Category — Home Made
Brief (and possibly final*) thoughts on homeMADE
Last night was the first elimination show on homeMADE and the cracks started to show in the concept. Even having a three-degrees-of-separation connection with the guest judge didn’t help.
Why?
As I mentioned in my previous post, I’m a complete sucker for reno shows, so was expecting this to grab me. Unfortunately, it is just grating.
- The arbitrary deadlines for the finished bedrooms were shown to be just that: arbitrary. Whilst other team members stepped in to help the bedroom designers reach their deadline, those designers just seemed to spend the remainder of the time perfecting their rooms rather than reciprocating.
- The bedroom designers seemed to get the benefit of input from the “guru”, which the others didn’t.
- One of the so-called “designers” fell at the obstacle of measuring the space and selecting appropriate furniture. Surely that’s Decorating 101. (The good news is that she was eliminated, I guess. Suzie Wilks is now the wearer of the second shortest pair of short shorts ever to grace a home reno show.)
- The judges criticised one of the houses for having no design cohesion, but there didn’t seem to be any time or structure built in for the teams to work as… a team.
- The houses looked so badly put together that it made me anxious. Looking at the hideous finishes screamed “poisoned chalice” rather than “free reno” to me.
- I find that I really can’t get over the mix of upper and lower case in the title. Petty, yes.
Will I watch it again? Probably not. If it was a once-a-week show in the 6.30 timeslot, I’d keep it on the radar, but I’m not going to watch the first half of a weekly elimination show. Nor am I ditching Model.
*RR might want to continue with it on her return, but it doesn’t bode well for a show that my reaction to the recording ending before the final judging for first elimination was “meh”.
May 13, 2009 2 Comments
homeMADE
Full disclosure: I loved Top Design. I loved The Block. I loved Changing Rooms. I’m saying this because I might not be the best judge of a renovation show – for me, it’s all about the sense of relief that I’m watching someone else’s reno nightmare.
The premise of homeMADE is straightforward. A cast of 10 “designers” has been assembled. They are split into teams and each team has five days and $50,000 to makeover an entire home. Each week, the losing team will lose a team member. Each team has a builder “free of charge” (i.e. the builder’s costs don’t come from the $50K; I doubt that the builders themselves are working pro bono) but all tradies are paid from the budget. In addition, all bedrooms have to be ready in the first 48 hours as the families need somewhere to sleep. Each reno is screened over two nights, Sundays and Tuesdays, with the elimination taking place on Tuesdays. It is being billed as “The biggest renovation competition ever attempted on television”.
On first viewing, this seems entertaining enough. The host/mentor (or “Design Guru”, as he is styled in the caption) is David Heimann, of Orson & Blake. In a previous post, RR noted that he is a TV novice – he’s doing a sterling job. His to-cameras were used for quite a bit of exposition, which was a quick way to orient viewers to the new show; as mentor, he provided detailed, constructive feedback to the designers.
The cast of designers is young and attractive. As with all reality shows, there are contestants with eccentric spelling (Chontelle and Tonie); contestants who get the clueless edit early (Annie, a flight attendant who “has never worked with a client”); and contestants who defy simple categorisation (Jason, the model, whose participation in the competition is “a spiritual thing” and who is relying on “forces from the universe” to help him. Also, his pants fall down a lot).
It will take a couple of weeks to settle into a rhythm with the show. The reality schedule is chockers right now, though, especially with the elimination episode programmed against Top Model and Masterchef filling up so much of the week.
Positives:
- no auditions! (although it might have been fun to see a prospective designer try to impress a producer in five minutes)
- the focus is on the work, rather than the personalities and back-stories
- the host
- I had to check the website to find out what the prize was, which means that they weren’t banging on about it every five seconds like some other shows *cough*Masterchef*cough*.
The jury’s still out on:
- having all the competitors share a house – why? It’s completely unnecessary and might become a crutch for some filler drama
- the judges – we’ll meet them tomorrow
- the decision-making process – David can’t have a role, being the mentor, but what about the home-owners?
- the structure of the show – will assigning rooms to designers have a bearing on the result? There seems to be a lot of pressure upfront on the bedroom designers
- the editing – hopefully we’ll get a better look at before/after
- the random upper/lower case title. Actually, that’s a lie – I hate it.
- the “Dodge Journey” giveaway? Dodge? Really?
May 11, 2009 2 Comments
Reality Tidbits
Australia’s Next Top Model Severs Ties With Vogue Australia
A new host is not the only change of this season’s Australia’s Next Top Model, as Harper’s Bazaar and Cosmopolitan will take over from Vogue Australia as the magazine represented in the show. The Sunday Tele gossip column (scroll down the article) states the split could have occurred because they did not put Demelza Reveley last year’s winner on the cover as they did with Alice Burdeau. However I think this is bollocks as Alice was the first winner ever to be put on the cover and there was never any expectation that other winners would get this honour.
Head Judge For Interior Design Show Home Made Announced.
Belle magazine editor-in-chief Neale Whitaker has joined the team on Nine’s lifestyle reality series Home Made. It is thought his role will be as head judge. Similar to that of Johnathan Adler of Arena’s Top Design. Sorry I should not have mentioned those shows in the same post as apparently they are going to be completely different. Each show is about interior designers competing to design different spaces and a designer is eliminated each week.
The producers Julian Cress and David Barbour of The Block fame, look like they are on a winner with this show. Also they always have high production values. David Heimann, proprietor of Orson & Blake will be the host.
Masterchef Australia – Another Melbourne Chef/Judge Announced.
As a Sydneysider I am about to crawl into a dark corner and curl into the feotal position with shame. Matt Preston a chef from Melbourne has been announced as the third judge to join the other two chefs from Melbourne Gary Mehigan and George Calombaris. Just a minor snipe why no female judge? Are there no good female televisual chefs in Australia?
The show is currently in pre-production and carrying out auditions throughout Australia.
Project Runway Australia Season 2 – Applications Are Now Open.
Project Runway Australia Season 2 applications are now open for aspiring or otherwise fashion designers. It will start filming in April and will launch midyear. Kristy Hinzes will continue to be the host.
Aspiring designers need to upload a CV, design samples and a video audition at arenatv.com.au
January 27, 2009 Comments Off on Reality Tidbits
Home Made Similar To Top Design? Who Cares Top Design Rocks
David Heimann, the owner of interior stores Orson & Blake has been named host and mentor on Channel Nine’s new reality TV show Home Made. It is a bold move by Nine as David has no previous TV experience. I am loving there is going to be some fresh talent on TV this year, this follows on from Channel Ten’s decision to make another unknown Sarah Wilson as host of Masterchef Australia.
The Daily Telegraph reveals Home Made will have up and coming interior designers competing with each other as they work with real clients – families in the suburbs looking for a professional interior makeover. I am presuming this is an elimination show and the last one standing will win some fabulous prize.
Heimann denies the show is a copy of popular US show Top Design.
He points out that “Top Design only works with sets whereas here there will be real clients,”. Personally I am not seeing a huge amount of difference, but really who cares, Top Design which is shown on Arena TV is a fantastic and entertaining show.
Season 2 of Top Design premieres on Arena TV on Monday 19 January at 9.30pm. The second series will not have first season host the serene Todd Oldham, but model and designer India Hicks. Todd will continue on as an occasional mentor.
The Futon Critic has an interview with India Hicks about Season 2 where she mentions the differences between series 1 and 2.
“The main different is going to be that we are really designing outside of the box. I mean, quite literally this time. On Season 1 they were designing inside these white boxes and this time we’ve taken our kids out in to real places and real settings.”
The shows sound pretty similar to me. I think Channel 9 could be on a winner with this one. Oh and if they need volunteers to have their houses made over, my Ikea chic house could do with a bit of razzle dazzle.
January 16, 2009 Comments Off on Home Made Similar To Top Design? Who Cares Top Design Rocks


