The Renovators – The Finale
Tonight The Renovators finally showed the finale. Most viewers would know the houses went to auction a couple of weeks ago over a three night period.
However not in The Renovators land. Brendan and the judges were pretending the auctions were all on the same night. In fact everyone wore the same clothes three nights in a row. I hope they were washed at least once in that time.
Brendan was also now pimping that the winner will be Australia’s best renovator not whipping them into a frenzy about all the money they could potentially win.
Anyway the auction kicked off with the weatherboard with Melissa as keyholder.
Brendan told her the weatherboard profit point was $573,855.
It sold for $575,000. Mel was disappointed and thinks they got a bargain. In a previous episode she thought it was worth over $700,000. She was dreaming. So she made a profit of $1,145. However as Brendan cheerfully pointed out she was the leading renovator. Even Melissa was not that stupid as she realised if she won the show her prize winnings would be less than $6,000.
Next up was August at the Marrickville shop.
The profit point for the Marrickville shop was $713,676. There was only one bid who came in with $700,000. He must be kicking himself he should have started at $650,000.
At this point Robyn Holt did a Scott Cam (when Chez’s apartment had not sold) and looked at her shoes and said nothing. Props to Barry Dubois for carrying an uncomfortable moment through.
Luke’s inner city terrace’s price profit point was $899,268.
It was hilarious all the inner city latte drinkers asked for their faces to be pixelated. Possibly not cool to be seen on a reality show.
It is sold for $925,000. Which gave it a profit of $25,732 which give him a profit point of 2.86%. He took over the lead.
The half done house auction was a disaster. Melissa thought it would suit a gay couple because it is immaculate. Let’s not stereotype. However Peter would have liked anyone with a bit of cash to turn up.
The profit point was $802,083. As Baz tried to whip up some excitement Robyn was the voice of reason when she said “we need another bidder”. The bidding stalled at $710,000. There was a vendor’s bid at $750,000. the house eventually sold for $770,000.
It was Natalia’s turn to have her real estate dreams dashed. The sixties suburban looked great and either nothing is happening in Castle Hill or there were some genuine buyers there. The profit point was $758,194. There was a lot of action but only sold for $730,000. Suzanne smirked and Nathan had his head in his hands.
Then it was time for the final house. The fibro house was the one the producers must have thought would win as they put it last.
All of the contestants are at the fibro house and it looked cold. Brendan gives Michael the bad news that currently the profit pool is only $26,000.
The profit point was $371,988.
The Fibro shack sold for $440,000 to a very nice young lad, so Michael won. His prize pool was $94,889. Brendan told him they were going to round it up to $100,000.
Unfortunately I don’t think we will be seeing another series of The Renovators which is a pity as the bones were there for a great reality show.

63 comments
Ten let them blow 24 grand each on a single stupid whiteroom challenge and then rounded up the winnings by 5,ooo$??!!!
Good on Michael. He looked very white and shattered. And good on nice young fellow who bought it.
And that Brandy is why people didnt watch it and why there will only be one season. All the money and energy wasted in the challenges and then very little time spent in the actual houses.
Question is what would the houses have looked like if there had been no prizes. Most likely they would have sold for a lot less.
It was a very badly thought out concept launched at a most inopportune time. Glad Michael won though. I read today in The West Australian that Robyn would do a second series if she’s asked but believes the show has a lot of flaws and needs to be rethought. You can say that again.
As much as I enjoyed this show, particularly the contestants and the judges, the executive producer deserved this after deciding to sandwich Renovators during the Masterchef finale at the beginning and giving a big f to the face of the public by denying how that was such a failure, and that the decision in the programming was going to be successful.
I do hope the show gets a second season, with the appropriate adjustments, because like everyone has said it definitely had the potential. I hope The Renovators follows a similar fate to AGT! and The Block in terms of viewership, both shows copped a flaking in their first seasons but both have achieved very respectable ratings now into their current seasons.
Forgot to add – one thing that this finale did very well – none of those stupid asides with contestants talking in the present tense, when clearly they’re talking to the camera after its happened!
More of this format for Masterchef next year would be appreciated – all these “stating the obvious” asides are so dull to watch…
I think they will not start this show again. They did get profit overall. Any way congrats Michael . Also Luke should have some prize too , he was the second person who earned profit from his house
Isn’t it funny how all the property renovation shows that have aired this year have been an overwhelming disaster in terms of profit raised on each house? The appalling housing market across Australia probably isn’t helping matters, but still.
I’m silently hoping that we’re finished with these types of shows for a long while.
So pleased that Michael won. I thought Luke would be the winner, although I don’t like the terrace at all just not my style.
Cannot believe the original asking prices for some of these places. I know it’s Sydney but ……
Congrats to Michael
I’m so happy Michael won! He’s been my fave since day one. I let out a big cheer when the price tip over the top.
Anyone else notice the “football WAG” girlfriend? Michaels’ doing well in all areas of life I think!
And I think Michael’s buyer could have passed as Luke’s younger brother.
I was amused at the change in Luke’s hair. It went from rather flat to very spiky towards the end. Didn’t know it was filmed over several days (nights). Also, why wasn’t Michael’s friend/wife/whatever introduced. And I didn’t like that he totally ignored her. Was Kim wearing a fur?? Not happy if she was.
We don’t know if he ignored her. We don’t know what was left on the cutting room floor.
As for Kim, she’s a classy broad. What more can be said?
I liked the white room challenges. that was the only one that upset me re wasted dollars. I think the problem with ratings was the assumption people would want to go straight into something after Masterchef and with the Block still on, and then the time-changes and general air of despair that put out. They should have acted the way they did with 7pm project. No faith, and Murdochs are what killed this great show. I hope it comes back next year. But then the renovators will be all would-be Zoo models…
after everything is done and dusted , so rapted that the fibro won, well done micheal and jarrod well done !!!! natalia’s face GOLD from smug to oops i’m in dip pooh pooh here and peter “what nobody loves my over the top house ” . i want another series please and please save me from junior masterchef little spoilt brats .
back to the land of real accounting…
yep, that wacky place where you have to count losses as well as profits.
By my calculations, based solely on the show’s dubious ‘profit point’* as presented above by Raver they made a ‘profit’ of only $20,936.
This equates to phenomonal 0.5% return on investment across the entire property portfolio. Though the real figures if you factor in contestant’s lost wages and all the other frivolous expenditure would be deep in the red.
In economic productivity terms a show called The Dole Bludgers would probably present a better balance sheet.
On the positive side, the most worthy contestant won, which was good. Well done Mickey Dread!
* (this was only based on the value bought and the purported budget – not the other money thrown at the contestants, nor the contestant’s labour/time/lost wages)
I’d really like to see another season of The Renovators, but after last night’s disastrous prices, which follows a similar result on The Block, I’ve been thinking: What could the producers do to change the auction outcomes?
Does there need to be disclosure as to the renovation budget (and therefore the required sale / profit price)? The reserve is kept secret from buyers for a good reason, so to break with this seems to be hurting the sales results badly.
Why wasn’t a vendor bid used at every auction? Seems a waste when the ‘reserve’ (profit price) wasn’t reached. Or were the purchase prices of some properties artificially inflated to Ten would guarantee a profit?????
Why weren’t properties that didn’t reach the profit point passed in as they did on The Block? At least then they could have negotiated up to a reasonable level.
Would a longer marketing campaign be of benefit? The end of both shows seemed quite rushed and The Renovators didn’t deal with the campaign side of things at all.
Remember back to the first season of The Block when Crazy John bought one of the apartments? The production team needs to get back to grass roots and ensure that future auctions are stacked with corporate buyers who would benefit from the national TV exposure.
Any other suggestions??
Culinary Boner , don’t forget they were each also paid a stipend (industry rate of 500-700 a week) , that they were accomodated , & possibly fed & watered as well – then add the pointless Qld trip ….
Well that was a train wreck. Convoluted rules like a game of Bridge anyone? Multitudinous repulsive hosts that were as inspiring as toast and the contestants working their bodies to breaking point; I’m keenly awaiting to read the ‘Woman’s Day’ articles about the asbestosis and back injury claims which will be the real legacy of the Renovators.
I hope it comes back next year with a few changes though.
If they want a more accurate way to find the best renovator, they need to decide this purely on challenges in the warehouse. There are a lot of circumstances that can affect auction prices.
what they need to do is find homes in areas that do sell , also no product placement (freedom ) , just give them a correct budget and let them buy anything like on ebay , recycled items, discounted items, free furniture and old wares that the council pick up of nature strips . not high class items which no renovator would buy , can you imagine how many tips you would learn . you would be really sticking to a budget plus have renovators live in the state were they live ,so they can cut travel time .no key holder just a team of four watch em go and please not so many challenges .so simple .
My two cents if they bring it back: consistancy in elimination challenges. some were white rooms, others were panic rooms, some were just random crap with foam.
I don’t knoe if the eliminations were worth it, it just seemed like a way to be different to the block.
In Masterchef the eliminations work, because there are no teams. Another thing Masterchef stated back at the beginning was that even though they had commercial obligations with coles etc, they wouldn’t stop a guest chef from bringing in an ingredient that wasn’t affilliated with coles, they just wouldn’t say where it was from. I feel the renovators had too much focus on freedom furniture. I don’t like or dislike freedom, I just think Mel could have furnished her backroom with things from freecycle if she had run out of money and just stated they were vintage.
If weatherboard house is back on market it probably never sold. Auction bids cannot be cancelled that easily (almost impossible) and while settlement can be rushed it seems way to quick. So, either it sold and has such major problems the new owner couldn’t wait to unload it or it never sold and whole auction rigged.
Congrats to Michael though I think the $40K pool helped him win it (and was not included in the “profit point”) I wonder if the 60’s suburban would have sold better with Michael’s pool instead?
kingfisher, we must have been typing at the same time, I totally agree
I am feeling really flat after the debacle of last night. I knew result but it was the pretending to auction all houses on one night and repeat lines from contestants and judges. Oh I wish they had shown peter in true colours. Dead boring Shine, could have been done much better.
it would’ve been dumber if they’d spent the show going, “Hey, remember last week?! hey, yeah, when your house was auctioned for a disappointing sum, remember how that felt?”
renocrazy, could you go into more detail on someone stumbling on a step and wailing about their result? I hope it was Beaky!
“From the makers of Ma$terchef”- says it all .
I too am feeling flat but not because of the auction results (although why the contestants weren’t allowed to pass the auctions in if it didn’t meet their reserve is anyone’s guess. I mean, only one vendor’s bid?). Possibly knowing that this is the last thread makes me a bit sad.
Knowing that there were no ads asking for interested applicants for next season pretty much means this is the end of the show.
Was a bit annoyed my internet was down during the finale so couldn’t follow the live blog. Personally, the pretending that the houses all auctioned on one night doesn’t bother me given that all reality tv competition shows don’t match real time – (The Renovators was filming before Easter and only stopped two weeks ago at the auctions). The disappointment on all the final keyholders’ faces was understandable. Given that the real estate agents talked up the value of the homes to such an extent, some of the contestants did fall for the spiel. I don’t blame them for that as it would be tempting to know that after 6-9 months of being away from family, maybe a big windfall would make the sacrifice all worth it. It was obvious Melissa and Natalia were banking on the real estate agents’ expectations matching the reality of what people will pay at a rushed auction. I thought it was insightful to have that property person, Chris, there as his thoughts prior to the auction as to what the people would pay proved pretty accurate – (no doubt it helps to shake down and grill the registered bidders prior to the auction).
Still, I think what gets me down is how damn expensive housing is in Australia and that those wanting to get into the market are being priced out. Of the six bidders, I only got the feeling that the bidder for the Fibro Cottage intended to live in it as his first home. Even then, it looked like he got on the phone to his dad to make sure his dad was still able to remortgage the family home to help him out with the loan. Renocrazy posted on a previous thread that she thought a major variable to be decided in auctions is how much bankers are prepared to lend. Gone are the days of those 110% loans, yet prices are still so expensive that most young people can’t afford to save up for a decent deposit on their own to buy their first homes. What is sad is that the contestants on The Renovators genuinely wanted to renovate a place for people to live in and call a home, not a rental property.
Hi Brandy, there was a lot of discussion on this forum about Peter’s step. So Renocrazy’s comments imply that Peter tripped over his own words, and literally tripped off that contraversial step in the living room….
Renocrazy- more goss please!
The Sydney Morning Herald and MolksTV are both still saying that it’s coming back next year so I’m holding out hope for it. They will need to really shake up the format though, like between Masterchef S1 and S2, because there are just too many parts of this season that appeared unfair and didn’t work. If they have packed up the warehouse that might be a good thing because I think the sheer number of offsite challenges was one of the things that didn’t work, the Friday masterclasses did work for me but they could do that in a smaller space.
JsTAR agree with you. My husband and I were frustrated at how expensive prices are in terms of the lack of quality stock here in homogenous Canberra.
Peter’s house the Glebe terrace etc. So more interesting than the monocrete ex-govies that they sell here for 750k that require either a knock-down (add 400k for a new build at least) or 200k in making liveable. If the producers of Renovators or Block were to buy up here in the ACT, it would only show the rest of the country what over-priced low quality run-downs people here are willing to buy. I guess our high on average incomes and steady jobs (public service) buy into this idea of a homogenous ponzi scheme that is the ACT real estate market.
To give you an idea- half of Ainslie, O’Connor, Turner etc are made up of ugly fibro-homes/ monocrete ex-govies that you would expect to see in Blacktown, that need some serious TLC/ renovating/ knocking down, yet the entry price is about 700-800k. Going to Woden or Belconnen and you’re looking at about 600k. I know single Gen Y’s on about 75k taking on 700k mortgages just to be 5 minutes closer to a trendy cafe, which they then can’t afford to go to, which then changes the culture of that local shop/ community. If you’re in Sydney- just refer to Leichardt and how dead Norton St is these days bc everyone who loved the restaurant culture there moved in, and it’s either the high replayments on your first home, or going out to dinner.
On a brighter note, and as contrary as it seems- it’s very exciting that the most deserving house won. Yay Blue team. That you can be creative with fibro shacks. And the face on that buyer when it was dawing on him that he was about to enter the elusive property market! Good on him- good on his folks for helping him out.
It was a just victory, and we always like just victories.
And that having a house in the right/ trendy suburb doesn’t entitle you to victory (the Glebe house). Neither does being a key-holder (Natalia and Mel). Or being tunnel-visioned with your ideal target-market and over-styling (Peter)- though I think the auctioneer stuffed up from a sales perspective and panicked during the opeining pregnant pause part of the auction. As a sales person (in IT), the mandatory pregnant pause phase in any negotitation can make or break the deal, and he just stuffed up.
Saw this at an auction a few months back, where the agent suffered a temporary moment of nervousness (it’s seriously a moment)- not sure whether he was discratcted, lost his confidence bearings or what, but someone screamed out 550 as a starting price, someone else screamed out 450k (we all looked at the low bidder as ‘are you kidding” thinking it was a joke and that the auctioneer would make some witty comment to that low bidder and start at 550, but nooo, he stuttered and accepeted it!).
It was passed in at 480. I spoke to other people at the auction, and they were surprise too, as they were all told during the inspections that it should fetch 690-710. So the agent was either doing a dodgy and over-pricing expectations, or he suffered from a bad moment of lack of confidence. Well….
It sold for 700 about a month later by another real estate agent. If I were the vendor I would have aksed my $$ back for marketing costs and wasting my time with that auction from the initial real-estate agent. So last night when I saw a similar thing with the auctioneer I looked at my hubby and said “oooh, did you see that- The JM effect it’ll stop at 730k!!!” (initals of the agent here in da berra).
I loved this show and despite the rather complex structure of the series I thought the production levels were really high for an Australian show. It left Top Design for dead. Which has to be one of the worst design shows ever! The American version was fantastic…but they didnt have Jamie Dreary ruining every scene….god hes a dick!
Anyway go channel 10 i hope you give renovators another go…be it a revised, streamlined version.
Also loved Brendans hosting. Having met him a couple of times I can say he really is a very charming man.
I watched last night only. That lead host is so creepy, blech. Should I feel sorry for these schmucks? All the time and effort and lost wages. Dunno. $25mil cost apparently and less than 1mill viewers per ep. Perhaps it should be become part of the Biggest Loser franchise.
I actually enjoyed the series – more so before that silly Qld visit. One big issue for me was the lopsided eliminations. If they must do eliminations – do regular elimination weeks so the teams can budget/schedule properly and are fairer in the challenges. Have one member from each team go home at the same time.
There was an element of randomness & unfairness when houses were picked. I wonder what the outcome would have been had the teams been able to research & buy the houses themselves – it would have been interesting to watch the process & decision making process.
Agree PollyB, Brendan was annoying as hell last night. While the auctions were on, I just kept yelling for him to shut up with all his comments. I know everyone was nervous, and he was trying to be positive and encouraging, but I found it immensely irritating to watch. Though that might have been because I’d already been spoilt and knew the results. I suppose the keyholder would not have noticed. And the whole thing about the important thing is they sold… really, would we have had the situation where one would be passed in?
There felt something wrong about rounding it up to $100K, as someone mentioned upthread. It was just throwing money at him, and considering 3 houses made losses which weren’t taken into account, it didn’t feel right. Nothing against Mikey, as he’s fabulous and without the fibro’s $68K profit, the prizemoney would have been embarrassingly small, but after the other results, suddenly $5k feels like a lot.
Also, I did like seeing the different demographics of the buyers and the neighbours – as a Sydney person, it made it interesting to watch, so I’m glad it wasn’t all in one location like the Block.
And why did Natalia have to have another go at Nathan in her piece last night?!
Rose by another name – I didn’t realise Canberra was so expensive. But then your point of public servants is taken and it now makes sense. Still, quite unaffordable for those on an average income. I note The Block will be held in Melbourne again in the inner city suburbs. Any takers for another passed-in auction result?
And I think you have an excellent point about the auctioneer. Definitely got that “deer-in-the-headlights” during all auctions, particularly Peter’s. (Was that a tumbleweed blowing in the background during the first twenty seconds of silence at the half-done house auction?). I felt there was a lot of panic with the auctioneers: the strongarm tactic of closing in on the registered bidders for a “whisper” in the ear was testament to that. I, myself, don’t mind Brendan as a host. But he definitely panicked a bit when it dawned on him that the auctions weren’t going to plan. He was really hanging on every drawn out bid during Natalia’s auction.
I hope the show comes back next year. A lot of us have commented on the flaws and the potential for this show if they were fixed. I wouldn’t particularly mind if all 4 judges had more say on the format. I don’t believe Peter Ho would have been comfortable with all that waste. Baz definitely had more to offer and Robyn at times was almost an afterthought. I just got the feeling during the season that all four judges were being held back by the producers because “the producers” knows best. The show scored 1.2 million nationwide last night. Not even close to The Block or MasterChef, but much better than what it had been averaging all season. Hopefully these producers got a nice pink slip to go with my foot towards their posteriors when they rocked up to work this morning.
I thought those prices were fairly cheap – but I am from Canberra too… They should do a series down here – although the initial purchases would cost them a bomb.
I liked the series. I like the hosts. I liked the white room challenges.
Not sure on the team and key holder concepts. Perhaps they need some prizes on the way through – like holidays etc, to make it worth the contestant’s while.
Perhaps they could decorate hotel rooms – less waste then, and tey can go crazy,m instead of beige-a rama.
The production company of Shine belongs to Elizabeth (I think it is) Murdoch. Her brother runs ten now. So whenever you turn the tv on, there’s a Murdoch (as in family of Rupert Murdoch, media baron etc) with their finger in the pie. My least favourite is Sarah Murdoch, married to the geezer running or in a top job at Ten. Is it James?? Are all sons of media moguls called James? I don’t see Shine’s takeover of previously ok productions ending any time soon. Hate what they’ve done to Australia’s Next Top Model, and can’t stand Sarah O’Hare/Murdoch while I’m venting either. Shine are set to take back production of Masterfulcrap next season. High 5!
Absolutely priceless!
Loved the look on Peter’s face when his house sold for exactly what it was worth (a bit high really, considering the flaws) The rest of the Auctions made me feel a bit sick, they were almost all so disappointed.
How many times did they blame it on the market? What fortunate timing having this final aired on the night of the carbon vote, it made them sound like they knew what they were talking about. Well done Channel 10, you finally scheduled one thing right.
As mentioned on the live thread, the Castle Hill house was designed for totally the wrong demographic – why didn’t the RE “guru” pick up on that earlier ? Where were the RE Agents who came in from time to time (snippets shown of lots of visits to other houses, did they give poor advice or was the advice ignored?
Also thinking back I think they also had the wrong demographic for the WB house in Parra – it needed a totally different pallet that drew inspiration from india & the middle east rather than the colour du jour (some variation of Hogs Bristle) on the walls.
I have looked at a lot of “renovated” houses over the last 3 months on the Central Coast – and they were al hogs bristle or similar
I quite like Hogs Bristle. It features throughout my place.
Get your drift though, Diogenes.
I am still chuckling over the look on Natalia’s face at the auction. Shit happens Nat. I used to like her and dare I say feel sorry for her with August and Christie but moving to khaki showed her true colours.
My 3 favorite eps were the friday masterclasses where judges went to each house and worked with team on problems. Perhaps this could be used some how in a new you beaut season. Sorry won’t hold my breath.
Yeah Nanliz I like those 3 eipsodes as well. It gave the judges a chance to mentor the renovators.
I really hope the show returns.
Brandy, I couldn’t agree more. I get a good laugh whenever the ad is on for Vaalia with Sarah Murdoch prancing around so ‘carefree’- I’ve never seen anything so awkward in my life.
Anyway, about the Renovators- what struck me most was this ‘incredibly tough market’ stuff. I live in Melbourne, so I’m not up with the market in sydney (nor do I know a lot about real estate). What I guess I’m wondering from any Sydney-ites is to what extent the sales last night (or, in reality, several weeks ago) reflected the market, vs reflecting other factors- such as poor marketing, poor renos (in some cases), the fact that the houses were on reality tv and therefore buyers had seen all the flaws (I wouldn’t want to buy one) etc etc. I think some have covered this a bit above, but I’d love someone to give an idea of whether the market is really THAT bad??
I note that the three houses that made profits were renovated MAINLY by the most competent and actually qualified builder-types ie Keenan (Weatherboard), Luke (inner city) and Michael (Fibro). Definitely factored, in my opinion- these are the houses I would have the most faith in the building work and that you are not going to have to tear something out in a few weeks because of hidden issues/shoddy work.
I was a fan of The Block (other than the lengthy recaps and “coming up next” parts and of course each and every single “challenge” episode), but I just couldn’t get into The Renovators.
I wanted to see them renovating the houses, not wasting time and MONEY renovating “fake” rooms in a warehouse. I think they had a couple of “real” challenges where they made over rooms in “real” houses (including some properties that were damaged by the floods in Queensland), but I had stopped watching by that time.
I did tune in for one challenge to design children’s bedrooms and it seemed to be something that would have worked better if the challenge was actually in a “real” house or in one of the houses that were being renovated. Maybe choose some kids who were battling an illness or something? Sure it would be harder to juggle the filming, etc of challenges involving “real” rooms, but the rewards seem much greater.
I just don’t understand the appeal of spending all that time and money on a “fake” room that is then torn down for the next challenge. Almost every episode was like the terrible “elimination” episodes that started off The Block and which were also a waste of time and money.
Renocrazy I don’t think weatherboard is actually up for sale. It’s the same link as the one before the auctions. It also mentions auction. They just haven’t taken it down. You can still go to the half done house page too.
flaws and all, I still liked it better than the Block…..so please, a tweaked version for next year ?!?!?!
With all opinions, with all recommendations around producing a better Renovators Show, I do hope the beige folk over at The Block don’t steal a great idea that needed to go through teething issues and have it as their own.
Hint Shine/ lizzy murdoch/ ch 10. There is enough cry for a fine-tuned version. Don’t let the folks at 9 or 7 grab it from you. As I suggested during the Michael live chat today, this sh
I want it back too….kicked butt over The Block and Top Design. Not sure how they will tweak it but I agree that it was a bit of a mess this year, took ages to work out the structure of the show with the different challenges, teams, key holders and very little actual renovation going on…but I still loved it. I loved the challenges at the warehouse but do think that we needed to see more of what was going on at ther actual houses. I would have loved to see a bit more ‘behind the scenes’ stuff too so we could get to know the contestants and their relationships…I was fascinated by the way Jason and August seemed to drive everyone crazy and I wanted to know more. I’m rambling because it’s late….bring it back next year, season two is always better than season one!!
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/entertainment/tv-radio/all-work-and-no-pay-for-victorian-duo-in-the-renovators-finale/story-e6frf9ho-1226165000239
Well it seems that they finally got respectable ratings and they might do second series.
http://www.mediaspy.org/report/2011/10/13/ratings-renovators-auction-finale-tops-wednesday-night/
Fab news Emma! Oh am going to miss secretly reading this thread. So many of us have come out of the woodwork (:)). Thanks a RR and rencrazy!!
Watching bad Colombian film. Why do baby-boomer Latino menhave to be such stereotypes! Grrh. But why am I watching such a bad film! Missing the renovators already.
There goes my secret tradition over the last 3 months. From BBC world service radio to overcome hubby’s snoring, to reading this thread and then listening to Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. Seriously makes you go to sleep after 10 mns. Archive.org have best collection of old digitalised archive.
Listening to old time radio serials (on ur I-device) will be all the rage in next cple of years.
Good night secret amigos! Seriously listen to Johnny dollar- at insurance investigations he’s great, but at cooking the books he’s a gEnius!
The primary advantage of this show over The Block was the lack of:-
– the appallingly lame Scott Cam and Shelley Tweety Bird; and,
– the constant repetitive editing that assumed we the audience have goldfish-like attention spans and the combined reasoning skills of Troy and Mackenzie from Beauty and the Geek.
I would be willing to give The Renovators another go on the proviso that they:-
– reduce the length of the season (why do these shows have to run as long as the NRL/AFL/NFL seasons? Ma$terChef has a lot to answer for in this regard)
– develop a clear set of competition rules and a consistent format for challenges and stick to it (if you look at shows like Top Chef you can see how to introduce drama and variety into challenges having to move the goal posts all the time)
– cut the lame, ‘community interest’ crap like the trip to Qld (if the producers want to feel good about their jobs then I suggest they ditch the Xmas piss-up this year – they didn’t earn in anyway – and donate the money saved to charity)
– focus challenges on rewarding – and showing – renovation skills (rather than half-arsed ‘artistic’ challenges, colour matching of cushions or murdering plants in ‘vertical gardens’)
– limit the use of the white room challenges (these were more often than not a waste of contestant sweat, material resources and viewer time)
– introduce more arsehole/egotistical contestants into the mix (every form of entertainment – films, theatre, footy – is better if there’s someone to hate and boo)
– properly research the property market and identify properties that have a shitload of difficult problems to solve, so that most of the action can focus on the renovation
– sort out DA and engineering approval local government stuff prior to starting the show (there’s no interest in watching people sit around moaning about red-tape delays, most of us get to do that at work)
– Oh, and as suggested by numerous others here, ditch Freedom and allow more creativity if they must persist with decorating the houses prior to sale
A properly focussed series with an 6-week run to get the renovations completed primarily through contestant labour (except for tasks that have statutory restrictions or in which they could kill themselves) would be the way to go I reckon
All the posts for the finale are really great! Over the weeks, I really enjoyed reading all the comments in this blog. Great observations and really good appreciations and contrasts to the realities that we experience everyday. I would definitely most miss checking the comments after every episode, here, and sometimes writing about it. I don’t really watch reality shows so can’t follow up the other discussions.
Culinary Boner you came up with great pointers there! I hope the producers get to check the blog. Hope they are the kind of people open to ideas of improvement (perhaps that is hoping too much)!
Australian property market seems to be getting exhausted. House prices in Australia are the highest of any English speaking country relative to income (according to ABC). Yep, investors are speculating for a bursting bubble sometime soon (hopefully not!). Canberra definitely has the highest or the second highest house prices in Australia (Mining boom city, Perth, is one of the top if not the top). Canberra’s Public sector superficial wage minimum versus Perth’s excessive, perhaps, mining exports are definitely having effects in the local economies reflected in the house prices (perhaps that mining tax would have been convenient to slow down the latter effect on the whole economy).
Would definitely be great to see another Renovators with lots of improvements, less waste, more on real renovations, fairness instead of favoritism, less editing and more reality.
Some of things that caught my attention in the finale were:
1. Melissa’s comments (Peter’s house for homosexuals ? Fibro the ‘castle’ of blacktown -found it a bit offensive-? and others).
2. The only bidder for the shop starting at $700k.
3. Luke expecting too much for a house that did not have a car park and with streets parking restrictions. No one having a $1million would pay that much for a house without parking. Expecting for someone to have a million and not a car will be rather silly. I think with all the renovations, and looking at the market in the area the price it went for it was quite good (but yes, it could have been a ‘bit’ better no more).
4. The flat ending without asking questions on what from there on…
A little late but thought some of you might be interested- just came across this in a ‘live blog’ with Michael (the winner) which was held at some point after the finale (from http://www.heraldsun.com.au/entertainment/tv-radio/all-work-and-no-pay-for-victorian-duo-in-the-renovators-finale/story-e6frf9ho-1226165000239):
Comment From Michelle B
Well done Michael….job well done. But will you be sharing a piece of the profit with Jarrod ?
From Michael:
Hi Michelle, I did plan to but because the prize money wasn’t as much as expected there really isn’t a lot to go around.
Personally, I’ve not been one of those saying that Michael definitely should share the money since I guess that was the point of the show (winner takes all) but I was surprised that he considers the prize money inadequate to share some with Jarrad…
He could at least shout him a haircut
I guess when you consider how much time out of their lives the show took, and what their expectations probably were, based on all the crapola coming out of the procuders/presenters moths- they probably were expecting waaay more. Having said that, it would have been nice if he could have made some gesture to Jarrod- not sure what tho…. (apart from the haircut, lol
)
A lot of these shows have a “no sharing the prize money” clause in them. I guess it’s to prevent alliances in shows etc. Renovators MAY have had it in their clause and maybe Michael was trying to tactfully answer the question without actually revealing contract details.
very good point smauge- hadn’t even considered that, but a clause to prevent alliances is highly likely isn’t it?
if so, then I think Michael is in an awkward position- the public expects him to make some sort of gesture to Jarrod, yet possibly his contract prevents this…. :).
It would restore my belief in Michael if this is indeed the case!!! I still like him (as a person lol) but the lack of gesture to Jarrod has been a little disheartening….
Not everyone. I don’t get at all why people expect him to give away some of his money to Jarrod. It was a comp, Michael won. I don’t think Jarrod expects him to. I’m not sure he’d have given Michael any if he’d won.
1. those houses were fabulous! They were worth much more than what they were sold to.
2. The profit point must be calculated considering the money won during the challenges too!
3. It has been stupid to have told all Australia how much money they were spending! this is not how it works in the real world! this way none can ever make money selling houses! absurd….
4. i hope there’s going to be a second season, but with more teaching and less “repeating already seen images”.
Wow, this post is good, my younger sister is analyzing these
kinds of things, so I am going to tell her.