would like to see Andre winning because he’s the only one who believes so much in quality ingredients and has the patience. So yes, it’s more than just having the ability, it’s reality TV “” I have to keep that in mind all the time.
As I was perusing the TV Week yesterday there was a quote from Sam saying prior to coming into the house he was a junk food addict, and also his friends would be surprised he had entered a cooking competition. Clearly he does not have much of a palate.
That explains why is dishes are not great. So why are they keeping him in the competition? It is not like he is hot, witty or has a rocking personality. Maybe a Sam fan could tell me why.
Also she has revealed again that it is GAME ON in the house when she said this:
Most people would cook so that people wouldn’t learn. I cooked in front of everyone and showed them how I did things. And I wouldn’t cook early in the morning so no one could see it and then put it away like others did. I don’t regret anything, it’s all about sharing and learning from each other.
June 16, 2009 14 Comments


